|
General Asylum General audio topics that don't fit into specific categories. |
|
|
|
General Asylum General audio topics that don't fit into specific categories. |
|
In Reply to: Don T is confused, I see. posted by jj on April 8, 2002 at 13:42:03:
> > I said nothing about my own work at all. Please retract your
> accusation immediately. I could, in fact, cite a great deal of my
> > own work here, but I've choosen not to do so EXACTY so as to avoid
> > your ill-taken and inaccurate accusation. I expect your complete
> > capitulation on this matter immediately.
No way! Did you intentionally misread the "much of" comment or was it intentional. Your ability to provide a couple of examples is meaningless.> > It disagrees exactly and precisely with what he alledged. Why is
> > this so hard to see? He claims that audio results are
> > pseudoscience, and I have cited a variety of results in the
> > catagory that he regards as pseudoscience that the people in the
> > art regard as leading edge science.
Again this is not his claim and you are just pigeon holing his remarks into an argument you want to make.> > Please explain how noting others' well known work is 'showing off'.
> > When you fail to do that, retract your accusation completely and
> > apologetically.
No I won't. Quoting some science does not indicate the incorrectness of ggraffs comments - again not he says "much of" not "all"> > Individuals' taste and preference vary enormously, there's no doubt
> > about that.
Enough said - you agree with me.> > Finally, what is your position on falsification, confirmation, and
> > repetition? Those issues are at the heart of the discussion of the
> > scientific validity of audio testing, not your ill-considered and
> > apparently malicious attacks on my professional reputation. Please,
> > after you address your illicit ad-hominem attacks, do address the
> > reality of audio testing as science as well.
More righteous indignation - I love it. Maybe if you could read and think about ggraffs post you could get off your high horse and make a contribution to this thread. But instead you seem to want to advertise you own self importance and education over the point and intentions of the original post. Good for you JJ!
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Please ....... - Don T 04/8/0214:05:39 04/8/02 (5)
- Re: Please ....... - jj 14:59:49 04/8/02 (4)
- Re: Please ....... - Don T 18:28:28 04/8/02 (3)
- Squirm all you want... Then admit you're wrong. - jj 19:38:45 04/8/02 (2)
- HA! You're speechless! - Don T 20:01:46 04/8/02 (1)
- No, just appalled at your attempt at character assassination... - jj 20:15:15 04/8/02 (0)
Top of Page ]
[ Contact Us ]
[ Support/Wish List ]
[ Copyright © 2025, Audio Asylum, all rights reserved ]
