Vinyl Asylum Welcome Licorice Pizza (LP) lovers! Setup guides and Vinyl FAQ. |
|
In Reply to: MY CONCLUSIONS posted by MusicLover on September 22, 2005 at 07:42:46:
I'll wear a blindfold and I want you to convince me with purely technical reasons.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups Full ThreadTopic - CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - MusicLover 08:53:33 09/21/05 (156)
- Why waste time? - Toddd 12:46:33 09/22/05 (4)
- Re: Why waste time? - MusicLover 13:47:01 09/22/05 (3)
- Not true - rand 14:52:36 09/22/05 (2)
- Re: Not true - Bry 18:52:37 09/22/05 (1)
- Re: Not true - MusicLover 06:07:58 09/23/05 (0)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - John Diamantis 10:54:14 09/22/05 (5)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - MusicLover 11:52:46 09/22/05 (4)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - John Diamantis 12:39:46 09/22/05 (3)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - MusicLover 13:54:53 09/22/05 (2)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - John Diamantis 10:08:31 09/23/05 (1)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - KyleCoppers 12:52:16 09/23/05 (0)
- The REAL reason we find analog superior - bangsezmax 09:44:22 09/22/05 (2)
- Re: The REAL reason we find analog superior - MusicLover 11:54:57 09/22/05 (1)
- So you do agree that mastering plays a big part? - KyleCoppers 12:39:32 09/23/05 (0)
- Depends. Vinyl can sound best a lot of the time... - vocalion 07:56:44 09/22/05 (0)
- MY CONCLUSIONS - MusicLover 07:42:46 09/22/05 (17)
- CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why 35mm film is better then digital video? - Queg 09/22/0511:44:04 09/22/05 (3)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why 35mm film is better then digital video? - MusicLOver 12:01:50 09/22/05 (2)
- Here is why this thread is irrelevant - rand 15:01:51 09/22/05 (1)
- Re: Here is why this thread is irrelevant - Stephen Murphy 21:26:27 09/22/05 (0)
- YOu are such a silly boy. You still haven't gone and HEARD vinyl. - Chet 10:27:13 09/22/05 (2)
- Re: YOu are such a silly boy. You still haven't gone and HEARD vinyl. - MusicLover 11:56:55 09/22/05 (1)
- Re: YOu are such a silly boy. You still haven't gone and HEARD vinyl. - StylinLP 12:23:23 09/22/05 (0)
- Yay!!! We're done! - Bry 08:42:58 09/22/05 (1)
- Re: Yay!!! We're done! - MusicLover 09:30:04 09/22/05 (0)
- I think your conclusions are a bit thin...like the sound of a CD! - tubesforever 08:32:27 09/22/05 (3)
- Re: I think your conclusions are a bit thin...like the sound of a CD! - MusicLover 09:32:47 09/22/05 (2)
- I must be a glutton for punishment, but... - rand 15:12:37 09/22/05 (1)
- Re: I must be a glutton for punishment, but... - MusicLover 06:09:52 09/23/05 (0)
- Re: MY CONCLUSIONS - mothra 08:30:03 09/22/05 (3)
- Re: MY CONCLUSIONS - MusicLover 09:34:03 09/22/05 (2)
- Re: MY CONCLUSIONS - mothra 09:45:03 09/22/05 (0)
- Re: MY CONCLUSIONS - bangsezmax 09:38:01 09/22/05 (0)
- The correct approach IMHO. - Bry 07:24:06 09/22/05 (0)
- Here is a musician's explanation. - tubesforever 23:57:33 09/21/05 (4)
- Re: Here is a musician's explanation. - MusicLover 06:37:33 09/22/05 (3)
- CD quietness is very flawed from the very start! - tubesforever 08:13:28 09/22/05 (0)
- This is like a game show. - Bry 06:46:59 09/22/05 (1)
- LOL! The Quizmaster has spoken. nt - Stephen Murphy 08:37:40 09/22/05 (0)
- Can someone explain to me why I should upgrade from my beloved 78's???? - tubesforever 23:43:53 09/21/05 (0)
