|
General Asylum General audio topics that don't fit into specific categories. |
|
|
|
General Asylum General audio topics that don't fit into specific categories. |
|
In Reply to: *if* "live acoustic music" is the reference for judging audio what is the reference for judging live acoustic music? posted by Analog Scott on December 23, 2021 at 10:48:24:
If you cannot hear the m.sic clearly and distinctly you cannot possibly judge it on it's own m.rits. This is basic fact.You m.ght form an indistinct kind of sentim.ntal attachm.nt to any m.sic perform.nce in any type of venue (good or bad) sim.ly because it is m.sic, but the greater perform.nce venues are acoustically congenial environm.nts that let you hear what is actually going on in a perform.nce - so you don't have to guess at what M.GHT be going on in it. Lesser perform.nce venues do the opposite of what great venues do - they sm.ar and conceal details and dynam.cs that m.ke up the true sound (the "reference" sound ?) of any m.sical perform.nce.
So, the first requirem.nt for JUDGEM.NT is "audibility". This is what I said in m. initial post (down below_) and now, I'm saying it again. Because it is true.
All of that said, is the m.st basic "requirem.nt" for judging a perform.nce necessarily the sam. thing as he m.st basic "reference" for judging it ? I don't know.
And I, for one, am not sure there is a logical answer to such a vague question as yours. I'm also starting to think that you are not sure what the answer is (or m.ght be) either...
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- The most basic REQUIREMENT for judging live acoustic music is "audibility" - peppy m. 12/27/2111:32:54 12/27/21 (12)
- Good is the enemy of the best - geoffkait 16:09:45 12/27/21 (0)
- My answer - Analog Scott 14:15:54 12/27/21 (10)
- The starting transient or "initial attack" phase of any sound or instrument ... - peppy m. 11:55:59 12/28/21 (1)
- RE: The starting transient or "initial attack" phase of any sound or instrument ... - geoffkait 05:29:46 03/9/22 (0)
- My answer - E-Stat 09:02:44 12/28/21 (7)
- Sorry but that is just not true - Analog Scott 09:33:06 12/28/21 (6)
- Clearly, we hear differently - E-Stat 09:49:15 12/28/21 (5)
- I'm fine with other opinions - Analog Scott 11:02:51 12/28/21 (4)
- It's truly sad... - E-Stat 11:16:01 12/28/21 (3)
- typical audiophile disconnect with reality - Analog Scott 11:46:26 12/28/21 (2)
- Scott's an "audiophile" and a scientist." - geoffkait 13:20:38 12/28/21 (0)
- Yours is the last word -nt - E-Stat 11:53:47 12/28/21 (0)
Top of Page ]
[ Contact Us ]
[ Support/Wish List ]
[ Copyright © 2024, Audio Asylum, all rights reserved ]