In Reply to: RE: 'Where's the beef?' - Magnepan must've added steroids to the 3.7i. posted by Norman M on June 8, 2015 at 15:18:22:
Your rig is very impressive, and I wouldn't dispute anything you've done to maximize your systems potential. We've just taken different paths to achieve satisfying sound. I'm sure that bi-amping and signal processing adds benefits as well as the quality of amplification, but the role room dimensions play is more complex.I have no idea what the world's greatest amplifier is as each amp design brings it's own baggage and benefits. Bryston has a great reputation and an excellent warranty (Wendell Diller apparently likes 'em a lot too). Given the difference between the Tympanies and less demanding 3.7i (driven full range) it's hard to say how much difference there might be between bi-amped Bryston 7BST and 4BSST (800 wpc & 500 wpc) and Sanders Magtech (900 wpc) when considered with other variables (room dimension, powered subwoofer, ceiling height, etc.). I certainly don't have the answer, but it's interesting nonetheless.
With careful speaker placement, first class amplification and figuring out the best ways to take advantage of room layout dimensional realism can be achieved. At this point I'm very comfortable with my system. My listening room is lively and the presentation robust. I haven't heard the Tympanies (which I'm sure are awesome to behold) and I don't believe you've heard the 3.7i Maggies with a Magtech amp in a similar setting to mine. We both may be predisposed to certain biases based on what we're familiar with compared to what we've owned before. I'm not saying you're incorrect in your assessments by any means, but my experience has been that it's often easier to criticize in absence of similar experiences.
Cheers,
AuPh
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: 'Where's the beef?' - Magnepan must've added steroids to the 3.7i. - Audiophilander 06/8/1522:35:51 06/8/15 (42)
- RE: 'Where's the beef?' - Magnepan must've added steroids to the 3.7i. - Swamis Cat 11:40:54 06/9/15 (39)
- RE: 'Where's the beef?' - Magnepan must've added steroids to the 3.7i. - raya 17:08:46 06/9/15 (38)
- With that sweet system you can borrow my club pass... - Audiophilander 23:23:22 06/9/15 (33)
- RE: With that sweet system you can borrow my club pass... - raya 13:08:42 06/10/15 (32)
- RE: With that sweet system you can borrow my club pass... - Audiophilander 02:47:51 06/11/15 (31)
- RE: With that sweet system you can borrow my club pass... - Norman M 08:15:28 06/12/15 (12)
- I understand where your caution comes from, but it's unwarranted. - Audiophilander 00:43:17 06/13/15 (10)
- RE: I understand where your caution comes from, but it's unwarranted. - Norman M 02:06:51 06/13/15 (9)
- No conclusion jumping was attempted but I may be guilty of trying to raise the bar a bit. - Audiophilander 03:45:57 06/13/15 (8)
- RE: No conclusion jumping was attempted but I may be guilty of trying to raise the bar a bit. - Norman M 08:24:43 06/13/15 (7)
- I understand your perspective... - Mark Man 09:15:06 06/13/15 (6)
- RE: I understand your perspective... - Norman M 10:37:37 06/13/15 (5)
- RE: I understand your perspective... - Audiophilander 11:48:03 06/14/15 (4)
- RE: I understand your perspective... - Norman M 17:43:02 06/14/15 (3)
- Your opinion is very meaningful. - Audiophilander 01:48:16 06/15/15 (1)
- RE: Your opinion is very meaningful. - Norman M 08:10:43 06/15/15 (0)
- RE: I understand your perspective... - Satie 19:46:15 06/14/15 (0)
- I think once you spoke to Roger Sanders... - Mark Man 12:07:03 06/12/15 (0)
- RE: With that sweet system you can borrow my club pass... - raya 06:40:21 06/11/15 (17)
- RE: With that sweet system you can borrow my club pass... - JBen 10:49:43 06/11/15 (3)
- RE: With that sweet system you can borrow my club pass... - macmagman 21:15:46 06/11/15 (2)
- RE: With that sweet system you can borrow my club pass... - JBen 21:50:26 06/11/15 (1)
- YES...Neo...he is the one... - Mark Man 12:24:39 06/12/15 (0)
- a million ways to get things done... - Mark Man 09:36:42 06/11/15 (12)
- Yeah, but I cheated. - wazoo 11:02:33 06/11/15 (11)
- RE: Yeah, but I cheated. - Mark Man 12:10:25 06/12/15 (10)
- It's an important detail. - wazoo 18:50:48 06/12/15 (9)
- RE: It's an important detail. - Satie 21:38:24 06/12/15 (8)
- Hmm, you know... - wazoo 10:00:49 06/13/15 (7)
- RE: Hmm, you know... - Satie 10:09:09 06/13/15 (6)
- Actually, they are the L/Rs in the main system,... - wazoo 14:53:10 06/13/15 (5)
- RE: Actually, they are the L/Rs in the main system,... - Satie 19:58:44 06/13/15 (4)
- Well, ... - wazoo 07:36:49 06/14/15 (3)
- RE: Well, ... - Norman M 09:40:32 06/14/15 (2)
- Imagine that - nutso behavior in an asylum. :-) - wazoo 10:41:20 06/14/15 (1)
- RE: Imagine that - nutso behavior in an asylum. :-) - Norman M 11:40:24 06/14/15 (0)
- RE: 'Where's the beef?' - Magnepan must've added steroids to the 3.7i. - JBen 23:16:45 06/9/15 (0)
- RE: 'Where's the beef?' - Magnepan must've added steroids to the 3.7i. - Satie 21:00:17 06/9/15 (0)
- RE: 'Where's the beef?' - Magnepan must've added steroids to the 3.7i. - Davey 19:35:31 06/9/15 (0)
- RE: 'Where's the beef?' - Magnepan must've added steroids to the 3.7i. - Green Lantern 18:45:27 06/9/15 (0)
- RE: 'Where's the beef?' - Magnepan must've added steroids to the 3.7i. - Satie 11:27:06 06/9/15 (1)
- Interesting observations. - Audiophilander 16:55:16 06/9/15 (0)