![]() |
Vinyl Asylum Welcome Licorice Pizza (LP) lovers! Setup guides and Vinyl FAQ. |
|
In Reply to: Re: SME 3009 measurement question (picture) posted by John Elison on November 13, 2006 at 10:16:39:
alignment. With enought built in adjustments (ofset angle, effective length and pivot distance) you can align the arm-cart combination to any alignment you want. I need to go to the local library for a copy of Baerwald's original paper. Does anyone have the references for the Stephenson andLoefgren papers. From what I read Baerwald tried to minimise the % tracking distortion curve. It is not intuitively obviouls to me that is best. It will be interesting to read his paper.
I found this on the web but did not send myself the reference, could have been from the Vinyl Engine."A 1941 paper in the /Journal of the Society of Motion Picture Engineers/ by the American engineer H. G. Baerwald worked out the conditions for optimal conventional tonearm design; one important thing to note is that it needs to be taken into account that the effects of tracking error are more serious for the inner grooves of the record, since the undulations in the groove representing the sound waves are closer together there. One approximation that can be used is to weight tracking error by the reciprocal of distance from the spindle.
An earlier paper by Erik Löfgren, cited in Baerwald's paper, proposed two alignments, the first being the same one as recommended in the paper by Baerwald which analyzed the question of tonearm design more thoroughly. Because there are additional problems with reproduction of the inner grooves of the record, in addition to the effects of tracking error being more severe there, a paper by Stephenson proposed a third arrangment more heavily favoring the inner grooves. And the turntable manufacturer Thorens has pursued an alignment standard of its own.
Jim N
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- How or why would anyone design an arm for a specific - jnorv 11/13/0610:46:14 11/13/06 (40)
- Re: How or why would anyone design an arm for a specific - JoeLip 21:03:31 11/14/06 (0)
- Name all the tonearms other than Schröder that are NOT designed for a specific alignment.... - John Elison 12:17:14 11/13/06 (5)
- That's a question that's been bugging me for - kavakidd 14:19:38 11/13/06 (3)
- It's called "adjustment". - Garth 23:03:51 11/13/06 (2)
- Why then - is there not a standard - kavakidd 06:45:03 11/14/06 (1)
- Why don't we all drive Model Ts or a VW Bug? - Garth 07:22:25 11/14/06 (0)
- The Black Widow used the SME mounting - jnorv 12:49:19 11/13/06 (0)
- In this case ... - Garth 11:08:21 11/13/06 (32)
- More newb questions... - Kiwi Brian 02:26:10 11/14/06 (21)
- Re: More newb questions... - jnorv 06:20:41 11/14/06 (18)
- Actually there are four unknowns. - Garth 07:36:10 11/14/06 (15)
- I don't thinik so - jnorv 20:17:12 11/14/06 (14)
- Yes, but for a given linear offset. - Garth 20:33:47 11/14/06 (13)
- Re: Yes, but for a given linear offset. - John Elison 05:17:34 11/15/06 (12)
- Yes, I meant as a design parameter. - Garth 07:18:35 11/15/06 (11)
- At least for the Baerwald alignment - jnorv 15:41:44 11/15/06 (8)
- It is true of ANY null points one chooses - Garth 20:37:32 11/15/06 (6)
- It has been a while since I took Variational Calculas - jnorv 09:10:18 11/16/06 (5)
- See, change the null points and you change at least the effecive length. - Garth 11:51:51 11/16/06 (4)
- For Baerwald's difinition of minimum distortion - jnorv 16:42:29 11/16/06 (3)
- Re: For Baerwald's difinition of minimum distortion - John Elison 21:01:38 11/16/06 (2)
- True, but obviously they are no different in terms of ... - Garth 22:15:14 11/16/06 (1)
- Re: True, but obviously they are no different in terms of ... - John Elison 15:39:20 11/17/06 (0)
- Re: At least for the Baerwald alignment - John Elison 19:45:04 11/15/06 (0)
- Re: Yes, I meant as a design parameter. - John Elison 08:42:48 11/15/06 (1)
- So what? - Garth 09:09:00 11/15/06 (0)
- The best tonearm.... - John Elison 06:47:24 11/14/06 (1)
- Yes, that's why they are so popular. (nt) - Garth 07:48:27 11/14/06 (0)
- Re: More newb questions... - Garth 04:51:13 11/14/06 (1)
- Thanks Garth - Kiwi Brian 02:38:10 11/15/06 (0)
- Re: In this case ... - John Elison 11:58:41 11/13/06 (9)
- My listening tests and feedback from others tell us differently. - Garth 13:38:50 11/13/06 (8)
- Here is something you might find interesting... - John Elison 06:34:49 11/14/06 (4)
- Yes, that was his, Loefgren's theory - Garth 07:04:58 11/14/06 (3)
- Not exactly.... - John Elison 09:27:57 11/14/06 (2)
- Actually all three methods are correct. - Garth 09:46:36 11/14/06 (1)
- Well, all three methods are different; that's for certain. ;-) (nt) - John Elison 09:55:54 11/14/06 (0)
- Löfgren "B" and Stevenson "1B" are very different.... - John Elison 15:45:35 11/13/06 (2)
- For those particular parameters - jnorv 17:56:45 11/13/06 (1)
- Actually, if you mount a Rega arm at about 220.5-mm.... - John Elison 18:20:18 11/13/06 (0)