In Reply to: Will hi-res die? Killed off by MP3? posted by Feanor on June 25, 2003 at 14:59:15:
Well let's see here,1) CD sales are dropping significantly.
2) Music firmware companies, musicians, and music equipment manufactures have a huge stake in assuring a future firmware music format that has nothing to do with downloading music from a computer.
3) Several SACD Hybrid disc manufacturing plants have opened up recently.
4) There are already greater than 1100 SACDs on the market (don't know how many DVD-As) and they just keep coming.
5) The price of hybrid SACDs is fast approaching the price of a 16 bit CD. People like getting extra features for the money they spend, even if it means making use of those extra featrues at a future time.
5) The 2004 Acura will feature DVD-A in at least one of its cars (it's the one I know about). There's every reason to believe that others will follow.
6) Musical ensembles and their representatives are working hard to get their music on hi-rez format (so people can hear their music as the music is meant to be heard) with, for instance, several symphony orchestras setting up their own SACD apparatus and starting to release their own SACDs, and independent firms buying apparatus to help smaller ensembles record their music in hi-rez.
7) More and more people are setting up surround systems in their homes and there's every evidence that future players (even in the low price ranges) will be 'universal' allowing DVD, SACD, and DVD-A to be played at home without purchasing extra equipment.
8) Even if the hi-rez factor doesn't catch the general public's interest right away, the multi-channel factor will (luckily for us, the the current MC music formats are hi-rez in nature).
9) I believe that soon most of the new releases will be on one of the two new formats (my guess is hybrid SACD will be the current chosen format over DVD-A because of it's portability (can also be played on any current CD player, walkman, car CD player, etc.).
In other words, I feel strongly that the answer to your question is NO.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: Will hi-res die? Killed off by MP3? - Striving for Musical Clarity 06/25/0317:24:10 06/25/03 (51)
- No?! I really, really hope your right - Feanor 19:31:21 06/25/03 (0)
- OR: No cars have SACD except one. NO SACD has shown sales - Duilawyer 19:00:05 06/25/03 (49)
- Sad ... - Striving for Musical Clarity 03:57:38 06/26/03 (36)
- Hey guys and gals i don't know why you getting so upset over Duilawyer's remarks ... - Christine Tham 14:51:43 06/26/03 (7)
- Show me my post that says SACD is, or will be a commercial success. - Duilawyer 20:39:33 06/26/03 (3)
- That's the point, we'll know the format's really in deep sh*t when you post that one. nt - Methos 22:21:26 06/27/03 (2)
- OK, show me a prediction I made that was wrong. - Duilawyer 09:42:18 06/28/03 (1)
- Like shooting fish in a barrell - TheNewOrder 13:46:00 06/28/03 (0)
- :-) This is the best post I have read in a long time - TheNewOrder 17:10:22 06/26/03 (2)
- it's all quite logical really ... - Christine Tham 18:58:30 06/26/03 (1)
- I did not buy an SACD player out of hatred, but out of hope. - Duilawyer 20:42:43 06/26/03 (0)
- The truth hurts. All are welcome to "enjoy" SACD. I just - Duilawyer 06:38:20 06/26/03 (27)
- Marketing ploy - rebop 11:41:37 06/26/03 (7)
- Its called "excess spendable $$$". nt - Duilawyer 20:49:23 06/26/03 (0)
- DUI is a lawyer, so I'm sure it helps sharpen his skills by playing Devil's Advocate. (nt) - Teresa 20:29:43 06/26/03 (5)
- Well, I'm certainly impressed with his lawyerly prowess. Gosh, such masterful skills exhibited here. - Striving for Musical Clarity 00:12:36 06/27/03 (4)
- Duh, did it dawn on you, I am not in court here? - Duilawyer 05:47:03 06/27/03 (2)
- Hmmm ... - Striving for Musical Clarity 10:29:18 06/27/03 (1)
- You make this nonsense up, or do you have help? - Duilawyer 20:59:10 06/27/03 (0)
- You guys should show some empathy for DUI - Eric LeRouge 03:08:25 06/27/03 (0)
- A marketing ploy??!!! - Striving for Musical Clarity 07:26:18 06/26/03 (18)
- I have said this a million times. I want a blind test on an - Duilawyer 20:54:48 06/26/03 (17)
- here is my answer from the last time you asked this... - tunenut 09:20:00 06/27/03 (7)
- I am sorry I forgot your post from Aug 2002. Shame on me! nt - Duilawyer 09:43:21 06/28/03 (6)
- so am I wrong? - tunenut 10:35:29 06/28/03 (5)
- I looked and could not find SMR. I don't have it. That is probably - Duilawyer 11:07:27 06/28/03 (4)
- let's be scientific but let's also face reality... - tunenut 14:00:52 06/28/03 (1)
- I also will buy only the SACD, where it and CD are available. - Duilawyer 19:32:15 06/28/03 (0)
- $1800 on stereo gear - Metralla 12:13:51 06/28/03 (1)
- A REL Stentor; but I ran into a problem. Only works in augment mode. - Duilawyer 19:29:08 06/28/03 (0)
- Try "Lady Jane" [**VERY, VERY LONG REPLY--SORRY**] - rebop 08:39:58 06/27/03 (4)
- Gave it the test! There is no appreciable difference. - Duilawyer 09:45:40 06/28/03 (2)
- Re: Gave it the test! There is no appreciable difference. - rebop 07:34:36 06/30/03 (1)
- "music industry desperately wants a secure digital format, and SACD provides it" - Metralla 07:47:09 06/30/03 (0)
- I will give it a solid test, Saturday. Thanks for the response. nt - Duilawyer 22:05:38 06/27/03 (0)
- Re: I have said this a million times. I want a blind test on an - Striving for Musical Clarity 22:29:24 06/26/03 (3)
- OK, that last sentence is important - Eric LeRouge 02:58:59 06/27/03 (0)
- Pick randomly. [nt] - Striving for Musical Clarity 00:03:34 06/27/03 (0)
- Which song? Which passage? Or time, such as "on track 4 at 2:24.." nt - Duilawyer 22:43:15 06/26/03 (0)
- DUI they are not all resurected recordings of artists you don't like, nearly 50% are brand new DSD - Teresa 22:12:06 06/25/03 (4)
- Brand new recordings of nobodies. (2 exceptions) - Duilawyer 23:02:39 06/25/03 (3)
- I'm sure that... - rebop 11:36:32 06/26/03 (2)
- In terms of sales, they are non-existent, not just nobodies. nt - Duilawyer 20:55:43 06/26/03 (1)
- By your standards... - rebop 08:29:04 06/27/03 (0)
- So DUI - TheNewOrder 19:53:05 06/25/03 (6)
- BTW: You (falsely) write that I hate SACD. Why misstate what I wrote? - Duilawyer 06:51:26 06/26/03 (2)
- Re: BTW: You (falsely) write that I hate SACD. Why misstate what I wrote? - TheNewOrder 09:33:38 06/26/03 (0)
- If almost none are worth owning... - rebop 08:44:39 06/26/03 (0)
- That can be said of any post here. There are people who do not care. nt - Duilawyer 23:03:33 06/25/03 (2)
- What a weak answer! - TheNewOrder 06:35:51 06/26/03 (1)
- Don't read them. :-) nt - Duilawyer 06:48:15 06/26/03 (0)