In Reply to: Peter Boffin Sound Improvement Disc (SID) posted by jeromelang on September 7, 2002 at 21:58:32:
The disc is laying on a black plastic drive anyway, covering some of the label. In a dark machine, more than likely. Do you hear a change of sound when the laser hits the disc where it is no longer supported by the black plastic drive? No.
And no one has proven that less error correction makes better sound, at least in the minute amounts this disc would be causing. IF the correct number enters the digital stream, whether error corrected or not, FINIS!Let's see where this company has done a blind test of the product and ANYONE could tell the difference.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Bubble, bubble, toil and trouble....... - Duilawyer 09/8/0207:42:07 09/8/02 (16)
- Also, something like this wouldn't change reflectivity of the data layer... - Michi 09:55:26 09/8/02 (8)
- What about the Audions? - Mark Kelly 18:35:22 09/8/02 (1)
- Well said (nt) - bruce3825 22:42:12 09/9/02 (0)
- Brilliant, as always. Factor in the poor aural memory. - Duilawyer 10:11:59 09/8/02 (5)
- iv'e allways been sceptical..... - mark111 17:51:03 09/8/02 (4)
- Same as sgb. Cables will not change the sound enough - Duilawyer 19:32:09 09/8/02 (2)
- A dangerous thing - arguing from the particular to the general - Metralla 22:26:19 09/8/02 (1)
- My own observations are a small part of what I relied on. - Duilawyer 23:44:37 09/8/02 (0)
- I haven't been skeptical. A cable passes a signal. - sgb 18:16:20 09/8/02 (0)
- If the errors are in too much numbers... to cope with.. - patrickU 09:43:04 09/8/02 (6)
- Patrick, for that to happen, there has to be a very serious problem. - Michi 10:07:20 09/8/02 (3)
- Michelle... - patrickU 11:50:20 09/8/02 (2)
- Of course it will skip. But will a CD-mat really help this? - Michi 22:34:07 09/8/02 (1)
- How should I know... - patrickU 03:55:02 09/9/02 (0)
- Not from too much data error, no... - Duilawyer 10:07:03 09/8/02 (1)
- Re: Not from too much data error, no... - patrickU 11:20:03 09/8/02 (0)