- I played this same game: I wanted *any* excuse to believe my CDs didn't sound as bad as they did when I upgraded. (nt) - jdaniel 22:31:32 09/21/05 (0)
- Mastering, plain and simple. - KyleCoppers 21:48:47 09/21/05 (6)
- Re: Mastering, plain and simple. - MusicLover 06:39:23 09/22/05 (4)
- Modern CD mastering techniques leave a lot to be desired, IMHO. - KyleCoppers 08:27:29 09/23/05 (0)
- I think you need a checkup from the neck up.... - tubesforever 08:39:39 09/22/05 (1)
- Re: I think you need a checkup from the neck up.... - MusicLover 11:59:59 09/22/05 (0)
- Re: Mastering, plain and simple. - Krisbee 07:20:28 09/22/05 (0)
- Re: Mastering, plain and simple. - scorpions113 23:59:09 09/21/05 (0)
- riddle me this - scorpions113 21:39:12 09/21/05 (4)
- and by the way - mothra 08:27:30 09/22/05 (0)
- Re: riddle me this - MusicLover 06:45:51 09/22/05 (2)
- Re: riddle me this - scorpions113 10:24:11 09/22/05 (1)
- Re: riddle me this - MusicLover 13:37:12 09/22/05 (0)
- Can you say, "GOTCHA!! Hello, Troll Patrol?" - Phil_in_CA 21:24:53 09/21/05 (2)
- Re: Can you say, "GOTCHA!! Hello, Troll Patrol?" - scorpions113 21:45:02 09/21/05 (1)
- Re: Can you say, "GOTCHA!! Hello, Troll Patrol?" - Phil_in_CA 16:17:40 09/22/05 (0)
- please go HERE - hifitommy 20:31:31 09/21/05 (0)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - dadbar 19:43:00 09/21/05 (8)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - MusicLover 06:49:00 09/22/05 (0)
- Wow! All the CDs I have from the early 80's sound just fine--much better now on modern CD players.... - John Elison 22:17:36 09/21/05 (6)
- Re: Wow! All the CDs I have from the early 80's sound just fine--much better now on modern CD players.... - dadbar 16:25:23 09/22/05 (1)
- Well, they play as well as ever. Actually, they play better than ever. :) (nt) - John Elison 20:34:07 09/22/05 (0)
- I've lost about 6 or 8... - Bry 03:41:12 09/22/05 (3)
- Re: I've lost about 6 or 8... - Arlekino 09:20:57 09/22/05 (0)
- Re: I've lost about 6 or 8... (picture) - Bry 04:06:57 09/22/05 (1)
- Interesting! Thanks! I'll recheck all mine. (nt) - John Elison 05:13:09 09/22/05 (0)
- It isn't....these people are nuts. Just ignore them..... - Marc Bratton 19:23:16 09/21/05 (1)
- Re: It isn't....these people are nuts. Just ignore them..... - MusicLOver 06:49:57 09/22/05 (0)
- Not going to get what your looking for dude.... - dBoon 18:33:48 09/21/05 (0)
- Ok, let's play point/counterpoint - rand 18:22:11 09/21/05 (1)
- Re: Ok, let's play point/counterpoint - MusicLover 06:51:40 09/22/05 (0)
- The only real scientific reason - IBSmiester 17:41:11 09/21/05 (4)
- Re: The only real scientific reason - MusicLover 06:58:13 09/22/05 (3)
- Re: The only real scientific reason - Krisbee 07:09:04 09/22/05 (2)
- Re: The only real scientific reason - MusicLover 07:46:00 09/22/05 (1)
- Re: The only real scientific reason - mothra 08:25:10 09/22/05 (0)
- Vinyl has less listener fatigue. - ancient tones 17:25:36 09/21/05 (1)
- Re: Vinyl has less listener fatigue. - Stephen Murphy 18:14:04 09/21/05 (0)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - AnalogJ 16:32:08 09/21/05 (1)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - MusicLOver 07:01:14 09/22/05 (0)
- Both formats are distortions of the event - pick your poison - Queg 15:37:30 09/21/05 (0)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - Arlekino 13:41:26 09/21/05 (1)
- Yes, I confess. I got goose pimples picking up lps my library got out of their archives for me - Chet 22:06:16 09/21/05 (0)
