In Reply to: Re: Compensating Sziklai doesn't help (that much) posted by Scott Frankland on July 23, 2003 at 00:51:43:
Here are some interesting results for the MLJ3281 Sizklai follower
with compensation and with a .1uF capacitor across a 10 ohm load.3900pF capacitor inserted between collector and base of first
transistor. Square Wave = 1050 Hz.
Using 1,3,5,...25,27 harmonic values only.
27th = 28350Hz. Amptitude = 8v peak.
Gibbs phenomena (although present)was very small.
Sine Wave = 5KHz. Amptitude = 1v peak.B+ = +-20v, ILoad = 1.9477 amps, RLoad = 10 ohms/.1uF
Vbase = 14.6mv.Simulation settings: Step = 100nS, Window = .1second
Compensated with .1uF load cap,Driven sine/square wave measure output(1stcolumn)
Uncompensated no .1uF load cap,Driven sine/square wave measure output(2ndcolumn)The noise floor on input was about .3nV which represents a
very low noise level.Here are the results:
Fndmntl(dB) 0.00 0.00
2nd -57.06 -57.10
3rd -61.39 -61.44
4th -71.10 -71.42
5th -80.66 -81.13
6th -79.13 -79.20
7th -88.88 -91.51
8th -86.56 -87.47
9th -90.93 -90.89
10th -93.98 -100.22
11th -97.74 -96.35
12th -92.44 -91.89
13th -90.10 -99.84Interesting that the compensated (3900pF) with .1uF cap across a
10 ohm load (first set of numbers) looks very similiar to the
uncompensated (no cap, and no cap across load) case.The non-linearities do not go away.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Cap loaded - mfc 07/23/0312:28:03 07/23/03 (12)
- Re: Cap loaded - Scott Frankland 12:55:44 07/23/03 (11)
- Re: Cap loaded - Scott Frankland 13:47:34 07/23/03 (10)
- Re: Cap loaded - mfc 14:18:30 07/23/03 (9)
- Re: Cap loaded - mfc 15:19:39 07/23/03 (8)
- Re: Cap loaded - Scott Frankland 17:41:41 07/23/03 (7)
- Re: Cap loaded - mfc 00:36:32 07/24/03 (6)
- Re: Cap loaded - Scott Frankland 11:43:40 07/24/03 (5)
- Re: Cap loaded - mfc 17:20:42 07/25/03 (4)
- Re: Cap loaded - Scott Frankland 22:22:30 07/25/03 (3)
- Re: Cap loaded - mfc 12:13:58 07/26/03 (2)
- Re: Cap loaded - Scott Frankland 13:02:21 07/26/03 (1)
- Re: Cap loaded - mfc 14:58:45 07/26/03 (0)