Forget it J..... - Marshall W

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - What band was most affected by the loss or departure of a member? - Quint 10:24:08 01/26/06 (77)

We all forgot about a Mick Jones-less Clash - DAT 08:15:18 02/6/06 (0)

CCR - John Fogery - blackwax@mac.com 19:15:41 02/5/06 (0)

Patti Smith's retirement was a setback for the Patti Smith Group - Bayside Bomber 11:05:54 01/31/06 (0)

Better question - What band was most successful in replacing the loss or departure of a member? - JDK 18:59:02 01/30/06 (4)

All the incarnations of the Byrds...... - hitsware 15:42:32 01/31/06 (0)

Re: Better question - What band was most successful in replacing the loss or departure of a member? - J 19:26:40 01/30/06 (2)

Re:Jefferson Airplane with Grace Slick - LongPlay 19:22:57 02/19/06 (0)

Good answer. My favorite Stones album is one... - Harmonia 09:27:25 01/31/06 (0)

The Doors... - RW 08:31:54 01/30/06 (0)

Journey - Steve Perry nt - AudioDwebe 21:28:44 01/29/06 (3)

You mean by ADDING Perry - Finch Platte 06:57:03 01/30/06 (2)

Re: You mean by ADDING Perry - Mike_in_MD 06:41:20 01/31/06 (1)

Hey Mike, - RW 11:22:37 01/31/06 (0)

too many - musiclistener 18:26:13 01/28/06 (1)

Focus without Jan Akkerman nt - Duilawyer 20:38:17 01/29/06 (0)

Velvet Underground, Wailers, Misfits, Byrds, Fleetwood Mac, Beach Boys, Black Flag...Dread Zeppelin w/out Ed Zeppelin... - J 13:41:47 01/28/06 (0)

Zombies after Jim Rodford left. - Duilawyer 11:18:22 01/28/06 (0)

Byrds without Gene Clark. nt - Duilawyer 09:32:16 01/28/06 (0)

Ambrosia losing David Pack. nt - Duilawyer 20:32:49 01/27/06 (0)

Pink Floyd without Roger Waters - David R. in WV 18:14:12 01/27/06 (5)

Pink Floyd without Syd Barrett* - Eflatminor 14:57:18 01/31/06 (0)

true, they are a shell of their former selves. - Duilawyer 09:33:21 01/28/06 (3)

I agree the Waters was Pink Floyd, but The Final Cut was a - Johnny B 03:51:03 01/29/06 (2)

ditto - blackwax@mac.com 23:51:36 01/31/06 (0)

sorry, don't know it. Never heard it. Not a PF fan at the time. nt - Duilawyer 08:51:21 01/29/06 (0)

Keith Moon, Mick Taylor (nt) - nycman 12:14:18 01/27/06 (1)

Re: Keith Moon, Mick Taylor (nt) - J 11:07:19 01/28/06 (0)

Here are some terrible examples of who shoulda just called it a day - DAT 07:53:34 01/27/06 (4)

I'd have to disagree with you about Bad Co and Sabbath - artemus 10:12:32 01/27/06 (1)

I meant they werent' the same after Ozzy, and they were no longer good after Dio - DAT 20:10:46 01/29/06 (0)

OT Question??? - bboroski 09:45:08 01/27/06 (1)

Great show, very 70s heavy set. - DAT 20:15:08 01/29/06 (0)

Free, when they lost Paul Kossoff...and - John_the_Scot 03:10:35 01/27/06 (0)

here's some - unleasHell 22:42:55 01/26/06 (2)

You couldn't have... - Finch Platte 02:36:25 01/27/06 (1)

Re: sor - unleasHell 21:05:14 01/27/06 (0)

Badfinger - LWR 18:10:03 01/26/06 (1)

Definitely - Quint 05:01:52 01/27/06 (0)

Take That .... Robbie Williams ;-) - welly 17:24:07 01/26/06 (0)

Mott the Hoople - Ian Hunter - SamA 16:29:38 01/26/06 (0)