- ask an intelligent question - mothra 13:14:54 09/21/05 (2)
- Re: ask an intelligent question - MusicLover 07:03:17 09/22/05 (1)
- Re: ask an intelligent question - mothra 08:21:47 09/22/05 (0)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - EdAInWestOC 12:55:39 09/21/05 (3)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - MusicLover 07:06:30 09/22/05 (2)
- If I understand the Nyquist Shannon theorem correctly... - EdAInWestOC 12:23:50 09/22/05 (0)
- I am. Bunch of meanless hogwash *nt* - StylinLP 11:32:24 09/22/05 (0)
- because they sound way better - fewf 12:26:22 09/21/05 (0)
- Someone please convince me to switch to 8-track. (nt) - Bry 12:22:54 09/21/05 (3)
- Cheaper software compared to "expensive" used records? [nt] - daviddeep 14:17:40 09/21/05 (0)
- No way man, not after... - KT88 13:02:08 09/21/05 (1)
- That reminds me... - Bry 07:00:46 09/22/05 (0)
- RFI..... - Todd Krieger 12:20:52 09/21/05 (1)
- Re: RFI..... - MusicLover 07:10:21 09/22/05 (0)
- Why should we want to convince YOU?...... - Ozzy 12:14:48 09/21/05 (0)
- Not proof but ... - garth 12:11:31 09/21/05 (0)
- No convicing to be found here, git out and listen fer yerself. (nt) - Spun1 11:46:06 09/21/05 (1)
- LOL. A true ambassador! nt - Ray-o-Stat 11:51:20 09/21/05 (0)
- What "challenge?" RBCD is just as good as vinyl as a rercording method. Very likely better. - jsm 11:38:53 09/21/05 (3)
- Old vs new - StylinLP 11:07:54 09/22/05 (0)
- Re: What "challenge?" RBCD is just as good as vinyl as a rercording method. Very likely better. - MusicLover 07:12:57 09/22/05 (0)
- Great Post! ...I'm glad someone tackled the software side of the equation :-) nt - Ray-o-Stat 11:43:40 09/21/05 (0)
- ..I can hear the Cussin' already, but here goes..... - Ray-o-Stat 11:22:40 09/21/05 (9)
- Re: ..I can hear the Cussin' already, but here goes..... - MusicLover 07:17:05 09/22/05 (0)
- jitter has the same effect as ... - csero 11:40:56 09/21/05 (6)
- True, but to my ears, the audible manifestation is more akin to mis-tracking, IMHO ... - Ray-o-Stat 11:49:56 09/21/05 (5)
- Re: True, but to my ears, the audible manifestation is more akin to mis-tracking, IMHO ... - MusicLover 07:18:41 09/22/05 (4)
- Re: True, but to my ears, the audible manifestation is more akin to mis-tracking, IMHO ... - Ray-o-Stat 09:15:51 09/22/05 (3)
- Re: True, but to my ears, the audible manifestation is more akin to mis-tracking, IMHO ... - StylinLP 10:54:49 09/22/05 (2)
- Re: True, but to my ears, the audible manifestation is more akin to mis-tracking, IMHO ... - MusicLover 13:59:25 09/22/05 (1)
- Re: True, but to my ears, the audible manifestation is more akin to mis-tracking, IMHO ... - StylinLP 14:34:19 09/22/05 (0)
- Geez, I should have previewed and checked my typing! oh well :-) nt - Ray-o-Stat 11:25:45 09/21/05 (0)
- CD's are much better than vinyl.... - cjfrbw 11:13:19 09/21/05 (0)
- Why not just read the responses you got to the same question you asked here a year ago? - Stephen Murphy 11:10:26 09/21/05 (9)
- Re: Why not just read the responses you got to the same question you asked here a year ago? - MusicLOver 07:20:03 09/22/05 (0)
- Re: Why not just read the responses you got to the same question you asked here a year ago? - Fred J 18:03:30 09/21/05 (4)
- Daaaaaang Fred! Thats answer blew me away lol *nt* - StylinLP 10:39:12 09/22/05 (0)
- Re: Why not just read the responses you got to the same question you asked here a year ago? - MusicLover 07:22:37 09/22/05 (0)
