Re: Why does Vinyl sound better than SACD? - mikel

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Why does Vinyl sound better than SACD? - newbie 16:25:05 12/9/01 (59)

From Mr.Hirsch's esteemed publication comes the answer: - waVeman 22:21:12 12/10/01 (9)

my first turntable was a Technics - tunenut 14:20:40 12/11/01 (5)

Re: my first turntable was a Technics - waVeman 21:10:47 12/11/01 (4)

why some people may get upset - tunenut 11:50:47 12/12/01 (3)

Here's a clue as to my thought processes: I like Carl Sagan a lot. - waVeman 17:44:53 12/12/01 (2)

fair enough - tunenut 18:33:04 12/12/01 (1)

Appreciate you replying. Thanks. N/T - waVeman 22:16:29 12/12/01 (0)

Might be your system as well as your education. (nt) - JCS 03:06:58 12/11/01 (2)

Your 5th grader reply is typical of an "audiophile" & why I place little value in their opinions N/T - waVeman 08:58:54 12/11/01 (1)

Nice response. - JCS 17:13:54 12/11/01 (0)

It is purely psychological... - jimmyjames 07:08:02 12/10/01 (1)

Re: It is purely psychological... - Michi 08:00:15 12/10/01 (0)

Because vinyl is a recording. - Alex Yakovlev 06:52:36 12/10/01 (1)

Re: Because vinyl is a recording. - M 16:36:45 12/10/01 (0)

In my system, SACD is better, but... - 9fold 20:46:01 12/9/01 (0)

Re: Why does Vinyl sound better than SACD? - Jazz Inmate 19:03:10 12/9/01 (22)

Re: Why does Vinyl sound better than SACD? - mikel 12/9/0119:24:17 12/9/01 (21)

I thought Jennifer Crock... - SACD Enthusiast 20:14:19 12/9/01 (16)

Re: I thought Jennifer Crock... - Jonathan Tinn 20:51:02 12/10/01 (0)

Re: I thought Jennifer Crock... - mikel 20:59:24 12/9/01 (14)

Re: I thought Jennifer Crock... - Jazz Inmate 21:44:33 12/9/01 (8)

i think maybe we are both right..... - mikel 05:31:33 12/10/01 (6)

I've recently had a similar experience, mikel - Dr. Audio 08:09:44 12/10/01 (1)

Re: I've recently had a similar experience, mikel - mikel 18:51:27 12/10/01 (0)

What about for 99.999999% of record players, though? - Skeptic 07:10:54 12/10/01 (3)

Re: What about for 99.999999% of record players, though? - mikel 07:30:05 12/10/01 (2)

Re: What about for 99.999999% of record players, though? - Double Trouble 18:21:18 12/10/01 (1)

Re: What about for 99.999999% of record players, though? - mikel 19:02:45 12/10/01 (0)

Wait until you put a Super Clock in your SCD-1! - Audiocrazed 02:10:20 12/10/01 (0)

It would be interesting to see if a 2nd generation SACD player closes the gap (nt) - Stephen 21:27:15 12/9/01 (4)

Need precision clock + state of the art analog stage to close the gap, not new gen. players. (nt) - Peter 03:58:24 12/10/01 (3)

This is an important point... - David W. Robinson 16:26:19 12/10/01 (2)

Guess those DSD DAC designers can put their feet up ;-) (nt) - Stephen 17:53:22 12/10/01 (1)

Don't tell Ed Meitner that!! ;-) [nt] - David W. Robinson 01:35:48 12/11/01 (0)

Remove the Aurios from underneath your player - jeromelang 19:31:40 12/9/01 (3)

Re: Remove the Aurios from underneath your player - mikel 19:50:40 12/9/01 (2)

Thanks for clarifications... - jeromelang 21:09:43 12/9/01 (1)

Re: Thanks for clarifications... - mikel 21:33:05 12/9/01 (0)

Re: Why does Vinyl sound better than SACD? - iza 18:02:04 12/9/01 (0)

"Better" is tough to qualify or define... - David W. Robinson 17:27:22 12/9/01 (0)

