General Asylum General audio topics that don't fit into specific categories. |
|
In Reply to: Here it is. The many reasons live acoustic music does not work as a practical reference for judging audio posted by Analog Scott on March 1, 2022 at 18:14:48:
Accurate reproduction of sounds does in fact have som.thing to do with the com.unication of this feeling. But I guess, that fact is a but a paltry detail - a m.re bit in the picture puzzle of audio enjoym.nt ?
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups Full ThreadTopic - Here it is. The many reasons live acoustic music does not work as a practical reference for judging audio - Analog Scott 18:14:48 03/1/22 (113)
- Agreed: Live music cannot be a "practical" reference - Feanor 04:54:13 03/5/22 (2)
- RE: Agreed: Live music cannot be a "practical" reference - Analog Scott 06:56:02 03/5/22 (0)
- There is no standard for sound. Do not seek the standard. - geoffkait 05:11:55 03/5/22 (0)
- RE: " objective standard of measure" - LtMandella 07:47:39 03/3/22 (4)
- Not really sure hoe your post relates to mine - Analog Scott 08:10:13 03/3/22 (3)
- RE: Not really sure hoe your post relates to mine - LtMandella 09:44:43 03/3/22 (2)
- Here is the correction - Analog Scott 09:51:17 03/3/22 (1)
- RE: Here is the correction - LtMandella 10:23:33 03/3/22 (0)
- You gave three reasons why audiophiles use live music as a reference but...- - geoffkait 04:30:24 03/3/22 (0)
- another problem - oldvinyl 16:39:50 03/2/22 (0)
- The feeling that live music gives us is "the reference". - peppy m. 03/2/2216:04:13 03/2/22 (5)
- RE: The feeling that live music gives us is "the reference". - Analog Scott 16:37:16 03/2/22 (4)
- Enjoyment comes of course but there are tangible reasons for it's coming... - peppy m. 10:23:09 03/3/22 (3)
- I get it now, you mean the sweet smell of weed wafting through the crowd? Nt - geoffkait 05:12:35 03/4/22 (2)
- RE: I get it now, you mean the sweet smell of weed wafting through the crowd? Nt - peppy m. 11:17:49 03/4/22 (1)
- RE: I get it now, you mean the sweet smell of weed wafting through the crowd? Nt - geoffkait 13:14:38 03/4/22 (0)
- So what does serve as the reference? nt - tinear 10:46:08 03/2/22 (5)
- I don't think a reference is needed at all - Analog Scott 10:53:21 03/2/22 (4)
- But that's impossible. One has a personal preference for sound - tinear 12:09:19 03/3/22 (1)
- RE: But that's impossible. One has a personal preference for sound - Analog Scott 14:09:31 03/3/22 (0)
- RE: I don't think a reference is needed at all - chocolate_lover 14:06:57 03/2/22 (1)
- RE: I don't think a reference is needed at all - Analog Scott 14:15:40 03/2/22 (0)
- Scott really came through this time...- - geoffkait 10:00:02 03/2/22 (2)
- Another gem...- - geoffkait 13:25:00 03/2/22 (0)
- This is too good not to share - geoffkait 11:27:53 03/2/22 (0)
- Seriously?! - Inmate51 08:48:36 03/2/22 (1)
- RE: Seriously?! - Analog Scott 09:00:12 03/2/22 (0)
- RE: Here it is. The many reasons live acoustic music does not work as a practical reference for judging audio - Story 04:08:29 03/2/22 (12)
- This was done at a CAF several years ago. - G Squared 07:20:27 03/2/22 (0)
- That works, too - E-Stat 05:54:58 03/2/22 (6)
- RE: That works, too - Todd Krieger 08:01:51 03/2/22 (5)
- Hedges is a favorite of mine - E-Stat 08:44:57 03/2/22 (1)
- RE: Hedges is a favorite of mine - Todd Krieger 01:32:11 03/3/22 (0)
- RE: That works, too - Analog Scott 08:06:33 03/2/22 (2)
- RE: That works, too - Todd Krieger 08:25:16 03/2/22 (1)
- RE: That works, too - Analog Scott 08:46:30 03/2/22 (0)
