When I was first introudced to high end audio the local shop was a dealer for Martin Logan and Apogee. There was a shop in Seattle that had Magnepan, and another had Acoustat. I always dreamed about owning panels, but as a poor college student that was not going to happen.
A number of years ago I had an interim system consisting of Acoustat 1+1, the TBT200 amplifier, and TNP pre-amp. At that time I was deep into SET amps, but I had to sell a system and this was an opportunity that presented itself as a friend of mine had picked these pieces up.
What I found is that the speakers created a huge image, larger than life really and I found it quite disconcerting. I also found the presentation to be tonally grey, where everything sounded like it was mixed the same. I moved on from these pieces.
But I have not given up on the dream. I wonder if this image size is related to panel size? I have heard similar effects on some of the larger magnepans, and I wonder if its because the panel portion is run full range and its a factor of size. Of course the drawback is that you need square inches of panel to gain efficiency and realistic dynamic output.
Any observations?
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - Large Format Panel Type Speakers and Image Size - Mister Pig 08:35:01 03/30/23 (16)
- RE: Large Format Panel Type Speakers and Image Size - SoundMann 16:41:02 04/6/23 (0)
- RE: Large Format Panel Type Speakers and Image Size - triamp 03:19:20 04/5/23 (0)
- RE: Large Format Panel Type Speakers and Image Size - Satie 09:12:07 04/1/23 (3)
- RE: Large Format Panel Type Speakers and Image SizeIMO - bluesy41 21:41:10 04/2/23 (2)
- RE: Large Format Panel Type Speakers and Image SizeIMO - Satie 23:31:26 04/4/23 (1)
- RE: Large Format Panel Type Speakers and Image SizeIMO - bluesy41 15:33:03 04/6/23 (0)
- I periodically switch back and forth between my large Maggies... - MWE 12:59:17 03/30/23 (0)
- RE: Large Format Panel Type Speakers and Image Size - G Squared 09:32:06 03/30/23 (0)
- RE: Large Format Panel Type Speakers and Image Size - Davey 08:58:27 03/30/23 (5)
- RE: Large Format Panel Type Speakers and Image Size - Mister Pig 09:13:46 03/30/23 (4)
- RE: Large Format Panel Type Speakers and Image Size - Davey 09:16:22 03/30/23 (3)
- RE: Large Format Panel Type Speakers and Image Size - Mister Pig 09:18:14 03/30/23 (2)
- RE: Large Format Panel Type Speakers and Image Size - Davey 09:23:44 03/30/23 (1)
- RE: Large Format Panel Type Speakers and Image Size - Mister Pig 09:48:10 03/30/23 (0)
- RE: Large Format Panel Type Speakers and Image Size - E-Stat 08:49:54 03/30/23 (1)
- Yes, agreed, the recording MUST be part of the equation. It's not just the speaker. nt. - MWE 12:22:41 03/30/23 (0)