In Reply to: Re: OK, all you hi-RPM propellerheads........... posted by john curl on May 1, 2003 at 12:53:23:
His figure 2-2 in his paper is the one he gets all his data and
derives his calculations from. It is not in the book referenced
in his paper:Olsen, Harry F. “Music, Physics and Engineering”
Dover Publications, Inc. N.Y., 2nd ed. : 1967When I contacted Dan, he never could find the actual reference.
I asked on this newsgroup about two months ago if anyone had seen the
book it came from.Not that it isn't an interesting paper. It just that the references cited don't check out.
Somebody here pointed me to an article by Hiraga that was reprinted
in the March 2002 issue of AudioXpress. This is very similiar.The main problem with this work is that the simple equations like
this ignores different frequencies. Cheever's equations were derived for a frequency of 1Khz. The equation would look different for 100Hz.It would be tough to get an amp to dynamically do a frequency analysis and produce the proper distortion spectrum. Nonetheless,
it might be a good first order approximation - especially for
tubes.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: OK, all you hi-RPM propellerheads........... - mfc 05/2/0300:44:19 05/2/03 (21)
- Could this be the missing Cheever ref? - Scott Frankland 11:01:17 05/7/03 (0)
- Re: OK, all you hi-RPM propellerheads........... - john curl 02:31:21 05/2/03 (19)
- Wegel and Lane paper found - Scott Frankland 19:55:25 05/8/03 (0)
- Re: OK, all you hi-RPM propellerheads........... - Scott Frankland 09:39:11 05/3/03 (17)
- Re: OK, all you hi-RPM propellerheads........... - mfc 14:40:32 05/3/03 (14)
- Re: OK, all you hi-RPM propellerheads........... - Scott Frankland 17:09:14 05/3/03 (13)
- Re: OK, all you hi-RPM propellerheads........... - mfc 17:48:58 05/3/03 (12)
- Re: OK, all you hi-RPM propellerheads........... - Scott Frankland 20:38:35 05/3/03 (11)
- Re: OK, all you hi-RPM propellerheads........... - mfc 16:24:32 05/4/03 (10)
- Re: OK, all you hi-RPM propellerheads........... - Scott Frankland 00:55:04 05/5/03 (3)
- "That's what I've been working on lately." - clarkjohnsen 08:39:31 05/5/03 (2)
- Re: "That's what I've been working on lately." - Scott Frankland 12:03:54 05/5/03 (1)
- My advice: Growing up is vastly overrated. nt - clarkjohnsen 10:06:06 05/6/03 (0)
- Neither pentodes nor transistors - Leisure7 18:19:01 05/4/03 (5)
- Re: Neither pentodes nor transistors - Scott Frankland 01:00:37 05/5/03 (4)
- Re: Neither pentodes nor transistors - mfc 19:34:55 05/6/03 (3)
- Re: Neither pentodes nor transistors - Scott Frankland 19:55:07 05/6/03 (2)
- Cascoded triodes (12AT7) - Leisure7 18:36:31 05/7/03 (1)
- Re: Cascoded triodes (12AT7) - Scott Frankland 23:11:44 05/7/03 (0)
- Re: OK, all you hi-RPM propellerheads........... - john curl 11:26:33 05/3/03 (1)
- Re: OK, all you hi-RPM propellerheads........... - Scott Frankland 20:14:16 05/3/03 (0)