Doctors?

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Doctor recommends late term abortion to a mother of 3 children, to save her life. Which life would you choose - Arya 09:33:34 02/22/06 (72)

Terry Schaivo. nt - The Real Dick Hertz 13:40:15 02/22/06 (0)

Re: Doctor recommends late term abortion to a mother of 3 children, to save her life. Which life would you choose - Gene W 12:17:45 02/22/06 (0)

For many centuries, and just ending sometime in the sixties, the Catholic Church - tinear 11:27:45 02/22/06 (0)

I don't know anyone who would not choose to save the mother. This is a red herring question at best and a troll at worst - artemus 11:02:41 02/22/06 (3)

Then, whats the problem in wording PBA like that ? --mt - Arya 11:22:11 02/22/06 (2)

Not sure there is a need for PBA. - artemus 11:43:53 02/22/06 (1)

Why is non-PBA acceptable? The fetus is terminated either way. -nt- - Donald 20:55:01 02/22/06 (0)

Doctors? - Marshall W 02/22/0611:00:50 02/22/06 (1)

Re: Doctors? - Gene W 14:48:15 02/22/06 (0)

The baby, of course. It might be a boy. - LesF 10:47:06 02/22/06 (0)

Good question. Why did she get knocked up after three anyway? * - mr grits 10:25:09 02/22/06 (1)

Why would that matter anyway? nt - GliderGuider 10:27:13 02/22/06 (0)

If it were to really save the "life" of the mother - MMasztal 10:20:23 02/22/06 (2)

the partial birth abortion act doesnt protect mothers PERIOD --mt - Arya 10:40:25 02/22/06 (1)

Of course not. Mothers period has stopped by then... - GliderGuider 10:57:01 02/22/06 (0)

Abortion clinic recommends an abortion for convenience sake... which would you choose? - dennzio 10:10:19 02/22/06 (10)

As usual, the answers are somewhere in the middle - PabloP 10:18:16 02/22/06 (5)

***The statute under review has an exception to protect the mother's life, so Adi's question is pointless.*** - Arya 10:34:05 02/22/06 (4)

Do you have some strange sort of dyslexia? "health" does not mean "life" - PabloP 10:40:22 02/22/06 (3)

so, all those judges are stupid in your opinion? - Arya 10:45:46 02/22/06 (2)

The bill says the opposite of what you apparently read it to say - PabloP 10:52:25 02/22/06 (1)

Not just me, please include all those judges quoted --mt - Arya 11:21:08 02/22/06 (0)

We are not talking: 1. abortion clinics, 2. convenience . Try again --mt - Arya 10:12:18 02/22/06 (3)

You don't get to manipulate the agenda. What do you think this is...Arya's place? - dennzio 11:52:36 02/22/06 (2)

Re: What do you think this is...Arya's place? - Arya 12:08:54 02/22/06 (1)

Just checking. (nt - dennzio 12:39:22 02/22/06 (0)

probably recommend a ceasarian section to save both lives _ (nt) - Mart 10:02:30 02/22/06 (7)

Dumb doctors. Mart to the rescue --mt - Arya 10:03:22 02/22/06 (6)

Abortionist selling more product - Gene W 15:02:46 02/22/06 (0)

that's an awful broad brush with which you're painting physicians _ (nt) - Mart 10:14:51 02/22/06 (4)

me? it was you who implied that doctors are stupid --mt - Arya 10:16:07 02/22/06 (3)

is your argument that weak that you're trying to put words in my mouth? _ _ (nt) - Mart 10:22:19 02/22/06 (2)

if you cannot give your honest opinion, may be you should indulge --mt - Arya 10:47:21 02/22/06 (1)

huh? _ is that your way of asking for my dishonest opinion, since you so discarded my honest one? _ (nt) - Mart 10:52:45 02/22/06 (0)

Re: You might like to also ask the mother...(nt) - Jeff Starrs 09:41:24 02/22/06 (13)

Would you, if the mother was a known drug addict and child abuser? --mt - Arya 09:47:47 02/22/06 (10)

