A marketing ploy??!!! - Striving for Musical Clarity

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Will hi-res die? Killed off by MP3? - Feanor 14:59:15 06/25/03 (79)

Re: Will hi-res die? Killed off by MP3? - wgb113 04:47:11 06/26/03 (0)

Re: Will hi-res die? Killed off by MP3? - Striving for Musical Clarity 17:24:10 06/25/03 (51)

No?! I really, really hope your right - Feanor 19:31:21 06/25/03 (0)

OR: No cars have SACD except one. NO SACD has shown sales - Duilawyer 19:00:05 06/25/03 (49)

Sad ... - Striving for Musical Clarity 03:57:38 06/26/03 (36)

Hey guys and gals i don't know why you getting so upset over Duilawyer's remarks ... - Christine Tham 14:51:43 06/26/03 (7)

Show me my post that says SACD is, or will be a commercial success. - Duilawyer 20:39:33 06/26/03 (3)

That's the point, we'll know the format's really in deep sh*t when you post that one. nt - Methos 22:21:26 06/27/03 (2)

OK, show me a prediction I made that was wrong. - Duilawyer 09:42:18 06/28/03 (1)

Like shooting fish in a barrell - TheNewOrder 13:46:00 06/28/03 (0)

:-) This is the best post I have read in a long time - TheNewOrder 17:10:22 06/26/03 (2)

it's all quite logical really ... - Christine Tham 18:58:30 06/26/03 (1)

I did not buy an SACD player out of hatred, but out of hope. - Duilawyer 20:42:43 06/26/03 (0)

The truth hurts. All are welcome to "enjoy" SACD. I just - Duilawyer 06:38:20 06/26/03 (27)

Marketing ploy - rebop 11:41:37 06/26/03 (7)

Its called "excess spendable $$$". nt - Duilawyer 20:49:23 06/26/03 (0)

DUI is a lawyer, so I'm sure it helps sharpen his skills by playing Devil's Advocate. (nt) - Teresa 20:29:43 06/26/03 (5)

Well, I'm certainly impressed with his lawyerly prowess. Gosh, such masterful skills exhibited here. - Striving for Musical Clarity 00:12:36 06/27/03 (4)

Duh, did it dawn on you, I am not in court here? - Duilawyer 05:47:03 06/27/03 (2)

Hmmm ... - Striving for Musical Clarity 10:29:18 06/27/03 (1)

You make this nonsense up, or do you have help? - Duilawyer 20:59:10 06/27/03 (0)

You guys should show some empathy for DUI - Eric LeRouge 03:08:25 06/27/03 (0)

A marketing ploy??!!! - Striving for Musical Clarity 06/26/0307:26:18 06/26/03 (18)

I have said this a million times. I want a blind test on an - Duilawyer 20:54:48 06/26/03 (17)

here is my answer from the last time you asked this... - tunenut 09:20:00 06/27/03 (7)

I am sorry I forgot your post from Aug 2002. Shame on me! nt - Duilawyer 09:43:21 06/28/03 (6)

so am I wrong? - tunenut 10:35:29 06/28/03 (5)

I looked and could not find SMR. I don't have it. That is probably - Duilawyer 11:07:27 06/28/03 (4)

let's be scientific but let's also face reality... - tunenut 14:00:52 06/28/03 (1)

I also will buy only the SACD, where it and CD are available. - Duilawyer 19:32:15 06/28/03 (0)

$1800 on stereo gear - Metralla 12:13:51 06/28/03 (1)

A REL Stentor; but I ran into a problem. Only works in augment mode. - Duilawyer 19:29:08 06/28/03 (0)

Try "Lady Jane" [**VERY, VERY LONG REPLY--SORRY**] - rebop 08:39:58 06/27/03 (4)

Gave it the test! There is no appreciable difference. - Duilawyer 09:45:40 06/28/03 (2)

Re: Gave it the test! There is no appreciable difference. - rebop 07:34:36 06/30/03 (1)

"music industry desperately wants a secure digital format, and SACD provides it" - Metralla 07:47:09 06/30/03 (0)

I will give it a solid test, Saturday. Thanks for the response. nt - Duilawyer 22:05:38 06/27/03 (0)

Re: I have said this a million times. I want a blind test on an - Striving for Musical Clarity 22:29:24 06/26/03 (3)

OK, that last sentence is important - Eric LeRouge 02:58:59 06/27/03 (0)

Pick randomly. [nt] - Striving for Musical Clarity 00:03:34 06/27/03 (0)

Which song? Which passage? Or time, such as "on track 4 at 2:24.." nt - Duilawyer 22:43:15 06/26/03 (0)

DUI they are not all resurected recordings of artists you don't like, nearly 50% are brand new DSD - Teresa 22:12:06 06/25/03 (4)

Brand new recordings of nobodies. (2 exceptions) - Duilawyer 23:02:39 06/25/03 (3)

I'm sure that... - rebop 11:36:32 06/26/03 (2)

In terms of sales, they are non-existent, not just nobodies. nt - Duilawyer 20:55:43 06/26/03 (1)

By your standards... - rebop 08:29:04 06/27/03 (0)

So DUI - TheNewOrder 19:53:05 06/25/03 (6)

