I have a Marantz SA-11S1. It's a beautiful player, built like a tank, sounds awesome with the Blackgate output coupling caps I installed. It has a notoriously unreliable laser pick-up, a common fault among SACD players. Mine has failed three times during the 13 years I've owned it. Marantz covered replacement the first two times but I got stuck for almost $400 the third time, and then that failed to read hybrids a couple years ago. I was determined to not pay another bundle for repair of a device as crappy as this one, so I've been listening to single layer SACD's and the CD layer of hybrids for all that time, trying to figure out what else to do. Buy a newer model that has what must be a more reliable mechanism? Bite the bullet and send it off? Buy a new laser and install it myself? Give up on SACD hybrids and learn to be satisfied with redbook playback, which is also excellent but just not quite as good?
Option three proved to be the best. I bought a new pick-up on eBay for $20 and installed it yesterday. It wasn't the most complicated or difficult thing I've done to audio equipment, but it was harder than changing a light bulb. Only tools needed are a phillips screw driver, a soldering iron and desolder wick, a magnifier for my old eyes, and a steady hand. There is no circuitry to solder, but there are two tiny blobs of solder that connect the leads of the laser diode that must be removed after the new laser is hooked up. Easy as pie, as the solder melts at low temp and is readily accessible. Touch the tip of the iron to the wick on top of the blob, and in one second it's absorbed. There is a fine gauge ribbon with a dozen or so circuit paths that must be removed from the old laser and carefully plugged in to the new one, but just a bit of magnification and a gentle touch is needed as it pretty much aligns itself.
Total time is a couple hours to be really careful and thorough. Maybe a dozen or so screws to undo/replace. Nothing to align or check, just plug the machine back in, sit back, and let the sound wash over you. Last night I played the Analogue Productions SACD issue of Reiner's "Pines/Fountains of Rome" and it was amazing.
I just ordered five more lasers. By the time I've gone through all those, I won't be able to see well enough to repair it myself, and I probably won't be able to hear the difference anyway!
Peace,
Tom E
berate is 8 and benign is 9
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - New laser plays SACD's - madisonears 14:38:47 03/3/18 (62)
- addendum and critical advice - madisonears 17:53:56 03/5/18 (37)
- RE: addendum and critical advice - Gerry E. 05:55:40 03/7/18 (35)
- RE: addendum and critical advice - fantja 03:59:40 03/8/18 (0)
- you misunderstood - madisonears 18:27:30 03/7/18 (33)
- RE: you misunderstood - airheadair 09:12:38 03/8/18 (27)
- That is such nonsense about Cd layer on SACD being made inferior. Total bogus nonsense. - toothpaste 14:40:41 04/19/18 (1)
- RE: That is such nonsense about Cd layer on SACD being made inferior. Total bogus nonsense. - fantja 20:01:44 04/20/18 (0)
- RE: you misunderstood - Bruce from DC 12:40:30 03/8/18 (22)
- Straw Man alert! - Chris from Lafayette 13:57:03 03/8/18 (20)
- Just to mention I am one who prefers CD to SACD. True about the odd sound of SACD. - toothpaste 12:40:20 04/12/18 (10)
- RE: Just to mention I am one who prefers CD to SACD. True about the odd sound of SACD. - fantja 16:01:25 04/13/18 (0)
- RE: Just to mention I am one who prefers CD to SACD. True about the odd sound of SACD. - fantja 23:06:17 04/12/18 (8)
