In Reply to: Re: Um... posted by Todd Krieger on April 22, 2003 at 17:01:35:
As long as you don't use enormous levels, the ear recovers in milliseconds.The taste buds and smell receptors can take from milliseconds to several minutes to "reset".
The two are NOT, repeat NOT equivelent in this sense.
What's more, Hall's level roving experiements, among other things, show very clearly that the ability to switch quickly and cleanly is without a doubt necessary.
You'll have to overturn Hall's work if you want to argue otherwise. I doubt you'll succeed, because the short-term auditory memory involved has a less than 200 millisecond retention period. Once you get beyond that length of time, give or take, you move from partial loudness differences to feature differences, which are considerably less sensitive.
-- Do not seek the treasure! DO NOT SEEK THE TREASURE!
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Listening is very different from wine-tasting, guys... - jj 04/22/0319:00:48 04/22/03 (26)
- Help illuminate us - E-Stat 21:11:00 04/22/03 (6)
- Read the literature. - jj 22:52:52 04/22/03 (5)
- Do you believe that - E-Stat 19:57:07 04/26/03 (4)
- Do you think that your comment is even possibly germane? - jj 14:28:02 04/28/03 (3)
- Thanks for the informative reply - E-Stat 16:12:45 04/28/03 (2)
- Did you read the part about "level roving"??? - jj 18:59:27 04/29/03 (1)
- I listed all the references Google sourced - E-Stat 16:47:39 05/2/03 (0)
- Re: Listening is very different from wine-tasting, guys... - Todd Krieger 20:00:48 04/22/03 (18)
- Your skepticism is uncalled for.... - jj 20:21:25 04/22/03 (17)
- Nothing Wrong with Skepticism... - Todd Krieger 20:36:05 04/22/03 (16)
- Then I suggest you do some studying.... - jj 22:51:49 04/22/03 (15)
- Re: Then I suggest you do some studying.... - Jitter_by_Coffee 09:55:44 04/25/03 (14)
- Re: Then I suggest you do some studying.... - cheap-Jack 11:41:35 04/28/03 (1)
- I certainly do not need to substantiate MY statement -It' snot "mine" to start with - jj 14:31:55 04/28/03 (0)
- Is there a reason you ignore the truth? - jj 18:39:51 04/25/03 (11)
- Studies vs. First Hand Observation - Todd Krieger 22:49:30 04/26/03 (10)
- Then you reject all knowledge that you didn't develop yourse.f - jj 14:26:09 04/28/03 (8)
- I Hope You Take This as Constructive Criticism... - Todd Krieger 19:51:26 04/28/03 (7)
- Retract that, and get your head out of the sand. - jj 19:22:28 04/29/03 (3)
- Man, What a Predikamunt... - Todd Krieger 22:28:58 04/29/03 (2)
- Oh, go ahead. You're playing to the crowd anyhow.... - jj 22:36:20 04/29/03 (1)
- OK, I'm Playing to the Crowd... - Todd Krieger 23:00:56 04/29/03 (0)
- Re: I Hope You Take This as Constructive Criticism... - cheap-Jack 09:55:11 04/29/03 (2)
- You are a malicious, stalking sock-puppet. - jj 19:08:47 04/29/03 (1)
- Re: You are a malicious, stalking sock-puppet. - cheap-Jack 13:49:16 04/30/03 (0)
- Re: Studies vs. First Hand Observation - john curl 11:55:08 04/27/03 (0)