|
Vinyl Asylum Welcome Licorice Pizza (LP) lovers! Setup guides and Vinyl FAQ. |
|
|
|
Vinyl Asylum Welcome Licorice Pizza (LP) lovers! Setup guides and Vinyl FAQ. |
|
In Reply to: Re: So what? posted by Todd Krieger on August 13, 2005 at 00:04:09:
> > Provided the signal is periodic...And music signals are comprised of ever changing periodic waveforms. For as long as I can remember stereos have carried specifications indicating frequency responses as being between 20 and 20kz. A freguency is, last time I looked, a periodic signal
> > If the fundamental frequency of the signal is near the "Nyquist
> > frequency,"There may be some truth here, but given the limits of human hearing, and the realities of vinyl recordings (ie. - normally they don't have much hifrequency info) I find this argument somewhat of a strawman. Given the above realities there's no reason for me to think a well produced and mastered CD won't sound as good as an LP.
Like I said there's good arguments why some might prefer vinyl to digital - but I'm convinced that Nyquist is not one of them.
Give me rhythm or give me death!
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups Full ThreadTopic - Could I get a concise complete rundown on vinyl/analog superiority reguardless of equipment? - StylinLP 14:55:17 08/12/05 (153)
- So you can't simply hear differences and thereby decide? - paul_s 13:14:34 08/14/05 (0)
- Why would you want to talk to people who have no idea what vinyl is?! (nt) - Langdell 11:16:01 08/14/05 (2)
- Re: Why would you want to talk to people who have no idea what vinyl is?! (nt) - StylinLP 12:38:06 08/14/05 (1)
- I understand completely... - Bry 13:24:00 08/14/05 (0)
- There you have it! Was that concise enough? - hukkfinn 11:46:15 08/13/05 (2)
- Auuuuuurg!!!!!! Now I have a blank stare *grin* - StylinLP 11:15:47 08/14/05 (1)
- At least your plan B was to get drunk! :) (nt) - Bry 11:20:52 08/14/05 (0)
- Why? - Don T 10:23:29 08/13/05 (4)
- What is a "pre Redbook" CD? - garth 11:02:57 08/13/05 (3)
- I don't know if there were pre redbook CDs but there were pre Redbook Cds vinyl! - Don T 21:39:22 08/13/05 (1)
- You mean preCD digitally recorded LPs? Why ... - garth 09:24:05 08/14/05 (0)
- Redbook the magazine? :) (nt) - Bry 11:13:40 08/13/05 (0)
- KT88 gave you the answer - mt10425 04:36:17 08/13/05 (0)
- Really hard to get through the whole thread, but simply ..... Analog is music. Digital is sound. - Elmo 01:53:20 08/13/05 (0)
- Regardless of Equipment? Not Really.... - Todd Krieger 00:42:47 08/13/05 (4)
- My experience... - Bry 10:35:28 08/13/05 (3)
- Re: My experience... - Todd Krieger 12:18:59 08/13/05 (2)
- Re: My experience... - Bry 12:34:36 08/13/05 (1)
- Re: My experience... - Todd Krieger 14:12:56 08/13/05 (0)
- Re: The only way you will convince your friends id to have them over to hear you vinyl rig. - SirAnthony 00:21:43 08/13/05 (0)
- Re: Could I get a concise complete rundown on vinyl/analog superiority reguardless of equipment? - RGA 00:01:00 08/13/05 (0)
- No - JeffH 22:18:24 08/12/05 (0)
- who would win in a fight? (it would be a LONG fight) - stark 20:58:18 08/12/05 (0)
- Re: Could I get a concise complete rundown on vinyl/analog superiority reguardless of equipment? - MusicHead 2 20:35:58 08/12/05 (0)
- RThere are very definite objective and quantitative reasons - Pauly 19:20:34 08/12/05 (0)
- I think it's funny... - Bry 19:01:44 08/12/05 (16)