- Audio Emporium Brown Deer WI (suburb of Milwaukee) - toothpaste 07:26:37 04/14/18 (1)
- RE: Audio Emporium Brown Deer WI (suburb of Milwaukee) - fantja 15:57:58 04/14/18 (0)
- RE: Just to mention I am one who prefers CD to SACD. True about the odd sound of SACD. - airheadair 10:05:45 04/13/18 (5)
- The person who had it for audition uses cheap transports for daily all day listening. Saving the $$$ laser - toothpaste 07:40:35 04/14/18 (1)
- RE: The person who had it for audition uses cheap transports for daily all day listening. Saving the $$$ laser - fantja 15:59:10 04/14/18 (0)
- RE: Just to mention I am one who prefers CD to SACD. True about the odd sound of SACD. - fantja 16:02:45 04/13/18 (2)
- RE: Just to mention I am one who prefers CD to SACD. True about the odd sound of SACD. - airheadair 17:33:41 04/13/18 (1)
- RE: Just to mention I am one who prefers CD to SACD. True about the odd sound of SACD. - fantja 18:49:55 04/13/18 (0)
- RE: Straw Man alert! - AbeCollins 21:14:48 03/15/18 (5)
- RE: Straw Man alert! - fantja 20:45:28 03/17/18 (4)
- RE: Straw Man alert! - AbeCollins 12:44:06 03/18/18 (3)
- RE: Straw Man alert! - fantja 19:29:41 03/19/18 (2)
- RE: Straw Man alert! - AbeCollins 14:42:53 03/22/18 (1)
- RE: Straw Man alert! - fantja 13:54:27 03/29/18 (0)
- RE: Straw Man alert! - Bruce from DC 21:08:54 03/8/18 (2)
- RE: Straw Man alert! - Chris from Lafayette 00:37:05 03/9/18 (0)
- RE: Straw Man alert! - fantja 23:38:37 03/8/18 (0)
- RE: you misunderstood - airheadair 13:38:15 03/8/18 (0)
- "I find his claim. . . very difficult to accept" - Yeah, so do I! - Chris from Lafayette 10:15:28 03/8/18 (1)
- RE: "I find his claim. . . very difficult to accept" - Yeah, so do I! - kenzo 09:35:49 03/18/18 (0)
- Are You Sure I Misunderstood? - Gerry E. 05:29:07 03/8/18 (3)
- Well, huh - madisonears 18:24:06 03/8/18 (1)
- RE: Well, huh - fantja 19:50:48 03/8/18 (0)
- Gerry - you are correct - one doesn't need a factory adjustment to set the default [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 10:06:55 03/8/18 (0)
- RE: you misunderstood - fantja 04:00:06 03/8/18 (0)
- RE: addendum and critical advice - fantja 05:02:34 03/6/18 (0)
- RE: New laser plays SACD's - AbeCollins 11:34:17 03/5/18 (3)
- RE: New laser plays SACD's - fantja 13:36:42 03/5/18 (2)
- RE: New laser plays SACD's - AbeCollins 17:10:16 03/5/18 (1)
- RE: New laser plays SACD's - fantja 05:01:45 03/6/18 (0)
- RE: New laser plays SACD's - fantja 16:19:02 03/4/18 (0)
- RE: New laser plays SACD's - stvnharr 16:24:08 03/3/18 (12)
- you're right - madisonears 18:51:45 03/3/18 (11)
- RE: you're right - stvnharr 14:09:42 03/4/18 (10)
- RE: you're right - PAR 03:19:52 03/8/18 (0)
- RE: you're right - fantja 16:18:14 03/4/18 (8)
- RE: you're right - stvnharr 01:13:40 03/5/18 (7)
- RE: you're right - fantja 13:34:09 03/5/18 (6)
- RE: you're right - PAR 03:48:29 03/8/18 (5)
- RE: you're right - fantja 04:01:33 03/8/18 (4)
- RE: you're right - PAR 05:21:20 03/8/18 (3)
- RE: you're right - fantja 19:47:48 03/8/18 (2)
- RE: you're right - PAR 01:42:27 03/9/18 (1)
- RE: you're right - fantja 18:50:59 03/10/18 (0)
- RE: New laser plays SACD's - Bruce from DC 15:52:37 03/3/18 (5)
- I LOVE my Z1, and there's one at MD for $1200 or so! - oldmkvi 07:39:05 03/4/18 (3)
- What's "MD"? - Bruce from DC 08:34:54 03/4/18 (2)
- Yes, Music Direct, $1295 - oldmkvi 11:39:19 03/4/18 (1)
- Thanks! - Bruce from DC 13:39:48 03/4/18 (0)
- legitimate alternative - madisonears 19:00:21 03/3/18 (0)