Re: Will you keep adding clauses to suit you? - Jeff Starrs 09:53:27 02/22/06 (9)

Isnt it how the courts are supposed to consider the legality of laws? --mt - Arya 09:57:39 02/22/06 (8)

Re: You're answering a question with a question... - Jeff Starrs 10:05:14 02/22/06 (7)

I am trying to answer anything here....just raising thought provoking questions --mt - Arya 10:15:00 02/22/06 (6)

Re: Fine... - Jeff Starrs 10:17:33 02/22/06 (5)

Voluntary death is illegal. Therefore, it is also illegal to let an individual choose between life and death --mt - Arya 10:22:23 02/22/06 (4)

No - Gene W 15:08:45 02/22/06 (0)

Re: Voluntary death is illegal. Therefore, it is also illegal to let an individual choose between life and death --mt - Jeff Starrs 10:25:50 02/22/06 (2)

Re: Voluntary death is illegal. Therefore, it is also illegal to let an individual choose between life and death --mt - Arya 10:38:48 02/22/06 (1)

Re: Voluntary death is illegal. Therefore, it is also illegal to let an individual choose between life and death --mt - Jeff Starrs 10:47:03 02/22/06 (0)

Good point - GliderGuider 09:45:09 02/22/06 (1)

Re: Unbelievable... - Jeff Starrs 09:56:55 02/22/06 (0)

That's a no-brainer - the mother - GliderGuider 09:37:30 02/22/06 (1)

Re: That's a no-brainer - the mother / Absolutely. Even a brainless mother (!) * - Guy 04:00:30 02/23/06 (0)

C. Everett Koop does not know of a single case in which abortion was necessary to save the mother's life-do you? nt - padreken 09:36:37 02/22/06 (20)

Re: Maybe Koop has been cooped up for too long. * - Guy 04:01:47 02/23/06 (0)

Therefor, there has never been one. - Jim Carlon 10:01:35 02/22/06 (2)

Do you know of any actual documented "late term abotrtions"? (nt) - mkuller 10:08:18 02/22/06 (1)

Who cares? Koop isn't familiar with every abortion on the planet. - Jim Carlon 10:44:54 02/22/06 (0)

Three courts, including the supreme court disagreed --mt - Arya 09:45:40 02/22/06 (15)

No they didn't - PabloP 09:51:34 02/22/06 (11)

Just heard it on the radio this morning - Arya 09:55:35 02/22/06 (10)

losing it, guys? - Bruce from DC 11:38:55 02/22/06 (4)

That's a bit disinginuous, isn't it? - Gene W 15:31:11 02/22/06 (0)

What? - PabloP 11:49:44 02/22/06 (2)

Thank God you are a lawyer, not someone in the Health Care business, Phew, just the thought alone is frightening! nt - PriyaW 14:26:49 02/22/06 (0)

Ah so - Bruce from DC 13:41:26 02/22/06 (0)

You should stop listening to the radio (nt) - PabloP 09:59:01 02/22/06 (4)

and believe some anonymous poster writes on the internet, who doesn bother spending 30 secs to check the facts? --mt - Arya 10:02:07 02/22/06 (3)

More likely accurate than the radio (link) - PabloP 10:09:01 02/22/06 (2)

Not at all. Radio report gave more indepth info.... - Arya 10:14:04 02/22/06 (1)

I see, the reason you listen to the radio is you can't read (nt). - PabloP 10:21:30 02/22/06 (0)

Didn't know judges were medical experts.* - HiFi Guy 09:47:19 02/22/06 (2)

neither are priests..... - Arya 09:49:41 02/22/06 (1)

Re: neither are priests..... - HiFi Guy 10:05:27 02/22/06 (0)

Is that even a serious question? Mother of course...nt - ToshiroofKreplachastan 09:36:17 02/22/06 (0)

Follow Ups

Doctors? - Marshall W 02/22/0611:00:50 02/22/06 (1)

Re: Doctors? - Gene W 14:48:15 02/22/06 (0)

Post a Message!