- RE: Here it is. The many reasons live acoustic music does not work as a practical reference for judging audio - Analog Scott 05:14:32 03/2/22 (3)
- another perspective on nine foot pianos - oldvinyl 16:12:12 03/2/22 (1)
- RE: another perspective on nine foot pianos - Analog Scott 16:39:17 03/2/22 (0)
- RE: Here it is. The many reasons live acoustic music does not work as a practical reference for judging audio - Story 06:53:12 03/2/22 (0)
- We covered this topic a whole buncha times, most recently only two months ago. - geoffkait 03:54:29 03/2/22 (0)
- I just saw your post Scott - I'm impressed by your thoroughness, but. . . - Chris from Lafayette 01:36:24 03/2/22 (3)
- RE: I just saw your post Scott - I'm impressed by your thoroughness, but. . . - Analog Scott 02:03:32 03/2/22 (2)
- Scott - I wasted a lot of time earlier today on Inmate Central - sorry! - Chris from Lafayette 01:15:59 03/3/22 (1)
- RE: Scott - I wasted a lot of time earlier today on Inmate Central - sorry! - Analog Scott 04:47:43 03/3/22 (0)
- Why must you persist on picking on these people? - Goober58 21:15:09 03/1/22 (34)
- I'm not picking on any people - Analog Scott 01:09:17 03/2/22 (33)
- RE: I'm not picking on any people - Goober58 08:09:53 03/2/22 (32)
- No I am not picking on anyone but since you do raise some points - Analog Scott 12:38:52 03/2/22 (31)
- RE: No I am not picking on anyone but since you do raise some points - Goober58 15:37:22 03/2/22 (30)
- RE: No I am not picking on anyone but since you do raise some points - Analog Scott 17:18:51 03/2/22 (28)
- RE: No I am not picking on anyone but since you do raise some points - Goober58 16:42:44 03/3/22 (27)
- RE: No I am not picking on anyone but since you do raise some points - Analog Scott 18:14:46 03/3/22 (26)
- RE: No I am not picking on anyone but since you do raise some points - Goober58 20:13:21 03/3/22 (25)
- "we can use anything we want as a reference" - Analog Scott 21:16:05 03/3/22 (24)
- It's not my problem - Goober58 21:50:39 03/3/22 (23)
- "Obviously?" - Analog Scott 04:18:54 03/4/22 (22)
- Again who cares? - Goober58 19:31:26 03/4/22 (8)
- If you don't care why are you getting involved in this thread? - Analog Scott 21:10:24 03/4/22 (7)
- Like I asked in my first comment to you - "Why are you always picking on these people?" - Goober58 11:19:02 03/5/22 (6)
- As said in my response, I amnot picking on anyone I am talking about audio - Analog Scott 11:28:01 03/5/22 (5)
- Not quite - Goober58 14:05:51 03/5/22 (4)
- RE: Not quite - Analog Scott 06:03:08 03/6/22 (3)
- "Here it is. The many reasons live acoustic music does not work as a practical reference for judging audio" - Goober58 08:20:26 03/6/22 (2)
- RE: "Here it is. The many reasons live acoustic music does not work as a practical reference for judging audio" - Analog Scott 09:27:08 03/6/22 (1)
- Fair enough - Goober58 10:44:42 03/6/22 (0)
- So... - E-Stat 05:56:50 03/4/22 (12)
- RE: So... - Analog Scott 09:29:42 03/4/22 (11)
- Amidst the bloviation - E-Stat 10:20:01 03/4/22 (7)
- OK, who bloviated? Nt - geoffkait 10:37:10 03/4/22 (5)
- I was amused by Inmate51's response - E-Stat 10:49:06 03/4/22 (4)
- OMG, are you saying Scott is mixed up with QAnon? - geoffkait 04:25:39 03/5/22 (0)
- RE: I was amused by Inmate51's response - Analog Scott 11:07:12 03/4/22 (2)
- Apparently... - E-Stat 11:08:51 03/4/22 (1)
- RE: Apparently... - Analog Scott 11:50:17 03/4/22 (0)
- RE: Amidst the bloviation - Analog Scott 10:30:57 03/4/22 (0)
- RE: So... - geoffkait 10:12:53 03/4/22 (2)
- RE: No I am not picking on anyone but since you do raise some points - geoffkait 15:44:04 03/2/22 (0)
