In Reply to: According to some experts, your generalizations are wrong. posted by Dave VH on May 28, 2001 at 14:41:43:
> > > Tubes are only part of the equation. < < <
True, but they are a big part, and to discount their effect is foolish.
Yes, different 300B amps sound different, but they still have a "300Bness" to thier sound-even PP amps.> > > Gordon Rankin of Wavelength Audio, one of the foremost SET designers in the world, < < <
He also sells an all WE version of the Cardinals-same cicuit, different tubes. Not to mention, 3 versions of the Mercury.There is a reason why so many people lust after 45s. Do you think all those DIYers thast use them have the same circuits?
Some people are willing to spend hundreds of dollars on used cunninghams(each) for thier amps. I'm going to go out on a limb, and guess its not for the looks. Why don't they just save money and use EL-34s?
The last time I talk to george Wright, he stated that he LOVED 45s, and if there was a cheap reliable source of them, he would build amps for them.
If OPTs, resistors, Caps, wires and other parts can have an effect on the sound, tubes (including driver and rectifier) can have more.
Jack
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: According to some experts, your generalizations are wrong. - Jack G 05/29/0117:49:04 05/29/01 (56)
- Re: According to some experts, your generalizations are wrong. - Rich 11:43:32 05/31/01 (0)
- Speaking of generalizations, I think we have both touched some truths. - Dave VH 00:53:50 05/30/01 (10)
- Re: Speaking of generalizations, I think we have both touched some truths. - Mark (S-D) 04:46:14 05/30/01 (9)
- Re: Speaking of generalizations, I think we have both touched some truths. - Paul Barker 06:10:23 05/30/01 (8)
- Re: Speaking of generalizations, I think we have both touched some truths. - Mark (S-D) 10:31:15 05/30/01 (7)
- Do not be too quick to condemn the king of DHT's, the 300B - FM 19:06:04 05/30/01 (6)
- Re: Do not be too quick to condemn the king of DHT's, the 300B - Paul Barker 01:59:43 05/31/01 (0)
- Re: Do not be too quick to condemn the king of DHT's, the 300B - Mark (S-D) 00:05:43 05/31/01 (4)
- Re: Do not be too quick to condemn the king of DHT's, the 300B - FM 09:05:32 05/31/01 (3)
- Re: Do not be too quick to condemn the king of DHT's, the 300B - Mark (S-D) 11:57:40 05/31/01 (2)
- Re: Do not be too quick to condemn the king of DHT's, the 300B - Paul Barker 13:33:37 05/31/01 (0)
- Re: Do not be too quick to condemn the king of DHT's, the 300B - FM 12:17:11 05/31/01 (0)
- In my opinion Wrong Jack - Steve 22:49:16 05/29/01 (40)
- The propoganda highway is 2 lane (extra wide on your side it seems) - Tom §. 23:07:00 05/29/01 (39)
- Re: The propoganda highway is 2 lane (extra wide on your side it seems) - Steve 11:50:40 05/30/01 (9)
- Hum, review, KT88's Rp and 300B's - Gordon Rankin 09:13:58 05/31/01 (8)
- Re: Hum, review, KT88's Rp and 300B's - Steve 14:55:14 05/31/01 (5)
- Steve, please, STOP THE INSANITY!!!!!! (nt) - Major Edwin Armstrong 16:42:38 05/31/01 (2)
- Re: Steve, please, STOP THE INSANITY!!!!!! (nt) - Steve 02:14:21 06/4/01 (0)
- I haven't seen anyone use the KT88 properly yet. - Steve 02:26:31 06/2/01 (0)
- Re: Hum, review, KT88's Rp and 300B's - Gordon Rankin 16:28:36 05/31/01 (1)
- Thanks Gordon. I am glad we had this conversation - Steve 20:05:26 05/31/01 (0)
- Triode strapped pentodes - David Home 11:00:02 05/31/01 (1)
- Re: Triode strapped pentodes - Steve 19:46:53 05/31/01 (0)
- Re: The propoganda highway is 2 lane (extra wide on your side it seems) - Paul Barker 06:17:08 05/30/01 (28)
- Re: The propoganda highway is 2 lane (extra wide on your side it seems) - Steve 11:43:17 05/30/01 (21)
- Re: The propoganda highway is 2 lane (extra wide on your side it seems) - Paul Barker 18:15:05 05/30/01 (0)
- The propoganda highway: What deleted posts? - mobile homeless 13:02:30 05/30/01 (7)
- Re: The propoganda highway: What deleted posts? - Paul Barker 18:21:38 05/30/01 (0)
- Re: The propoganda highway: What deleted posts? - Steve 16:29:32 05/30/01 (5)
- A Manufacturer's Duty? Can one Save Grace? - mobile homeless 17:35:37 05/30/01 (4)
- Re: A Manufacturer's Duty? Can one Save Grace? - Steve 00:51:44 05/31/01 (3)
- The "untruthful attacks"? Are these the posts you obliquely refer to? - Tom §. 12:13:33 05/31/01 (1)
- Re: The "untruthful attacks"? Are these the posts you obliquely refer to? - Steve 02:12:15 06/4/01 (0)
- It's not tha facts that cause you troubles, it's how you handle them. - Dave VH 10:44:39 05/31/01 (0)
- Engineers and personal communications. - Dave VH 12:37:06 05/30/01 (10)
- Re: Engineers and personal communications. - Steve 16:39:15 05/30/01 (8)
- Re: Engineers and personal communications. - Rod M 20:59:01 05/31/01 (0)
- Forums like this can be brutal!! - Dave VH 17:30:03 05/30/01 (6)
- Re: Forums like this can be brutal!! - Steve 01:16:38 05/31/01 (5)
- Re: Forums like this can be brutal!! - jeff mai 11:52:41 05/31/01 (4)
- Re: Forums like this can be brutal!! - Steve 01:54:46 06/4/01 (0)
- Re: Forums like this can be brutal!! - Steve 15:06:42 05/31/01 (2)
- Re: Forums like this can be brutal!! - jeff mai 15:48:21 05/31/01 (1)
- Re: Forums like this can be brutal!! - Steve 02:03:25 06/4/01 (0)
- Re: Engineers and personal communications. - BFitz 13:12:37 05/30/01 (0)
- Magnitude. - Tom §. 09:21:28 05/30/01 (5)
- Re: Magnitude. - Paul Barker 18:32:31 05/30/01 (0)
- Re: Magnitude. - Steve 12:07:53 05/30/01 (3)
- Re: Magnitude. - Tom §. 13:42:14 05/30/01 (0)
- Quite a disheartening response, Steve. Manufacturer Savvy? <nt> - mobile homeless 13:22:31 05/30/01 (0)
- I agree with Jack on this - Kurt Strain 19:13:44 05/29/01 (2)
- Re: I agree with Jack on this - Steve 15:19:03 05/31/01 (1)
- Re: I agree with Jack on this - Kurt Strain 00:38:49 06/1/01 (0)