Are we talking 10 favorties or 10 greatest?

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - His Top 10 are certainly not mine - Amphissa 12:10:25 01/21/11 (118)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - learsfool 06:44:32 01/26/11 (1)

learsfool - jult52 09:37:29 01/26/11 (0)

Wow, Atterburg on your list - madisonears 15:01:19 01/24/11 (2)

RE: Wow, Atterburg on your list - Amphissa 18:36:25 01/24/11 (1)

Atterburg 's Symphonies can be a bit of a chore...... - Chuck Y 16:02:59 01/25/11 (0)

10 Alphabetically - ArdRi 13:58:03 01/24/11 (4)

Chausson - I like Viviane quite a bit. - jult52 06:42:59 01/25/11 (0)

The painting ... - Amphissa 18:40:22 01/24/11 (2)

I find in Moeran I think just a smidge broader - ArdRi 20:18:39 01/24/11 (1)

Moeran is excellent..... - Chuck Y 15:46:40 01/25/11 (0)

Tomassini is on my list... - Bill Way 12:34:32 01/24/11 (1)

I don't think Tommasini's effort was so bad - jult52 12:38:24 01/24/11 (0)

I Like Your List - Mike Porper 09:40:55 01/24/11 (2)

RE: I Like Your List - Amphissa 12:49:03 01/24/11 (1)

"But on the whole I just don't enjoy listening to his [Shostakovich's] music" - Chris from Lafayette 18:01:03 01/24/11 (0)

RE: Top 10 - MichaelV8 08:30:42 01/24/11 (0)

I tabulated the results for all these lists - puremusic 23:40:38 01/23/11 (8)

Boiled down to top ten greatest except . . . - Mali 16:30:04 01/24/11 (0)

I'd have to say that - kavakidd 15:29:56 01/24/11 (0)

Bartok lovers - Amphissa 06:59:54 01/24/11 (5)

Are symphonies and concertos the essential signs of a great composer? NT - David Aiken 14:18:51 01/24/11 (1)

Absolutely not. - Mali 16:37:01 01/24/11 (0)

RE: Bartok lovers - garrod 07:40:21 01/24/11 (2)

RE: Bartok lovers - Amphissa 08:15:20 01/24/11 (1)

RE: Bartok lovers - garrod 07:49:33 01/25/11 (0)

I hfta wonder why - kavakidd 23:16:59 01/23/11 (2)

RE: I hfta wonder why - Amphissa 07:16:31 01/24/11 (0)

"10 most overrated composers" - farfetched 01:02:14 01/24/11 (0)

Gee?! Okay then! - Timbo in Oz 19:22:33 01/23/11 (5)

RE: Gee?! Okay then! - Mali 16:48:50 01/24/11 (4)

I sing at St Pauls, Manuka in Canberra, Australia's capital. - Timbo in Oz 18:47:53 01/24/11 (3)

RE: I sing at St Pauls, Manuka in Canberra, Australia's capital. - Mali 19:32:04 01/24/11 (2)

No Choir School - we do a sung evensong about ten times a year - Timbo in Oz 23:31:17 01/24/11 (1)

RE: No Choir School - we do a sung evensong about ten times a year - Mali 16:02:26 01/25/11 (0)

Instead of arguing, I decided to just listen - Pivo 19:20:19 01/23/11 (0)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - Peter TeHone 08:53:38 01/23/11 (0)

Are we talking 10 favorties or 10 greatest? - Tadlo 01/23/1105:38:08 01/23/11 (9)

Bringing up your larger question - Chris from Lafayette 21:13:25 01/23/11 (4)

Exactly - Amphissa 08:09:36 01/24/11 (3)

RE: Exactly - Chris from Lafayette 18:09:03 01/24/11 (0)

RE: Exactly - Tadlo 11:33:36 01/24/11 (0)

Interesting, but..... - puremusic 10:15:33 01/24/11 (0)

"many are not remotely plausible as 10 greatest" - Chris from Lafayette 14:05:58 01/23/11 (1)

agree wholeheartedly nt - farfetched 01:03:20 01/24/11 (0)

Read the original post [nt] - Amphissa 09:36:53 01/23/11 (1)

RE: Read the original post [nt] - Tadlo 11:35:26 01/24/11 (0)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - John N 18:46:59 01/22/11 (0)

Top 10, for now... - genungo 17:51:02 01/22/11 (2)

I thought i would be alone on Ives Nt - Frihed89 01:14:29 01/23/11 (1)

RE: I thought i would be alone on Ives - genungo 01:25:23 01/23/11 (0)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - puremusic 13:11:48 01/22/11 (0)

This really isn't easy - srl1 12:42:56 01/22/11 (0)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - Pat D 11:30:54 01/22/11 (0)

The correct answer is... - Tadlo 09:03:50 01/22/11 (3)

Wow! - Only ONE non-Germanic composer on that list - Chris from Lafayette 18:47:10 01/22/11 (2)

RE: Wow! - Only ONE non-Germanic composer on that list - Tadlo 05:35:41 01/23/11 (1)

Then you didn't answer the question that was posed [nt] - Amphissa 09:38:22 01/23/11 (0)

I hardly know the names of 10 composers, let alone their work - Frihed89 03:11:40 01/22/11 (3)

Where's Beethoven? - Mali 15:20:59 01/23/11 (2)

RE: Where's Beethoven? - Frihed89 01:19:30 01/26/11 (1)

RE: Where's Beethoven? - Mali 09:22:13 01/27/11 (0)

My top 10… - David Aiken 23:53:48 01/21/11 (0)

As promised, My Wife's Top Ten - Chris from Lafayette 23:46:03 01/21/11 (3)

