![]() |
Propeller Head Plaza Technical and scientific discussion of amps, cables and other topics. |
|
In Reply to: "very nice argument" - I trust you don't mean as in "being nice" (but that's to be expected). posted by carcass93 on September 30, 2009 at 08:56:13:
I thought it was an interesting argument, and one that I've never heard before. I make no comment on its accuracy. I'd have to say I'm a believer in "room nodes don't coexist with accuracy" but I'm guessing AJ has more to say on the subject. The guy builds and alters speakers so I'd have to say that gives him a leg and two arms up on me, and I'm curious what else he comes up with.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups Full ThreadTopic - Blind listening test of power cords - and reactions to it. - carcass93 08:19:27 09/25/09 (151)
- RE: Blind listening test of power cords - and reactions to it. - andy19191 16:44:01 09/28/09 (107)
- No idea, and don't give a damn. But you're not talking about yourself, hopefully. N/T - carcass93 05:27:17 09/29/09 (16)
- RE: No idea, and don't give a damn. But you're not talking about yourself, hopefully. N/T - andy19191 01:47:44 09/30/09 (15)
- That would be people that aren't looking beneath the surface - kerr 08:03:19 09/30/09 (13)
- RE: That would be people that aren't looking beneath the surface - andy19191 14:19:33 09/30/09 (10)
- So, when thinly-disguised audiophile hater, with the only... - carcass93 09:44:00 10/1/09 (2)
- RE: So, when thinly-disguised audiophile hater, with the only... - kerr 13:03:27 10/1/09 (1)
- Yeah... When professionals discuss online top-of-the-line Lavry vs. Crane Song AD/DAs,... - carcass93 14:26:06 10/1/09 (0)
- RE: That would be people that aren't looking beneath the surface - theaudiohobby 20:52:50 09/30/09 (0)
- RE: That would be people that aren't looking beneath the surface - kerr 17:09:38 09/30/09 (4)
- If you're right about "got as much as he gave", that only means... - carcass93 09:58:35 10/1/09 (3)
- Thanks! - kerr 10:08:11 10/1/09 (2)
- On different subject - bought some "cheap" single malts recently in Duty Free shop abroad. - carcass93 10:45:11 10/1/09 (1)
- I've not done much experimenting lately - kerr 10:57:08 10/1/09 (0)
- for some one who claims to be a disinterested observer - Analog Scott 15:58:18 09/30/09 (0)
- "very nice argument" - I trust you don't mean as in "being nice" (but that's to be expected). - carcass93 08:56:13 09/30/09 (1)
- I meant "interesting" - kerr 09/30/0909:18:42 09/30/09 (0)
- Fine collection of fantasies, guesses and lies in one short post. Keep it up. N/T - carcass93 08:00:55 09/30/09 (0)
- What I find revealing is this quote - E-Stat 16:54:23 09/28/09 (6)
- Well at least they are being honest! - Don Till 11:05:32 09/30/09 (5)
- Are you being honest? I kind of doubt that... - carcass93 12:41:07 09/30/09 (2)
- .Right on par - Don Till 18:19:49 09/30/09 (1)
- "I'm a subjectivist " - if you say so... - carcass93 08:23:16 10/1/09 (0)
- RE: Well at least they are being honest! - kerr 12:37:20 09/30/09 (1)
- RE: Well at least they are being honest! - Don Till 18:24:07 09/30/09 (0)
- The DBT pseudoscientists are even crazier than we hobbyists are...(nt) - mkuller 16:47:08 09/28/09 (82)
- RE: The DBT pseudoscientists are even crazier than we hobbyists are...(nt) - Peter H-son 08:53:14 09/30/09 (72)
- I BELIEVE!!! - morricab 14:34:56 09/30/09 (0)
- Looks like your posts below have been deleted... - mkuller 09:58:16 09/30/09 (1)