- Lowered Standards........ - Todd Krieger 20:48:39 03/1/22 (32)
- "Johnston was one of those "audio engineers" who I didn't have much regard for.." - E-Stat 05:48:33 03/2/22 (14)
- RE: "Johnston was one of those "audio engineers" who I didn't have much regard for.." - Todd Krieger 07:24:57 03/2/22 (13)
- RE: "Johnston was one of those "audio engineers" who I didn't have much regard for.." - geoffkait 09:55:27 03/2/22 (4)
- RE: "Johnston was one of those "audio engineers" who I didn't have much regard for.." - E-Stat 10:15:41 03/2/22 (3)
- RE: "Johnston was one of those "audio engineers" who I didn't have much regard for.." - geoffkait 12:46:02 03/2/22 (2)
- There were quite a few characters at Prop Head - E-Stat 13:02:01 03/2/22 (1)
- Remember the halcyon days of The Intelligent Chip? Nt - geoffkait 13:19:26 03/2/22 (0)
- RE: "Johnston was one of those "audio engineers" who I didn't have much regard for.." - Analog Scott 09:50:38 03/2/22 (5)
- RE: "Johnston was one of those "audio engineers" who I didn't have much regard for.." - Analog Scott 06:33:40 03/3/22 (4)
- "Good Advice"...... - Todd Krieger 01:36:59 03/6/22 (3)
- RE: "Good Advice"...... - Analog Scott 06:53:00 03/6/22 (1)
- An excellent, no GREAT, example of Appeal to Authority logical fallacy. - geoffkait 08:23:08 03/6/22 (0)
- RE: "Good Advice"...... - geoffkait 02:52:11 03/6/22 (0)
- He couldn't even remember his own login - E-Stat 07:29:51 03/2/22 (1)
- RE: He couldn't even remember his own login - Todd Krieger 07:42:27 03/2/22 (0)
- RE: Lowered Standards........ - Analog Scott 01:34:39 03/2/22 (16)
- RE: Lowered Standards........ - Todd Krieger 05:18:05 03/2/22 (12)
- Live music is not evaluated? I beg to differ - Analog Scott 07:57:10 03/2/22 (8)
- RE: Live music is not evaluated? I beg to differ - Todd Krieger 00:55:56 03/4/22 (7)
- What should one use instead? - Analog Scott 04:23:05 03/4/22 (6)
- RE: What should one use instead? - Todd Krieger 02:01:33 03/6/22 (5)
- " Again, there is no higher reference than live music......" - geoffkait 11:28:46 03/6/22 (1)
- The Experiences Matter........ - Todd Krieger 15:53:33 03/7/22 (0)
- RE: What should one use instead? - Analog Scott 09:59:25 03/6/22 (2)
- See My Response to Geoff Kait...... - Todd Krieger 15:57:53 03/7/22 (1)
- That doesn't answer any of my questions - Analog Scott 20:49:07 03/7/22 (0)
- One Further Comment........ - Todd Krieger 05:50:46 03/2/22 (2)
- RE: One Further Comment........ - Analog Scott 08:02:35 03/2/22 (0)
- Back in high school, I had a Pioneer RG2 dynamic range expander... - MWE 06:07:08 03/2/22 (0)
- Watch out, Todd! That last line is a trick question! [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 01:39:25 03/2/22 (2)
- RE: Watch out, Todd! That last line is a trick question! [nt] ;-) - Todd Krieger 05:24:51 03/2/22 (1)
- RE: Watch out, Todd! That last line is a trick question! [nt] ;-) - Analog Scott 07:41:57 03/2/22 (0)
Follow Ups
- The feeling that live music gives us is "the reference". - peppy m. 03/2/2216:04:13 03/2/22 (5)
- RE: The feeling that live music gives us is "the reference". - Analog Scott 16:37:16 03/2/22 (4)
- Enjoyment comes of course but there are tangible reasons for it's coming... - peppy m. 10:23:09 03/3/22 (3)
- I get it now, you mean the sweet smell of weed wafting through the crowd? Nt - geoffkait 05:12:35 03/4/22 (2)
- RE: I get it now, you mean the sweet smell of weed wafting through the crowd? Nt - peppy m. 11:17:49 03/4/22 (1)
- RE: I get it now, you mean the sweet smell of weed wafting through the crowd? Nt - geoffkait 13:14:38 03/4/22 (0)