In Reply to: What if? posted by TDM on January 25, 2006 at 06:30:29:
I have always been concerned with the Unity approach because it seems to discount the fact that the sound from the drivers closer to the mouth also goes back down the horn body and reflects off of the other drivers thereby creating a secondary sound source which is significantly delayed from the first - usually a bad thing. The extent to which this is a problem is unknow to me since I have no data, but at first look it appeared that this could be an achiles heal to the design.Perhaps Tom has some data that he can share showing the unEQ'd frequency response of a unity horn on axis. Seperatly for each set of drivers would be most enlightening.
Now for Pro usage, which I think was Tom's target application, this design has some real merits in its ability to "cluster" the multiple drivers required for very high SPLs into a small package. The tradeoffs here are very different and I might prefer Tom's approach to the line array approach that we see so often and which has some eal problems itself. But for home use where SPL is not a problem I think that there are cleaner approaches to the problem.
Earl Geddes
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- There are other problems here - EGeddes 01/25/0607:04:55 01/25/06 (27)
- Re: are there, other problems here - tomservo 18:23:34 01/25/06 (24)
- Re: are there, other problems here- fix that karlson - lol - freddyi 15:13:58 01/26/06 (0)
- Interesting - EGeddes 08:27:04 01/26/06 (22)
- Re: Interesting - tomservo 06:08:33 01/27/06 (21)
- I tried - EGeddes 06:30:58 01/27/06 (0)
- But its not an open standard - EGeddes 06:15:49 01/27/06 (19)
- Re: But its not an open standard - tomservo 09:37:19 01/27/06 (18)
- I know - EGeddes 09:48:00 01/27/06 (17)
- Re: I know - tomservo 12:35:08 01/28/06 (1)
- I can probably do it - EGeddes 12:23:55 01/29/06 (0)
- Re: I know - bzdang 13:59:47 01/27/06 (14)
- No - EGeddes 14:29:02 01/27/06 (11)
- Polar maps are great! - John Sheerin 15:46:54 01/27/06 (10)
- Re: Polar maps are great! - EGeddes 18:13:49 01/27/06 (8)
- Re: Polar maps are great! - John Sheerin 18:18:57 01/27/06 (7)
- OK so what was - EGeddes 18:53:41 01/27/06 (6)
- Re: OK so what was - John Sheerin 06:45:04 01/28/06 (5)
- One more thing - EGeddes 07:19:58 01/28/06 (0)
- FEA vs BEM - EGeddes 07:12:59 01/28/06 (3)
- Re: FEA vs BEM - John Sheerin 07:47:41 01/28/06 (2)
- Re: FEA vs BEM - EGeddes 08:44:52 01/28/06 (1)
- Re: FEA vs BEM vs "what do I want" - freddyi 12:13:46 01/28/06 (0)
- Thanks for the clarification - bzdang 17:38:46 01/27/06 (0)
- Re: I know - kool - freddyi 14:11:43 01/27/06 (1)
- Re: I know - kool - bzdang 14:13:49 01/27/06 (0)
- Re: There are other problems here - Mark Seaton 08:30:18 01/25/06 (1)
- I will wait - EGeddes 07:57:23 01/26/06 (0)