In Reply to: Thanks for the info.... posted by Charles Hansen on August 1, 2003 at 21:24:59:
I've heard Atmaspheres and I've heard Hurricanes, but I will let the reviewers make the public pronouncements about their qualities. Trust me, doing so is a no-win situation for a mfr.Output impedance is a real issue with tube amps, even those with feedback, because the feedback is not always fully operative due to load reactance. The definitive solution is to use a great many output tubes.
Charlie, I pulled the feedback from the EL34 version of my V8 some three years ago. Its got a bigger soundstage and is more vivid in the midrange, but I can't say as I like it any better overall. I am having some luck, believe it or not, with 6550 beam tubes using *local* feedback. This converts the horizontal plate curves to triode-like diagonal curves. These 6550 amps don't use any global feedback. They were used to drive the Avalon Opus at the recent HE2003.
But I have not given up on feedback. I find it a facinating challenge. The reason I think it can work is because it is used throughout the human body. Even the ear uses it. It is what protects the inner ear from overload. The touch of a finger on a piano key is a servo operation through and through. There is even compensation by integration. So I believe feedback can work. It's just difficult.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: Thanks for the info.... - Scott Frankland 08/2/0302:18:02 08/2/03 (12)
- Re: Thanks for the info.... - mfc 12:30:15 08/2/03 (1)
- Re: Thanks for the info.... - Scott Frankland 13:15:05 08/2/03 (0)
- Concerning feedback in the human body... - Charles Hansen 07:05:56 08/2/03 (9)
- Re: Concerning feedback in the human body... - Scott Frankland 11:28:59 08/2/03 (8)
- Well, yahbut... - Charles Hansen 11:57:30 08/2/03 (7)
- Re: Well, yahbut... - Scott Frankland 13:51:24 08/2/03 (6)
- Interesting stuff! - Charles Hansen 21:43:18 08/2/03 (5)
- Feedback here, there, and elsewhere - Scott Frankland 01:41:22 08/3/03 (4)
- Linear Stages - Charles Hansen 08:02:29 08/3/03 (3)
- Re: Linear Stages - Scott Frankland 14:54:08 08/3/03 (1)
- You're right.... - Charles Hansen 20:27:04 08/3/03 (0)
- Re: Linear Stages - Steve Eddy 09:58:08 08/3/03 (0)