- RE: Looks like your posts below have been deleted... - Peter H-son 10:37:14 09/30/09 (0)
- I'm not the sharpest knife in the drawer, it's true - kerr 09:30:09 09/30/09 (65)
- RE: I'm not the sharpest knife in the drawer, it's true - Peter H-son 09:44:08 09/30/09 (64)
- RE: I'm not the sharpest knife in the drawer, it's true - kerr 10:07:26 09/30/09 (55)
- RE: I'm not the sharpest knife in the drawer, it's true - Peter H-son 10:28:03 09/30/09 (53)
- "This thread is an attack on reason, skepticism, critical thinking and science." um...no - Analog Scott 11:41:39 09/30/09 (14)
- RE: "This thread is an attack on reason, skepticism, critical thinking and science." um...no - Peter H-son 11:45:50 09/30/09 (13)
- "Being called "lunitic fringe" by your kind is a badge of honor." - Analog Scott 13:26:33 09/30/09 (12)
- RE: "Being called "lunitic fringe" by your kind is a badge of honor." - Peter H-son 10:31:31 10/1/09 (11)
- "Why would I do that?" - Analog Scott 13:43:40 10/1/09 (10)
- RE: "Why would I do that?" - Peter H-son 06:30:55 10/2/09 (9)
- "I'm talking about the outlandish claims made by the wire fetishists." - Analog Scott 07:56:28 10/2/09 (8)
- RE: "I'm talking about the outlandish claims made by the wire fetishists." - Peter H-son 09:10:04 10/2/09 (5)
- RE: "I'm talking about the outlandish claims made by the wire fetishists." - Analog Scott 12:57:01 10/2/09 (4)
- RE: "I'm talking about the outlandish claims made by the wire fetishists." - Peter H-son 06:39:20 10/3/09 (3)
- RE: "I'm talking about the outlandish claims made by the wire fetishists." - Analog Scott 09:36:26 10/3/09 (2)
- RE: "I'm talking about the outlandish claims made by the wire fetishists." - Peter H-son 13:33:14 10/3/09 (1)
- Well argued - Analog Scott 17:43:55 10/3/09 (0)
- He apparently thinks that "Nobody is dumber that the idiots here" swing, that started the mayhem,... - carcass93 08:11:49 10/2/09 (1)
- RE: He apparently thinks that "Nobody is dumber that the idiots here" swing, that started the mayhem,... - Peter H-son 06:55:40 10/3/09 (0)
- RE: I'm not the sharpest knife in the drawer, it's true - kerr 10:46:46 09/30/09 (36)
- Man, you don't understand... you HAVE TO PROVE something to him. N/T - carcass93 11:20:37 09/30/09 (0)
- RE: I'm not the sharpest knife in the drawer, it's true - Donald North 11:15:17 09/30/09 (4)
- A perfectly logical approach... - mkuller 11:18:24 09/30/09 (3)
- RE: A perfectly logical approach... - Peter H-son 11:35:04 09/30/09 (2)
- Looks like you also have... - mkuller 11:48:48 09/30/09 (1)
- RE: Looks like you also have... - Peter H-son 11:58:58 09/30/09 (0)
- RE: I'm not the sharpest knife in the drawer, it's true - Peter H-son 11:10:43 09/30/09 (29)
- RE: I'm not the sharpest knife in the drawer, it's true - kerr 12:30:05 09/30/09 (25)
- RE: I'm not the sharpest knife in the drawer, it's true - Pat D 09:32:07 10/2/09 (24)
- RE: I'm not the sharpest knife in the drawer, it's true - kerr 10:21:44 10/2/09 (23)
- RE: I'm not the sharpest knife in the drawer, it's true - Pat D 14:11:10 10/3/09 (22)
- "the problems are to show that there are any audible differences and under what conditions." - Analog Scott 10:44:07 10/4/09 (21)
- No one says you can't enjoy your perceptions. - Pat D 18:59:24 10/5/09 (20)
- looks to me like he asked you... - Analog Scott 08:29:21 10/6/09 (19)
- RE: looks to me like he asked you... - Pat D 12:16:07 10/6/09 (18)
- Then we come full circle - Analog Scott 14:44:16 10/6/09 (4)
- You are totally confused. - Pat D 18:37:16 10/6/09 (3)
