In Reply to: New laser plays SACD's posted by madisonears on March 3, 2018 at 14:38:47:
Abe did the math correctly, but based on faulty input data.
The original and replacement lasers did not last average 4 years. All of them failed to perfectly play hybrids after only two or so years. Redbook and single layer SACD's were never a problem. I endured listening to the less than optimal configuration for quite some time before servicing. Sometimes a hybrid disc would play fine, other times it would skip a few seconds of music, rarely but shockingly it would lose tracking and emit a god awful loud noise that sounded a lot like a needle skimming across vinyl. Talk about analog sound! Eventually the machine could not even initialize some hybrid discs in either redbook or SACD mode.
IMPORTANT for Marantz owners, possibly others:
The last time the machine was serviced, at my expense, the tech adjusted the firmware of the player so that hybrid SACD's would not play automatically, but rather default to redbook layer, which usually played without a problem. I appreciated this strategy as a way to conserve the laser for when I really wanted to listen critically, in which case the SACD layer was accessed via the front panel/remote "Sound Mode" button. With this new laser installed by me, the firmware update remains in effect and I must select SACD when playing hybrids. Single layer SACD's play fine, and always have, even when the laser was getting finicky.
If you're paying to have your machine serviced by a competent technician or you have access to a service manual that describes how it's done, you should consider tweaking the firmware to default to CD mode unless commanded otherwise. Listening to SACD is not always necessary if it saves a bit of laser life.
Peace,
Tom E
berate is 8 and benign is 9
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- addendum and critical advice - madisonears 03/5/1817:53:56 03/5/18 (37)
- RE: addendum and critical advice - Gerry E. 05:55:40 03/7/18 (35)
- RE: addendum and critical advice - fantja 03:59:40 03/8/18 (0)
- you misunderstood - madisonears 18:27:30 03/7/18 (33)
- RE: you misunderstood - airheadair 09:12:38 03/8/18 (27)
- That is such nonsense about Cd layer on SACD being made inferior. Total bogus nonsense. - toothpaste 14:40:41 04/19/18 (1)
- RE: That is such nonsense about Cd layer on SACD being made inferior. Total bogus nonsense. - fantja 20:01:44 04/20/18 (0)
- RE: you misunderstood - Bruce from DC 12:40:30 03/8/18 (22)
- Straw Man alert! - Chris from Lafayette 13:57:03 03/8/18 (20)
- Just to mention I am one who prefers CD to SACD. True about the odd sound of SACD. - toothpaste 12:40:20 04/12/18 (10)
- RE: Just to mention I am one who prefers CD to SACD. True about the odd sound of SACD. - fantja 16:01:25 04/13/18 (0)
- RE: Just to mention I am one who prefers CD to SACD. True about the odd sound of SACD. - fantja 23:06:17 04/12/18 (8)
- Audio Emporium Brown Deer WI (suburb of Milwaukee) - toothpaste 07:26:37 04/14/18 (1)
- RE: Audio Emporium Brown Deer WI (suburb of Milwaukee) - fantja 15:57:58 04/14/18 (0)
- RE: Just to mention I am one who prefers CD to SACD. True about the odd sound of SACD. - airheadair 10:05:45 04/13/18 (5)
- The person who had it for audition uses cheap transports for daily all day listening. Saving the $$$ laser - toothpaste 07:40:35 04/14/18 (1)
- RE: The person who had it for audition uses cheap transports for daily all day listening. Saving the $$$ laser - fantja 15:59:10 04/14/18 (0)
- RE: Just to mention I am one who prefers CD to SACD. True about the odd sound of SACD. - fantja 16:02:45 04/13/18 (2)
- RE: Just to mention I am one who prefers CD to SACD. True about the odd sound of SACD. - airheadair 17:33:41 04/13/18 (1)
- RE: Just to mention I am one who prefers CD to SACD. True about the odd sound of SACD. - fantja 18:49:55 04/13/18 (0)
- RE: Straw Man alert! - AbeCollins 21:14:48 03/15/18 (5)
- RE: Straw Man alert! - fantja 20:45:28 03/17/18 (4)
- RE: Straw Man alert! - AbeCollins 12:44:06 03/18/18 (3)
- RE: Straw Man alert! - fantja 19:29:41 03/19/18 (2)
- RE: Straw Man alert! - AbeCollins 14:42:53 03/22/18 (1)
- RE: Straw Man alert! - fantja 13:54:27 03/29/18 (0)
- RE: Straw Man alert! - Bruce from DC 21:08:54 03/8/18 (2)
- RE: Straw Man alert! - Chris from Lafayette 00:37:05 03/9/18 (0)
- RE: Straw Man alert! - fantja 23:38:37 03/8/18 (0)
- RE: you misunderstood - airheadair 13:38:15 03/8/18 (0)
- "I find his claim. . . very difficult to accept" - Yeah, so do I! - Chris from Lafayette 10:15:28 03/8/18 (1)
- RE: "I find his claim. . . very difficult to accept" - Yeah, so do I! - kenzo 09:35:49 03/18/18 (0)
- Are You Sure I Misunderstood? - Gerry E. 05:29:07 03/8/18 (3)
- Well, huh - madisonears 18:24:06 03/8/18 (1)
- RE: Well, huh - fantja 19:50:48 03/8/18 (0)
- Gerry - you are correct - one doesn't need a factory adjustment to set the default [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 10:06:55 03/8/18 (0)
- RE: you misunderstood - fantja 04:00:06 03/8/18 (0)
- RE: addendum and critical advice - fantja 05:02:34 03/6/18 (0)