- Re: Why not just read the responses you got to the same question you asked here a year ago? - Stephen Murphy 21:33:26 09/21/05 (1)
- Re: Why not just read the responses you got to the same question you asked here a year ago? - Fred J 12:53:46 09/22/05 (0)
- Nice catch....(NT) - Ozzy 12:15:50 09/21/05 (0)
- Troll police? - Elmo 11:51:49 09/21/05 (1)
- LOL. Keeping the streets safe for the rest of us! nt - Stephen Murphy 13:53:37 09/21/05 (0)
- Digital is to videotape as vinyl is to film - Steve Culton 10:43:02 09/21/05 (2)
- Re: Digital is to videotape as vinyl is to film - MusicLover 07:25:11 09/22/05 (1)
- Re: Digital is to videotape as vinyl is to film - StylinLP 10:37:18 09/22/05 (0)
- Fe, Fi, Fo, Fum . . . I smell a troll. (plonk) /nt\ - HenryH 10:34:06 09/21/05 (0)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - Fred J 10:29:28 09/21/05 (6)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - MusicLover 07:33:55 09/22/05 (5)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - Fred J 13:45:24 09/22/05 (4)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - MusicLover 14:06:36 09/22/05 (3)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - Fred J 14:57:05 09/22/05 (0)
- Ummmm WHAT??? - StylinLP 14:43:31 09/22/05 (1)
- Re: Ummmm WHAT??? - MusicLover 06:13:32 09/23/05 (0)
- I'm preparing to be ignored... - slate1 10:28:47 09/21/05 (0)
- Be carefull, look be for you leap. - USA2Mexico0 10:09:53 09/21/05 (0)
- Tastes better. Less annoying. - Elmo 09:55:30 09/21/05 (0)
- There is no *must* - _canuck 09:48:45 09/21/05 (0)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - bangsezmax 09:43:02 09/21/05 (2)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - MusicLover 07:36:18 09/22/05 (0)
- And let me add . . . - bangsezmax 09:56:03 09/21/05 (0)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - Bruce from DC 09:42:39 09/21/05 (2)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - MusicLover 07:37:20 09/22/05 (0)
- Very nice post! - Steve Culton 10:45:13 09/21/05 (0)
- CHALLENGE: Go listen... - KT88 09:24:24 09/21/05 (0)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - StylinLP 09:18:28 09/21/05 (1)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - MusicLover 14:14:22 09/22/05 (0)
- If you can't hear it, don't bother. More used deals for the rest of us. nt - Jackaro 09:17:45 09/21/05 (0)
- This should keep you busy for a while (link) - Robert S. 09:12:32 09/21/05 (0)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why vinyl is better than redbook CD? - nbteddy@yahoo.com 09:01:03 09/21/05 (3)
- Who said you need thousands of $$?? I've heard $350-500 is enough to surpass the best CD players... - jdaniel 09:34:57 09/21/05 (2)
- I have 610 dollars in my table and three different cartridges....all which sound better than a CD!!! - tubesforever 00:07:48 09/22/05 (1)
- Re: I have 610 dollars in my table and three different cartridges....all which sound better than a CD!!! - MusicLover 07:48:00 09/22/05 (0)
- I have a 61 dollar table, a 550 dollar arm and three different cartridges that all sound better than CD by a wide margin - tubesforever 00:03:11 09/22/05 (0)
Follow Ups
- CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why 35mm film is better then digital video? - Queg 09/22/0511:44:04 09/22/05 (3)
- Re: CHALLENGE: Can someone please explain to me why 35mm film is better then digital video? - MusicLOver 12:01:50 09/22/05 (2)
- Here is why this thread is irrelevant - rand 15:01:51 09/22/05 (1)
- Re: Here is why this thread is irrelevant - Stephen Murphy 21:26:27 09/22/05 (0)