Tube DIY Asylum Do It Yourself (DIY) paradise for tube and SET project builders. |
|
In Reply to: Thanks all - but still wondering about potential effect of core materials posted by Deke609 on October 7, 2020 at 05:33:54:
Not really my area Deke... I do think core materials matter for plate chokes, FWIW. Quality nanocrystal would be my first choice, followed by one of the really Hi-B types. This based on Dave's comments here and elsewhere and those of some engineers in SE Asia that have been winding on a range of cores for 20+ years. On balance, in the hands of good winders, I found in favour of nanocrystal. I've had chokes and output transformers made from it and been very pleased. But I think a really nice, if a bit different flavour, amp can be made with nickel too.
"Confusion of goals and perfection of means seems to characterise our age." Albert Einstein
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups Full ThreadTopic - What makes a high quality plate choke? - Deke609 06:14:07 10/6/20 (93)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? - sser2 23:24:20 11/12/20 (1)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? - kobasa@xs4all.nl 11:24:09 11/13/20 (0)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? - ivan_terrible 09:49:16 10/27/20 (0)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? - griboon 14:28:34 10/8/20 (0)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? - je2a3 17:41:42 10/6/20 (3)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? - andy evans 07:14:15 10/7/20 (2)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? - je2a3 09:26:49 10/7/20 (1)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? - kobasa@xs4all.nl 10:37:31 10/7/20 (0)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - drummerwill 13:26:58 10/6/20 (82)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - deathtube 667 12:23:53 10/7/20 (74)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - drummerwill 20:34:43 10/7/20 (62)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - deathtube 667 05:14:17 10/8/20 (61)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - Tre' 06:54:50 10/8/20 (60)
- RE: cult like behavior ? - deathtube 667 14:23:16 10/9/20 (4)
- RE: cult like behavior ? Ahh... DT you are too kind... - drummerwill 17:32:46 10/9/20 (0)
- RE: cult like behavior ? - Deke609 15:48:19 10/9/20 (2)
- RE: cult like behavior ?....Wait A Minute !!! - drummerwill 17:16:46 10/9/20 (0)
- RE: it was tried in the past ... - deathtube 667 16:26:58 10/9/20 (0)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - cpotl 09:30:28 10/8/20 (54)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - rivervalley817 11:02:47 10/8/20 (0)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - Tre' 10:29:25 10/8/20 (52)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - cpotl 11:19:54 10/8/20 (1)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - Tre' 11:35:08 10/8/20 (0)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - kobasa@xs4all.nl 10:41:40 10/8/20 (49)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - dave slagle 13:36:43 10/11/20 (48)
- So there Dave... - PakProtector 03:33:07 10/14/20 (14)
- RE: So there Dave... - dave slagle 05:49:45 10/14/20 (2)
- RE: So there Dave... - PakProtector 05:48:50 10/15/20 (0)
- RE: So there Dave... - kobasa@xs4all.nl 05:59:20 10/14/20 (0)
- RE: So there Dave... - kobasa@xs4all.nl 05:03:19 10/14/20 (10)
- RE: So there Dave... - GEO 11:55:12 10/14/20 (4)
- RE: So there Dave... - kobasa@xs4all.nl 12:00:51 10/14/20 (3)
- RE: So there Dave... - Tre' 15:06:31 10/16/20 (1)
- RE: So there Dave... - The Bored 08:51:44 10/17/20 (0)
- RE: So there Dave... - The Bored 13:05:44 10/16/20 (0)
- RE: So there Dave... - dave slagle 05:58:26 10/14/20 (4)
- RE: So there Dave... - kobasa@xs4all.nl 06:03:45 10/14/20 (3)
- RE: So there Dave... - dave slagle 07:41:37 10/14/20 (2)
- RE: So there Dave... - kobasa@xs4all.nl 08:04:35 10/14/20 (1)