- You aren't getting it and that makes me confused...... - Analog Scott 23:16:39 10/6/09 (2)
- "Technical and scientific discussion of amps, cables and other topics." - Pat D 12:57:39 10/8/09 (1)
- No I have no problem with that - Analog Scott 10:48:01 10/10/09 (0)
- The answer is equally easy: it can, if you're willing to substantiate it for yourself. - carcass93 14:02:26 10/6/09 (12)
- Life is too short. - Pat D 18:31:05 10/6/09 (11)
- Where does posting silly demands of others for "proof" on this forum fit into that? - carcass93 08:29:33 10/7/09 (4)
- I only ask if there is proof of extraordinary claims. - Pat D 10:37:34 10/7/09 (2)
- Asked and aswered - there is. Just not for you. N/T - carcass93 12:53:41 10/7/09 (1)
- You haven't indicated any proofs. (nt) - Pat D 16:03:47 10/10/09 (0)
- Well, you have to admit he has a point - kerr 09:09:20 10/7/09 (0)
- More like too busy posting demands for evidence on this forum... - morricab 01:52:15 10/7/09 (5)
- I'm not the one making extraordinary claims about what I can hear. (nt) - Pat D 10:32:29 10/7/09 (4)
- RE: I'm not the one making extraordinary claims about what I can hear. (nt) - morricab 00:54:04 10/8/09 (3)
- "Technical and scientific discussion of amps, cables and other topics." - Pat D 13:43:47 10/8/09 (1)
- RE: "Technical and scientific discussion of amps, cables and other topics." - morricab 02:26:35 10/9/09 (0)
- Ah, there's the question! - kerr 04:46:07 10/8/09 (0)
- Can you show me evidence... - mkuller 11:21:14 09/30/09 (2)
- RE: Can you show me evidence... - Peter H-son 11:32:25 09/30/09 (1)
- You got nothing - who's the wackjob? (nt) - mkuller 11:36:49 09/30/09 (0)
- "attack on reason, skepticism, critical thinking and science" - you're wrong again. - carcass93 10:44:46 09/30/09 (0)
- His two weapons are fear and surpise and - Analog Scott 10:16:29 09/30/09 (0)
- What fallacy? - Tony Lauck 10:05:49 09/30/09 (0)
- So if a peice of wire has different... - mkuller 09:59:53 09/30/09 (6)
- RE: So if a peice of wire has different... - Peter H-son 10:17:59 09/30/09 (5)
- "As far as we know" - you don't know too far then. BTW, "we" - you got helminths? - carcass93 10:35:18 09/30/09 (2)
- RE: "As far as we know" - you don't know too far then. BTW, "we" - you got helminths? - Peter H-son 10:41:13 09/30/09 (1)
- I thought their video was about the beliefs of the DBT pseudoscientists...(nt) - mkuller 10:58:00 09/30/09 (0)
- "As far as we know..." - you got a mouse in your pocket? (nt) - mkuller 10:29:06 09/30/09 (1)
- Judging by tone of his posts - it's helminths, indeed. Nasty ones, and lot of them. N/T - carcass93 11:22:30 09/30/09 (0)
- "Nobody is dumber that the idiots here" - that's right, you're the dumbest of anti-audiophile idiots here. - carcass93 09:14:51 09/30/09 (2)
- RE: "Nobody is dumber that the idiots here" - that's right, you're the dumbest of anti-audiophile idiots here. - Peter H-son 09:47:14 09/30/09 (1)
- You don't have a point. - carcass93 10:12:20 09/30/09 (0)
- Yeah, ironic talk about tribes, when his is the craziest .(nt) - Sordidman 10:35:06 09/29/09 (5)
- IMO both fringes are on even ground when it comes to craziness and vitrole. nt - Analog Scott 12:44:56 09/29/09 (4)
- Perhaps, but... - mkuller 20:42:18 09/29/09 (2)
- Tell ya? Heck I'll show ya. - Analog Scott 08:05:26 09/30/09 (1)
- I'd forgotten that episode.... - robert young 11:46:24 09/30/09 (0)
- I hear that but - Sordidman 18:25:17 09/29/09 (0)
- ...and they like their DBT's only when they give them expected results (nt) - kerr 16:54:05 09/28/09 (2)
