RE: F. Charles Adler did not record the 8th. He did however record...

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Mahler 9th Orgy: Klemperer, Barbirolli, and Kubelik. I was going to give Kubelik 1st prize, until... - jdaniel@jps.net 22:16:34 02/10/13 (48)

Does anyone make a really bad performance of this symphony? - Frihed89 00:29:53 02/14/13 (3)

Well, the traps: the 1st mov't can easliy collapse, the 2nd gets played too politely, the 3rd too careful and - jdaniel@jps.net 07:49:30 02/14/13 (0)

RE: Does anyone make a really bad performance of this symphony? - Chuck Y 07:22:44 02/14/13 (1)

OOps the last one: 6th. Sorry - Frihed89 08:34:26 02/14/13 (0)

RE: Now for a different take.... - Ivan303 10:12:05 02/13/13 (6)

During my brief love affair with SACD, I had the Chailly 3rd and 9th: stunning stunning sound and playing. nt - jdaniel@jps.net 19:03:03 02/13/13 (5)

Streaming the Barbirolli at the moment... - Ivan303 20:21:46 02/13/13 (4)

Me too. 4th mov't. Loveliness aside, the Berliners-esp the strings-are pretty sloppy. nt - jdaniel@jps.net 20:32:17 02/13/13 (3)

Another winner... - Ivan303 21:37:45 02/13/13 (2)

You know the gossip around that one? The whole trombone section misses the most important entrance.... - jdaniel@jps.net 07:50:58 02/14/13 (0)

We agree. - Chuck Y 07:28:48 02/14/13 (0)

Walter's 9th re-issue - Amphissa 15:22:58 02/12/13 (1)

I wish I like Walter's Mahler but the 4th mov't taken at roughly 18 minutes? Kubelik's "flowing" tempo clocks - jdaniel@jps.net 16:09:24 02/12/13 (0)

Hmmm ... I wasn't aware that Kubelik's Mahler had been "overshadowed" - Amphissa 13:35:27 02/12/13 (1)

I should say, "overlooked". By me. nt - jdaniel@jps.net 17:09:20 02/12/13 (0)

I'm a fan of the Abbado/Berlin Phil live 9th - jult52 01:19:32 02/12/13 (0)

Hey, how about Walter's premier recording with the VPO? - Poles Apart 18:40:16 02/11/13 (6)

Thanks, I'll check-out the Mitro. I'm with Hurwitz regarding the '38 9th. Was just listening to Walter's - jdaniel@jps.net 18:49:10 02/11/13 (5)

The Reiner was my learning recording, but now I find it on the bland side. - Poles Apart 20:22:13 02/11/13 (4)

RE: The Reiner was my learning recording, but now I find it on the bland side. - Tony Lauck 08:40:06 02/12/13 (3)

What?! You learned on the Thorborg Schuricht? - Poles Apart 10:18:04 02/12/13 (2)

RE: What?! You learned on the Thorborg Schuricht? - Tony Lauck 10:23:01 02/12/13 (1)

Yes! Thorborg Schuricht!! NT - Poles Apart 15:09:16 02/12/13 (0)

RE: Mahler 9th Orgy: Klemperer, Barbirolli, and Kubelik. I was going to give Kubelik 1st prize, until... - pbarach 14:14:37 02/11/13 (1)

What examples would you give, that Kubelik's orchestra doesn't measure up. Frankly I'm quite surprised by the - jdaniel@jps.net 18:25:37 02/11/13 (0)

it's reviews like this,,, - tesla 13:36:45 02/11/13 (15)

RE: it's reviews like this,,, - rbolaw 10:16:17 02/13/13 (0)

You're missing the point: the beauty of Mahler, (and sex) is that there is no "perfect" performance. nt - jdaniel@jps.net 19:08:02 02/11/13 (0)

Is "knowing" a composer all it's about? I love Walter's Mahler 4th, but come to find out that one of his major - jdaniel@jps.net 18:31:16 02/11/13 (0)

AFAIK, - John Marks 15:10:12 02/11/13 (11)

I know of 5 - Amphissa 13:21:34 02/12/13 (3)

F. Charles Adler did not record the 8th. He did however record... - Poles Apart 16:05:27 02/12/13 (2)

RE: F. Charles Adler did not record the 8th. He did however record... - Tom B. 02/20/1317:04:44 02/20/13 (0)

RE: F. Charles Adler did not record the 8th. He did however record... - Amphissa 18:42:15 02/12/13 (0)

Mengelberg count as modern era? (nt) - John N 19:22:42 02/11/13 (2)

Sorry, I meant modern recording technology - John Marks 06:58:12 02/12/13 (1)

"modern recording technology"? - Amphissa 15:16:13 02/12/13 (0)

Klemperer wrote a book, Remembrances of Gustav Mahler. And... - Poles Apart 18:34:43 02/11/13 (0)

Wouldn't Klemperer qualify, too? nt - srl1 17:18:34 02/11/13 (2)

Sorry, I inverted his and Walter's dates - John Marks 06:56:09 02/12/13 (0)

Certainly (nt) - briggs 05:12:56 02/12/13 (0)

"Walter's 'band'"? - briggs 07:07:04 02/11/13 (3)

Hey, I've defended Walter's band--it's hard marching to Mahler. Seriously, I've defended his "band(s)" when - jdaniel@jps.net 08:11:16 02/11/13 (2)

Some of the players were pretty legendary.... - C.B. 07:47:03 02/14/13 (1)

Thanks, was looking for that info. nt - jdaniel@jps.net 07:52:03 02/14/13 (0)

Dick Shahinian's favorite, I believe, was Barbirolli - John Marks 06:21:44 02/11/13 (2)

Right on the money, John... - tonyptony 15:41:19 02/11/13 (0)

I'm finding myself leaning that way, w/Giulini's Chicago, but the moods Kubelik creates in the 1st mov't.... - jdaniel@jps.net 08:08:35 02/11/13 (0)

Follow Ups

RE: F. Charles Adler did not record the 8th. He did however record... - Tom B. 02/20/1317:04:44 02/20/13 (0)

Post a Message!