- These guys listen to alot of new music-Thats the problem - StylinLP 20:06:43 08/12/05 (1)
- In this case, my point is.... - Peter Olofsson 03:40:09 08/13/05 (0)
- Speak for yourself - Pauly 19:25:00 08/12/05 (0)
- Victim of circumstance. There are few if any recordings being made that originate as analog. CD's now sound decent and.. - Ray-o-Stat 19:23:24 08/12/05 (9)
- I never said I was a victim of circumstance. - hukkfinn 08:08:02 08/14/05 (0)
- Records are regaining... - Bry 19:43:56 08/12/05 (7)
- Yeah but the quality isn't there... - Ray-o-Stat 20:01:17 08/12/05 (6)
- True....but.... - MattC 07:01:33 08/13/05 (3)
- but.... - Tetrack 10:59:44 08/13/05 (0)
- Yeah. That's the point I was trying to make in another post below regarding "potential". nt - Ray-o-Stat 07:46:48 08/13/05 (1)
- Re: Yeah. That's the point I was trying to make in another post below regarding "potential". nt - StylinLP 12:40:46 08/14/05 (0)
- Not always true - some artists still insist on - kavakidd 20:15:38 08/12/05 (0)
- True, there are exceptions, but then the quality of the pressings becomes a concern; in this forum, I have noted that... - Ray-o-Stat 08:03:08 08/13/05 (0)
- I'm not so sure. - Bry 20:13:54 08/12/05 (0)
- Makes you kind of wonder, doesn't it??? (nt) - John Elison 19:08:58 08/12/05 (2)
- So, should StylinLP just tell his friends he's insane? (nt) - Bry 20:00:11 08/12/05 (1)
- Well, when he spends this much time in an asylum, it might be the most logical thing to do. :) (nt) - John Elison 20:14:39 08/12/05 (0)
- Re: Could I get a concise complete rundown on vinyl/analog superiority reguardless of equipment? - magnetoman_2000 18:35:46 08/12/05 (1)
- I already answered this question *nt* - StylinLP 20:00:38 08/12/05 (0)
- I think you have missed the point of the debate... - Ray-o-Stat 18:08:48 08/12/05 (3)
- Re: I think you have missed the point of the debate... - StylinLP 19:59:05 08/12/05 (2)
- Re: I think you have missed the point of the debate... - Ray-o-Stat 20:11:25 08/12/05 (0)
- Re: I think you have missed the point of the debate... - Bry 20:04:40 08/12/05 (0)
- Re: Could I get a concise complete rundown on vinyl/analog superiority reguardless of equipment? - dBoon 18:01:07 08/12/05 (6)
- Re: Could I get a concise complete rundown on vinyl/analog superiority reguardless of equipment? - John Elison 18:34:47 08/12/05 (5)
- Re: Could I get a concise complete rundown on vinyl/analog superiority reguardless of equipment? - Fretless 18:52:23 08/12/05 (1)
- Re: Could I get a concise complete rundown on vinyl/analog superiority reguardless of equipment? - John Elison 18:55:19 08/12/05 (0)
- Re: Could I get a concise complete rundown on vinyl/analog superiority reguardless of equipment? - Bry 18:51:54 08/12/05 (2)
- I got rid of my two Dragons when I discovered DAT. :) (nt) - John Elison 18:56:36 08/12/05 (1)
- I can't remember the last time I used my cassette deck. :) (nt) - Bry 19:55:56 08/12/05 (0)
- brick walls, stochastic resonance…(long) - nosmok 17:28:06 08/12/05 (1)
- Impressive. You've touched some of the subjects I've heard - StylinLP 17:43:37 08/12/05 (0)
- "ilike what I like" "I live music" "I am in my happy place" "makes me feel good" "sounds like real music& - LesF 17:23:17 08/12/05 (7)
- Re: "ilike what I like" "I live music" "I am in my happy place" "makes me feel good" "sounds like real mu - Bry 17:31:53 08/12/05 (6)
- Those are all good reasons to like vinyl - LesF 17:52:41 08/12/05 (5)