- double word (nt) - Analog Scott 08:21:16 09/29/09 (0)
- Word (nt) - Donald North 17:06:00 09/28/09 (0)
- It is very easy to understand their beliefs - E-Stat 07:05:35 09/27/09 (15)
- Along the same lines - their systems (E. Winer responds to ajinfla): - carcass93 11:52:53 09/28/09 (12)
- Interestingly, AJinFLA already got into disagreement there (who could've thought?)... - carcass93 08:42:25 09/29/09 (9)
- He may get bounced for disagreeing - kerr 09:33:27 09/29/09 (8)
- This "LFO on LFO" violence must cease!!!! - Analog Scott 10:32:04 09/29/09 (6)
- We can't have them fighting amongst themselves! - kerr 11:20:02 09/29/09 (5)
- That's the - E-Stat 15:41:39 09/29/09 (2)
- Gotta admit - kerr 15:53:54 09/29/09 (1)
- Its definitely - E-Stat 16:24:33 09/29/09 (0)
- Let's Go!!! - robert young 15:32:02 09/29/09 (1)
- RE: Let's Go!!! - kerr 15:55:42 09/29/09 (0)
- Absolutely. BTW, some stuff there is informative (especially if you haven't read it previous 100 times). - carcass93 09:48:25 09/29/09 (0)
- Who said anything about a spigot? - E-Stat 16:59:04 09/28/09 (0)
- RE: Along the same lines - their systems (E. Winer responds to ajinfla): - kerr 16:51:03 09/28/09 (0)
- As you've always said... - kerr 13:24:33 09/27/09 (1)
- It is truly perplexing! - E-Stat 15:42:54 09/27/09 (0)
- Scavenging in the Toxic Waste Dump - Tony Lauck 08:04:17 09/26/09 (3)
- RE: Scavenging in the Toxic Waste Dump - Pat D 10:21:28 09/26/09 (2)
- RE: Scavenging in the Toxic Waste Dump - Tony Lauck 11:03:12 09/26/09 (1)
- RE: Scavenging in the Toxic Waste Dump - geoffkait 09:42:23 09/27/09 (0)
- And your evaluation of his blind test is? - Pat D 14:30:08 09/25/09 (8)
- Considering your supposed mighty struggle comprehending English, I'm not sure you could... - carcass93 14:46:39 09/25/09 (7)
- Apparently you didn't read the thread very well . . . - Pat D 15:24:18 09/25/09 (6)
- You could easily answer all these questions yourself. - carcass93 08:56:52 09/28/09 (0)
- RE: Apparently you didn't read the thread very well . . . - Analog Scott 20:12:05 09/25/09 (4)
- Well, if you want to talk personalities . . . - Pat D 08:42:54 09/26/09 (3)
- Spreading your wings Pat? - bjh 10:25:18 09/26/09 (0)
- I guess I struck a nerve - Analog Scott 08:55:25 09/26/09 (1)
- Well, that answers my question. (nt) - Pat D 16:38:26 10/3/09 (0)
- RE: Blind listening test of power cords - and reactions to it. - kerr 10:16:33 09/25/09 (13)
- Hydrogen Audio Is The Training Manuel For The LFOs On PHP - thetubeguy1954 13:45:50 09/26/09 (7)
- RE: Hydrogen Audio Is The Training Manuel For The LFOs On PHP - Todd Krieger 19:28:05 09/28/09 (0)
- I hope you have that backwards - kerr 15:11:31 09/26/09 (5)
- Sadly I Don't Believe I Do... - thetubeguy1954 07:07:06 09/28/09 (4)
- Their forum, their rules - kerr 06:10:11 09/29/09 (3)
- "Their forum, their rules" ah that depends on who you are - Analog Scott 12:28:16 09/30/09 (2)
- RE: "Their forum, their rules" ah that depends on who you are - kerr 16:55:14 09/30/09 (1)
- yeah I didn't know about the unwritten rules - Analog Scott 22:24:31 09/30/09 (0)
- I've had some real fun with them lately - Analog Scott 20:07:58 09/25/09 (1)
- I've seen your posts there - kerr 06:09:17 09/26/09 (0)
- BTW, one old friend popped up there, too. - carcass93 10:54:35 09/25/09 (1)
- I saw his post - kerr 12:10:33 09/25/09 (0)
- The Knights who say Ni. (nt) - Al Sekela 10:49:30 09/25/09 (0)
Follow Ups
- I meant "interesting" - kerr 09/30/0909:18:42 09/30/09 (0)