R.E.M.-Berry; Pink Floyd1-Barrett; Pink Floyd2-Waters nt - provny 15:43:02 01/26/06 (0)

CSNY then CSN...nt - millen 15:06:24 01/26/06 (0)

Moody Blues - Mike Pinder, The Who - Moonie - Bob Rex 13:33:03 01/26/06 (0)

Genesis, Allman Bros. & Chicago - dwill123 12:59:35 01/26/06 (0)

Blind Melon nt - mes 12:31:31 01/26/06 (0)

Menudo, losing Ricky Martin (nt) - Stone 12:11:40 01/26/06 (0)

John Bonham's death marked the end of Zeppelin - artemus 12:05:14 01/26/06 (0)

Uriah Heep without David Byron - Zenos 11:53:32 01/26/06 (0)

UFO without Michael Schenker. - Audiophilander 11:49:20 01/26/06 (5)

Did Grand Funk do anything without Mark Farner? - artemus 12:03:19 01/26/06 (4)

Oh yeah; they've been touring for years without Mark who went all jesus-freak on 'em ... - Audiophilander 12:38:11 01/26/06 (3)

Hey AuiPh. Found this interview with Mark. It may be of interest to ya - artemus 14:18:02 01/26/06 (0)

Apparently - artemus 13:54:21 01/26/06 (1)

Yeah, the problem is that Mark apparently walked after a disagreement with Don and Mel on their last tour in the 90's. - Audiophilander 23:51:15 01/26/06 (0)

YES -when they lost Jon Anderson. - Zenos 11:43:53 01/26/06 (2)

Although Drama was a good album. nt - Redwing 15:17:30 01/27/06 (1)

I am a Camera,...Camera ,Camera - Zenos 16:55:38 01/27/06 (0)

Buddy Holly and The Crickets...N/T - musetap 11:33:26 01/26/06 (0)

Many - Frihed89 11:32:14 01/26/06 (11)

"Queen" - Although Paul Rogers, IMHO, is surprisingly credible interpreting songs of irreplaceable Freddie Mercury. (nt) - Audiophilander 11:53:19 01/26/06 (10)

Respectfully disagree too - suburbanDK 12:57:00 01/26/06 (1)

Watch the DVD if you can; I happen to like it. but it may not work for you. - Audiophilander 21:52:06 01/27/06 (0)

Re: Ugh - J 12:23:28 01/26/06 (7)

Well, I have a different perspective. - Audiophilander 12:47:15 01/26/06 (6)

Obviously - J 12:57:41 01/26/06 (5)

"I do not have to agree" - True, but I have confidence in your ability to improve your reasoning. - Audiophilander 01:27:51 01/27/06 (4)

Is it possible... - J 08:19:29 01/27/06 (3)

Forget it J..... - Marshall W 01/27/0610:51:19 01/27/06 (2)

"He does, however, completely respect your right to be wrong." - And your's as well! - Audiophilander 15:32:14 01/27/06 (1)

Re: Time to tally up: AuPh - 5 pts.; J - 3 pts; Marshall - in the negatives * - Guy 08:47:12 01/28/06 (0)

The Doors - Morrison * - Fishstink 10:52:57 01/26/06 (0)

The Doors nt - bboroski 10:52:51 01/26/06 (0)

Jimi Hendrix Experience losing Jimi...(nt) - mkuller 10:45:36 01/26/06 (0)

The ABB losing Duane. - PdL 10:43:15 01/26/06 (0)

Re: Greatfull Dead - hitsware 10:40:53 01/26/06 (2)

pigpen - jefe 15:19:26 01/27/06 (1)

Re: pigpen - hitsware 20:47:40 01/27/06 (0)

Follow Ups

Forget it J..... - Marshall W 01/27/0610:51:19 01/27/06 (2)

"He does, however, completely respect your right to be wrong." - And your's as well! - Audiophilander 15:32:14 01/27/06 (1)

Re: Time to tally up: AuPh - 5 pts.; J - 3 pts; Marshall - in the negatives * - Guy 08:47:12 01/28/06 (0)