- Spot on Les - Pauly 19:37:21 08/12/05 (4)
- Re: Spot on Les - LesF 21:07:16 08/14/05 (0)
- Re: Spot on Les - John Elison 19:45:20 08/12/05 (2)
- I flip LP's real fast John ;-) - Pauly 20:15:18 08/12/05 (1)
- You could put on 2 at once. ;) (nt) - Bry 20:20:48 08/12/05 (0)
- Re: Could I get a concise complete rundown on vinyl/analog superiority reguardless of equipment? - mothra 16:31:06 08/12/05 (6)
- I allways make the mistake of starting a conversation unprepared - StylinLP 16:40:32 08/12/05 (5)
- Re: I allways make the mistake of starting a conversation unprepared - John Elison 17:04:06 08/12/05 (4)
- Re: I allways make the mistake of starting a conversation unprepared - Bry 17:12:03 08/12/05 (3)
- Re: I allways make the mistake of starting a conversation unprepared - John Elison 17:17:53 08/12/05 (2)
- Vinyl vs CD is all that most consumers understand - StylinLP 17:21:14 08/12/05 (0)
- Re: I allways make the mistake of starting a conversation unprepared - Bry 17:19:59 08/12/05 (0)
- To me, the problem is.... - Peter Olofsson 16:08:39 08/12/05 (5)
- Re: To me, the problem is.... - Bry 16:31:29 08/12/05 (4)
- Re: To me, the problem is.... - RobertB53 07:08:41 08/13/05 (0)
- Re: To me, the problem is.... - Peter Olofsson 17:19:59 08/12/05 (2)
- Re: To me, the problem is.... - Bry 17:22:45 08/12/05 (1)
- Re: To me, the problem is.... - Peter Olofsson 17:40:21 08/12/05 (0)
- Alright. Let me rephrase this question then - StylinLP 15:58:47 08/12/05 (10)
- Re: Alright. Let me rephrase this question then - Bry 16:23:12 08/12/05 (9)
- IMHO, the spec argument, misses the mark entirely... - Ray-o-Stat 19:16:46 08/12/05 (4)
- Re: IMHO, the spec argument, misses the mark entirely... - nosmok 15:37:38 08/13/05 (0)
- New music - StylinLP 19:43:11 08/12/05 (0)
- What mark are you shooting for???? - John Elison 19:31:31 08/12/05 (1)
- Re: What mark are you shooting for???? - Ray-o-Stat 19:39:16 08/12/05 (0)
- Thank you Bry - StylinLP 16:48:18 08/12/05 (3)
- Re: Thank you Bry - Bry 16:55:01 08/12/05 (2)
- #3 always impresses me too. (nt) - srdavis2000 18:55:09 08/12/05 (0)
- Still considered? - StylinLP 17:00:45 08/12/05 (0)
- Re: Could I get a concise complete rundown on vinyl/analog superiority reguardless of equipment? - Bry 15:51:52 08/12/05 (45)
- Sorry but this is wrong! - Don T 16:20:09 08/12/05 (44)
- Actually, Bry Is Correct!! - Todd Krieger 23:55:13 08/12/05 (1)
- Re: Correct, but... - Peter Olofsson 02:59:36 08/13/05 (1)
- Re: Sorry but this is wrong! - John Elison 16:30:07 08/12/05 (5)
- Re: Sorry but this is wrong! - Don T 09:40:57 08/13/05 (4)
- Re: Sorry but this is wrong! - John Elison 14:30:21 08/13/05 (3)
- Re: Sorry but this is wrong! - Don T 18:21:24 08/13/05 (2)
- You're right.... - John Elison 19:09:54 08/13/05 (1)
- No you're right.... - Don T 19:34:16 08/13/05 (0)
- Re: Sorry but this is wrong! - Bry 16:28:49 08/12/05 (35)
- The Nyquist theorem only works for sine waves? (nt) - Peter Olofsson 16:48:22 08/12/05 (34)
- Re: The Nyquist theorem only works for sine waves? (nt) - Todd Krieger 23:59:12 08/12/05 (0)
- So what? - Don T 18:21:32 08/12/05 (4)
- Re: So what? - Todd Krieger 00:04:09 08/13/05 (3)
- Re: So what? - Don T 08/13/0508:44:01 08/13/05 (2)
- Re: So what? - Todd Krieger 22:14:34 08/13/05 (1)
- Re: So what? - Don T 07:35:41 08/14/05 (0)
- Isn't it wonderful that the most complex musical waveform can be recreated perfectly using only sine waves. (nt) - John Elison 17:12:31 08/12/05 (16)
