In Reply to: Re: The paper can't be that good and here's why... posted by mfc on May 4, 2003 at 10:24:17:
Great input mfc. Your reference removes a lot of 'head scratching' about the problem of higher order harmonics.
Let me quote from 'Science and Music' Sir James Jeans 1937 , p87: "... all these (first) six harmonics form parts of the common chord of the fundamental note, and so are concordant with this note and with one another. The seventh harmonic, however, introduces an element of discord; if the fundamental tone is c', its pitch is approximately b (flat)''', which forms a dissonance with c. The same is true with the ninth, eleventh, thirteenth, and all higher odd-numbered harmonics; these add dissonance as well as SHRILLNESS (caps mine) to the fundamental tone, and so introduce a roughness or harsheness into the composite sound. The resultant quality of tone is often described as 'metallic' , since a piece of metal, when struck, emits a sound which is rich in discordant high tones. "
Does this sound like some audio equipment that you have heard? ;-)
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: The paper can't be that good and here's why... - john curl 05/4/0313:10:49 05/4/03 (16)
- Re: The paper can't be that good and here's why... - mfc 21:19:35 05/4/03 (15)
- Re: The paper can't be that good and here's why... - Steve Eddy 21:34:34 05/6/03 (14)
- Amplifier harmonics vs real instruments - Scott Frankland 13:31:07 05/8/03 (2)
- Re: Amplifier harmonics vs real instruments - Steve Eddy 16:43:20 05/8/03 (1)
- Re: Amplifier harmonics vs real instruments - Scott Frankland 17:22:05 05/8/03 (0)
- Re: The paper can't be that good and here's why... - mfc 00:39:08 05/7/03 (10)
- Re: The paper can't be that good and here's why... - Steve Eddy 07:56:26 05/8/03 (4)
- Re: The paper can't be that good and here's why... - mfc 19:37:13 05/8/03 (3)
- Re: The paper can't be that good and here's why... - john curl 09:33:36 05/9/03 (2)
- Ordered it from Amazon, and Test setup - mfc 10:39:40 05/9/03 (1)
- Re: Ordered it from Amazon, and Test setup - john curl 11:57:57 05/9/03 (0)
- Re: The paper can't be that good and here's why... - john curl 15:25:00 05/7/03 (4)
- Re: The paper can't be that good and here's why... - Steve Eddy 07:47:20 05/8/03 (2)
- Re: The paper can't be that good and here's why... - john curl 11:45:34 05/8/03 (1)
- God you're an insufferable prick. nt - Steve Eddy 16:13:47 05/8/03 (0)
- Oh, not spices, more like rat poison? Not really - mfc 16:13:15 05/7/03 (0)