Re: Why does Vinyl sound better than SACD? - mikel 16:53:45 12/9/01 (17)

Interesting, - oitzman 12:35:48 12/10/01 (0)

So perhaps SACD/DVD-A are obsolete... - oscar 18:13:36 12/9/01 (2)

Perhaps, with DataPlay, unfortunately. - Michi 00:08:33 12/10/01 (0)

i agree and chose SACD too, and the next digital format...... - mikel 18:28:22 12/9/01 (0)

Re: Why does Vinyl sound better than SACD? - M 17:45:35 12/9/01 (1)

Re: Why does Vinyl sound better than SACD? - mikel 18:35:14 12/9/01 (0)

that broken mirror is an interesting analogy, mikel - sgb 17:44:10 12/9/01 (0)

Good analogy, that last one! (nt) - Peter 17:41:30 12/9/01 (0)

Re: Why does Vinyl sound better than SACD? - lenardd 17:29:22 12/9/01 (8)

yes, analog clocks do have more resolution than....... - mikel 18:47:26 12/9/01 (7)

Isn't tape resolute down to the molecular level... - SACD Enthusiast 20:35:10 12/9/01 (2)

Re: Isn't tape resolute down to the molecular level... - Michi 08:01:32 12/10/01 (0)

Re: Isn't tape resolute down to the molecular level... - mikel 21:19:54 12/9/01 (0)

If you take that logic to the extreme then....... - saywhat 20:17:07 12/9/01 (0)

You completely ignored.... - SimonTJU 20:10:21 12/9/01 (1)

resolution is different than accuracy....... - mikel 21:08:36 12/9/01 (0)

Watching too many reruns of Matrix ? (nt) - oscar 19:03:40 12/9/01 (0)

Re: Why does Vinyl sound better than SACD? - M 16:29:40 12/9/01 (0)

Follow Ups

Re: Why does Vinyl sound better than SACD? - mikel 12/9/0119:24:17 12/9/01 (21)

I thought Jennifer Crock... - SACD Enthusiast 20:14:19 12/9/01 (16)

Re: I thought Jennifer Crock... - Jonathan Tinn 20:51:02 12/10/01 (0)

Re: I thought Jennifer Crock... - mikel 20:59:24 12/9/01 (14)

Re: I thought Jennifer Crock... - Jazz Inmate 21:44:33 12/9/01 (8)

i think maybe we are both right..... - mikel 05:31:33 12/10/01 (6)

I've recently had a similar experience, mikel - Dr. Audio 08:09:44 12/10/01 (1)

Re: I've recently had a similar experience, mikel - mikel 18:51:27 12/10/01 (0)

What about for 99.999999% of record players, though? - Skeptic 07:10:54 12/10/01 (3)

Re: What about for 99.999999% of record players, though? - mikel 07:30:05 12/10/01 (2)

Re: What about for 99.999999% of record players, though? - Double Trouble 18:21:18 12/10/01 (1)

Re: What about for 99.999999% of record players, though? - mikel 19:02:45 12/10/01 (0)

Wait until you put a Super Clock in your SCD-1! - Audiocrazed 02:10:20 12/10/01 (0)

It would be interesting to see if a 2nd generation SACD player closes the gap (nt) - Stephen 21:27:15 12/9/01 (4)

Need precision clock + state of the art analog stage to close the gap, not new gen. players. (nt) - Peter 03:58:24 12/10/01 (3)

This is an important point... - David W. Robinson 16:26:19 12/10/01 (2)

Guess those DSD DAC designers can put their feet up ;-) (nt) - Stephen 17:53:22 12/10/01 (1)

Don't tell Ed Meitner that!! ;-) [nt] - David W. Robinson 01:35:48 12/11/01 (0)

Remove the Aurios from underneath your player - jeromelang 19:31:40 12/9/01 (3)

Re: Remove the Aurios from underneath your player - mikel 19:50:40 12/9/01 (2)

Thanks for clarifications... - jeromelang 21:09:43 12/9/01 (1)

Re: Thanks for clarifications... - mikel 21:33:05 12/9/01 (0)