- Re: Isn't it wonderful... - Bry 17:49:18 08/12/05 (15)
- I am trying - StylinLP 19:36:10 08/12/05 (1)
- It's not like vinyl lps extended to 20 kHz either! - Don T 09:20:01 08/13/05 (0)
- On Nyquist... - Peter Olofsson 18:01:34 08/12/05 (12)
- Nope... - Don T 18:20:08 08/12/05 (11)
- Nope? - Peter Olofsson 18:39:54 08/12/05 (10)
- more than two can be less than 3. - Don T 09:06:33 08/13/05 (9)
- Being close to 2 is very bad. - Bry 10:25:17 08/13/05 (7)
- No it's not! - Don T 11:22:28 08/13/05 (6)
- An example... - Bry 12:25:35 08/13/05 (3)
- Re: An example... - Don T 19:04:26 08/13/05 (0)
- Re: An example... - John Elison 18:06:15 08/13/05 (1)
- Re: An example... - Bry 18:27:45 08/13/05 (0)
- Re: No it's not! - Bry 11:34:22 08/13/05 (1)
- Re: No it's not! - Don T 18:47:12 08/13/05 (0)
- OK, my mistake (nt) - Peter Olofsson 10:01:00 08/13/05 (0)
- Re: The Nyquist theorem only works for sine waves? (nt) - Bry 17:09:22 08/12/05 (10)
- Re: The Nyquist theorem only works for sine waves? (nt) - Peter Olofsson 17:32:39 08/12/05 (9)
- Re: The Nyquist theorem only works for sine waves? (nt) - Bry 19:52:53 08/12/05 (8)
- Re: The Nyquist theorem only works for sine waves? (nt) - John Elison 20:09:24 08/12/05 (7)
- Re: Many thanks..... - Peter Olofsson 10:30:39 08/13/05 (5)
- You're welcome.... - John Elison 14:50:39 08/13/05 (4)
- Re: You're welcome.... - Peter Olofsson 18:46:21 08/13/05 (3)
- Re: You're welcome.... - John Elison 20:30:42 08/13/05 (1)
- Thanks again... - Peter Olofsson 03:58:49 08/14/05 (0)
- Re: You're welcome.... - Bry 19:09:55 08/13/05 (0)
- Looks better than most early CD players. :) (nt) - Bry 20:19:55 08/12/05 (0)
- No - KT88 15:38:20 08/12/05 (1)
- Re: Could I get a concise complete rundown on vinyl/analog superiority reguardless of equipment? - John Elison 15:18:28 08/12/05 (16)
- What you listen for - paul_s 12:58:36 08/13/05 (0)
- Re: Could I get a concise complete rundown on vinyl/analog superiority reguardless of equipment? - KT88 15:24:00 08/12/05 (14)
- One sided - StylinLP 16:45:51 08/12/05 (10)
- Well, I suppose one could argue or one could simply listen to what they like - KT88 18:19:35 08/12/05 (1)
- It's easy ... - garth 18:03:20 08/12/05 (8)
- I really get a kick out of you Garth. Are you for real or are you just kidding all the time? :) (nt) - John Elison 18:18:43 08/12/05 (7)
- John, that IS the difference. Nothing more nothing less. Or? :-) [nt - garth 18:52:46 08/12/05 (0)
- How many here take themselves WAY too seriously? - garth 18:37:07 08/12/05 (5)
- You've definitely got a point. :) (nt) - John Elison 18:45:55 08/12/05 (0)
- Re: How many here take themselves WAY too seriously? - srdavis2000 18:44:52 08/12/05 (3)
- What exactly is posturing? (nt) - John Elison 18:46:59 08/12/05 (2)
- See post time 17:04:06 above. (nt) - srdavis2000 19:04:54 08/12/05 (1)
- Bingo! nt - Stephen Murphy 22:21:10 08/13/05 (0)
- Bravo! Clap Clap!!!! - garth 15:40:05 08/12/05 (1)
- What is "audible" vs. what is noted - paul_s 12:24:37 08/13/05 (0)
- Re: Could I get a concise complete rundown on vinyl/analog superiority reguardless of equipment? - mosin 15:25:50 08/12/05 (0)
Follow Ups
- Re: So what? - Don T 08/13/0508:44:01 08/13/05 (2)
- Re: So what? - Todd Krieger 22:14:34 08/13/05 (1)
- Re: So what? - Don T 07:35:41 08/14/05 (0)
Top of Page ]
[ Contact Us ]
[ Support/Wish List ]
[ Copyright © 2025, Audio Asylum, all rights reserved ]