BTW: You (falsely) write that I hate SACD. Why misstate what I wrote? - Duilawyer 06:51:26 06/26/03 (2)

Re: BTW: You (falsely) write that I hate SACD. Why misstate what I wrote? - TheNewOrder 09:33:38 06/26/03 (0)

If almost none are worth owning... - rebop 08:44:39 06/26/03 (0)

That can be said of any post here. There are people who do not care. nt - Duilawyer 23:03:33 06/25/03 (2)

What a weak answer! - TheNewOrder 06:35:51 06/26/03 (1)

Don't read them. :-) nt - Duilawyer 06:48:15 06/26/03 (0)

exactly 3 years ago, on these boards... - tunenut 16:22:45 06/25/03 (21)

who says playing digital music is "easy" - Mellson 01:20:50 06/27/03 (1)

Might as well go back to vinyl - Feanor 08:08:15 06/27/03 (0)

Re: exactly 3 years ago, on these boards... - Jazz Inmate 16:58:34 06/25/03 (18)

This hobby is like any other... - rebop 12:06:39 06/26/03 (0)

I'm with you on this, Jazz - Jim Pearce 08:05:47 06/26/03 (0)

Can't find an LP Player for my Car.... - Tommart 21:16:01 06/25/03 (1)

You have to look hard but there was LP Player's for the Car, watch out for those pot holes - Teresa 22:19:35 06/25/03 (0)

I'm more or less half and half... - tunenut 19:58:49 06/25/03 (0)

but the hunt is half the fun, SACD will survive just as LP has, at least as a niche market, and It - Teresa 17:36:19 06/25/03 (12)

I'm with you... - JefferyK 13:19:15 06/26/03 (0)

Wrong. LP surivived because it was once ubiquitous. - Duilawyer 18:57:11 06/25/03 (10)

Vinyl also survives because.. - JCS 03:24:19 06/26/03 (9)

Completely true and you don't need an expensive turntable either. On my - Teresa 20:37:39 06/26/03 (2)

How much are audiophile LPs going for these days Teresa? [nt] - Striving for Musical Clarity 00:17:51 06/27/03 (1)

$15.99 - $35.00 per LP, yes they are on average more expensive than SACDs, but there are Sales and - Teresa 01:17:24 06/27/03 (0)

Good point. I am still amazed at how many times it beats SACD. - Duilawyer 06:42:41 06/26/03 (5)

Not which format is BEST, but which will have CHOICE of high-quality CONTENT - Feanor 08:32:27 06/27/03 (4)

I agree. We have to each factor in that garage full of records though. - Duilawyer 19:36:40 06/28/03 (0)

the short answer... - tunenut 09:03:16 06/27/03 (2)

to expand more on Tunenuts points, another reason to have both: - Teresa 17:30:18 06/27/03 (0)

I'm reassured to an extent - Feanor 09:51:09 06/27/03 (0)

I like Don MacLean's music, but he was a lousy prophet. (nt) - Audiophilander 15:46:54 06/25/03 (0)

Think of it this way - DAT 15:39:13 06/25/03 (0)

Time Will Tell But - Robertc88 15:30:04 06/25/03 (0)

Re: Wrong Forum... - thenexte 15:26:00 06/25/03 (0)

Follow Ups

A marketing ploy??!!! - Striving for Musical Clarity 06/26/0307:26:18 06/26/03 (18)

I have said this a million times. I want a blind test on an - Duilawyer 20:54:48 06/26/03 (17)

here is my answer from the last time you asked this... - tunenut 09:20:00 06/27/03 (7)

I am sorry I forgot your post from Aug 2002. Shame on me! nt - Duilawyer 09:43:21 06/28/03 (6)

so am I wrong? - tunenut 10:35:29 06/28/03 (5)

I looked and could not find SMR. I don't have it. That is probably - Duilawyer 11:07:27 06/28/03 (4)

let's be scientific but let's also face reality... - tunenut 14:00:52 06/28/03 (1)

I also will buy only the SACD, where it and CD are available. - Duilawyer 19:32:15 06/28/03 (0)

$1800 on stereo gear - Metralla 12:13:51 06/28/03 (1)

A REL Stentor; but I ran into a problem. Only works in augment mode. - Duilawyer 19:29:08 06/28/03 (0)

Try "Lady Jane" [**VERY, VERY LONG REPLY--SORRY**] - rebop 08:39:58 06/27/03 (4)

Gave it the test! There is no appreciable difference. - Duilawyer 09:45:40 06/28/03 (2)

Re: Gave it the test! There is no appreciable difference. - rebop 07:34:36 06/30/03 (1)

"music industry desperately wants a secure digital format, and SACD provides it" - Metralla 07:47:09 06/30/03 (0)

I will give it a solid test, Saturday. Thanks for the response. nt - Duilawyer 22:05:38 06/27/03 (0)

Re: I have said this a million times. I want a blind test on an - Striving for Musical Clarity 22:29:24 06/26/03 (3)

OK, that last sentence is important - Eric LeRouge 02:58:59 06/27/03 (0)

Pick randomly. [nt] - Striving for Musical Clarity 00:03:34 06/27/03 (0)

Which song? Which passage? Or time, such as "on track 4 at 2:24.." nt - Duilawyer 22:43:15 06/26/03 (0)