- RE: So there Dave... - kobasa@xs4all.nl 11:06:16 10/14/20 (0)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - kobasa@xs4all.nl 01:54:24 10/12/20 (32)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - dave slagle 07:13:02 10/12/20 (31)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - 91derlust 02:59:57 10/15/20 (19)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - dave slagle 06:30:23 10/15/20 (18)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - je2a3 17:33:07 10/18/20 (4)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - ivan_terrible 23:23:27 10/26/20 (3)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - RPMac 05:40:00 10/27/20 (2)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - ivan_terrible 07:21:06 10/27/20 (0)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - kobasa@xs4all.nl 06:20:38 10/27/20 (0)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - 91derlust 18:18:30 10/16/20 (11)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - dave slagle 06:30:34 10/17/20 (10)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - 91derlust 18:11:44 10/18/20 (8)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - kobasa@xs4all.nl 12:38:54 10/20/20 (7)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - GEO 14:27:58 10/20/20 (6)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - rivervalley817 14:34:20 10/20/20 (5)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - kobasa@xs4all.nl 00:15:55 10/21/20 (4)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - GEO 09:59:34 10/21/20 (2)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - kobasa@xs4all.nl 11:54:02 10/21/20 (1)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - kobasa@xs4all.nl 11:15:33 10/22/20 (0)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - rivervalley817 09:03:22 10/21/20 (0)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - je2a3 16:29:06 10/18/20 (0)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - kobasa@xs4all.nl 09:29:31 10/15/20 (0)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - kobasa@xs4all.nl 00:18:28 10/13/20 (10)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - dave slagle 05:59:09 10/13/20 (8)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - kobasa@xs4all.nl 06:25:22 10/13/20 (7)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - dave slagle 08:41:52 10/13/20 (6)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - kobasa@xs4all.nl 10:26:15 10/13/20 (5)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - dave slagle 11:44:03 10/13/20 (4)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - kobasa@xs4all.nl 12:00:40 10/13/20 (3)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - dave slagle 17:04:22 10/13/20 (2)
- I think its Nokia Labs now but. - elblanco 17:15:43 10/13/20 (1)
- RE: I think its Nokia Labs now but. - kobasa@xs4all.nl 02:49:10 10/14/20 (0)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - Stephen R 04:19:54 10/13/20 (0)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - Tre' 15:29:27 10/7/20 (10)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - elblanco 19:39:44 10/7/20 (9)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - dave slagle 06:06:08 10/8/20 (4)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - Deke609 06:49:05 10/8/20 (3)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - dave slagle 08:17:32 10/8/20 (2)
- Thank You Dave, your erudite and cogent response is markedly appreciated.~nT - Cleantimestream 13:16:34 10/17/20 (0)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - Deke609 10:37:16 10/8/20 (0)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - Tre' 20:33:56 10/7/20 (2)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - Stuben 13:34:32 10/9/20 (1)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - Tre' 18:01:21 10/9/20 (0)
- RE: What makes a high quality plate choke? .... Better yet .... - rivervalley817 20:05:54 10/7/20 (0)
- He was asking about parafeed output transformer arrangement - Chip647 13:42:22 10/6/20 (6)
- RE: He was asking about parafeed output transformer arrangement - 91derlust 21:09:39 10/6/20 (5)
- RE: He was asking about parafeed output transformer arrangement - drummerwill 12:47:38 10/7/20 (0)
- Thanks all - but still wondering about potential effect of core materials - Deke609 05:33:54 10/7/20 (3)
- RE: Thanks all - but still wondering about potential effect of core materials - 91derlust 10/7/2012:35:00 10/7/20 (0)
- RE: Thanks all - but still wondering about potential effect of core materials - kobasa@xs4all.nl 06:22:42 10/7/20 (1)
- RE: Thanks all - but still wondering about potential effect of core materials - Sidewinder 16:05:25 10/7/20 (0)
- You could use a plate choke instead of the interstage as well - andy evans 09:04:12 10/6/20 (0)
- Having someone competent wind it. - Chip647 07:16:11 10/6/20 (0)
Follow Ups
- RE: Thanks all - but still wondering about potential effect of core materials - 91derlust 10/7/2012:35:00 10/7/20 (0)