Glad to see Brahms - jult52 07:02:32 01/22/11 (2)

RE: Glad to see Brahms - Amphissa 09:48:16 01/22/11 (1)

Have to disagree with this statement - jult52 11:57:17 01/22/11 (0)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - jazz1 23:12:05 01/21/11 (1)

I wish I had you courage!!!!!! and I think you'd love Geoffrey Lanacaster's CD's of H's piano Sonatas. - Timbo in Oz 19:27:59 01/23/11 (0)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - Mali 22:08:00 01/21/11 (0)

Can't count.... - jimbill 20:22:24 01/21/11 (0)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - docw 19:33:52 01/21/11 (10)

docw like many other on the Times thread - jult52 07:00:43 01/22/11 (9)

Speaking as another P.-I.-lister … - Charlie F. 13:22:08 01/22/11 (7)

RE: Speaking as another P.-I.-lister … - Amphissa 14:30:06 01/22/11 (6)

Amphissa - jult52 05:07:43 01/23/11 (1)

RE: Amphissa - Amphissa 15:01:02 01/23/11 (0)

RE: Speaking as another P.-I.-lister … - Todd Krieger 14:40:24 01/22/11 (3)

Agreed! - Charlie F. 14:56:24 01/22/11 (2)

Winter Dreams, FWIW is after many years one of the few - Chuck Y 11:09:17 01/23/11 (0)

RE: Agreed! - Amphissa 18:11:36 01/22/11 (0)

RE: docw like many other on the Times thread - docw 12:17:25 01/22/11 (0)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - classfolkphile 19:02:18 01/21/11 (0)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - Todd Krieger 18:34:41 01/21/11 (2)

The Obscure Liszt.................. - Todd Krieger 18:55:41 01/21/11 (1)

RE: The Obscure Liszt.................. - Amphissa 18:18:27 01/22/11 (0)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - cycletemp 16:11:10 01/21/11 (2)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - Amphissa 16:33:49 01/21/11 (1)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - cycletemp 17:50:10 01/21/11 (0)

An obvious list, but as with all "great" lists, there is - tinear 16:03:30 01/21/11 (4)

RE: An obvious list, but as with all "great" lists, there is - Amphissa 16:31:43 01/21/11 (3)

In my case, the consensus greatest also are mine. I'm a pretty - tinear 20:53:50 01/21/11 (2)

RE: In my case, the consensus greatest also are mine. I'm a pretty - Amphissa 09:38:48 01/22/11 (1)

All I saw in the header was "top 10." But, again to answer - tinear 12:48:06 01/22/11 (0)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - k-k-k-kenny 16:00:42 01/21/11 (2)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - Amphissa 16:29:50 01/21/11 (1)

He sure is - k-k-k-kenny 21:51:13 01/21/11 (0)

For their entire body of work, - madisonears 15:42:32 01/21/11 (1)

RE: For their entire body of work, - Amphissa 16:27:14 01/21/11 (0)

I Think These Are My Top 10 - Charlie F. 15:18:40 01/21/11 (2)

RE: I Think These Are My Top 10 - Amphissa 16:24:31 01/21/11 (1)

RE: I Think These Are My Top 10 - Charlie F. 17:09:30 01/21/11 (0)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - Daverz 15:02:23 01/21/11 (1)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - Amphissa 16:19:51 01/21/11 (0)

Actually, I like your list quite a bit! - Chris from Lafayette 14:58:55 01/21/11 (4)

There's a typo on your list... - Doktor Brahms 07:48:59 01/22/11 (1)

RE: There's a typo on your list... - Chris from Lafayette 08:23:08 01/22/11 (0)

RE: Actually, I like your list quite a bit! - Amphissa 16:18:37 01/21/11 (1)

The thing about Medtner. . . - Chris from Lafayette 23:51:51 01/21/11 (0)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - Chuck Y 14:45:32 01/21/11 (7)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - Amphissa 16:16:53 01/21/11 (6)

These I find engaging and frequently revisited. - Chuck Y 16:41:17 01/21/11 (5)

RE: These I find engaging and frequently revisited. - Amphissa 18:25:26 01/22/11 (4)

Chandos' series of Stanford's music contains a performance I really like.... - Chuck Y 11:18:21 01/23/11 (3)

RE: Chandos' series of Stanford's music contains a performance I really like.... - Amphissa 08:30:45 01/24/11 (1)

I have Perry's and Bennetts....... - Chuck Y 15:34:31 01/25/11 (0)

Yes, I like that disc, too. But haven't listened to it in probably years.* - Mali 15:22:12 01/23/11 (0)

Bartok - mwhitmore 13:11:21 01/21/11 (0)

RE: His Top 10 are certainly not mine - DemSpinner 12:53:20 01/21/11 (0)

Follow Ups

Are we talking 10 favorties or 10 greatest? - Tadlo 01/23/1105:38:08 01/23/11 (9)

Bringing up your larger question - Chris from Lafayette 21:13:25 01/23/11 (4)

Exactly - Amphissa 08:09:36 01/24/11 (3)

RE: Exactly - Chris from Lafayette 18:09:03 01/24/11 (0)

RE: Exactly - Tadlo 11:33:36 01/24/11 (0)

Interesting, but..... - puremusic 10:15:33 01/24/11 (0)

"many are not remotely plausible as 10 greatest" - Chris from Lafayette 14:05:58 01/23/11 (1)

agree wholeheartedly nt - farfetched 01:03:20 01/24/11 (0)

Read the original post [nt] - Amphissa 09:36:53 01/23/11 (1)

RE: Read the original post [nt] - Tadlo 11:35:26 01/24/11 (0)

Post a Message!