RE: I can't say i ever bought a recording for the sound rather than the plain old music.

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Overrated audiophile recordings - magiccarpetride 14:43:34 06/13/11 (83)

RE: Overrated audiophile recordings - Chazro 13:11:20 06/15/11 (0)

Your system must not be good enough to hear them properly. - JimBop 20:05:08 06/14/11 (3)

RE: Your system must not be good enough to hear them properly. - pictureguy 14:31:41 06/17/11 (0)

Or his system may be so good that he can hear there's no there there... - musetap 12:08:48 06/15/11 (0)

but do you believe that? bet not. you said it to make a funny. nt - Elizabeth 23:07:59 06/14/11 (0)

Almost none of them are overrated... - genungo 17:31:12 06/14/11 (0)

RE: Overrated audiophile recordings - JimL 12:49:49 06/14/11 (0)

A pop/rock music fan chimes in - goober58 10:47:45 06/14/11 (0)

You're close! (re muffled piano sound) - Charlie S in Maryland 10:35:28 06/14/11 (1)

It sounded good on the original LPs. Blue Note got a very mellow, round piano sound. Many other labels were - oldmkvi 17:11:59 06/14/11 (0)

Comment on vintage LP sound... - docw 07:59:19 06/14/11 (0)

RVGs for sure. JRVGs much better. - Sigmund 07:50:04 06/14/11 (0)

Mercury Living Presence & RCA Living Stereo - Feanor 07:34:47 06/14/11 (4)

RE: Mercury Living Presence & RCA Living Stereo - geoffkait 08:44:48 06/14/11 (3)

Very good but not consistently great * - Feanor 15:17:31 06/14/11 (2)

Pretty sure noone ever claimed they were consistently great. - geoffkait 03:02:14 06/15/11 (1)

Of course not ... - Feanor 03:56:23 06/15/11 (0)

RVG's - jimmyjames 06:02:09 06/14/11 (1)

RE: RVG's - middleground 06:12:40 06/18/11 (0)

The RVG catalogue - Larry I 05:50:38 06/14/11 (0)

Audiophile self-loathing - Jim Austin 04:48:28 06/14/11 (5)

RE: Audiophile self-loathing - magiccarpetride 10:13:31 06/16/11 (0)

The problem is the group of boring but wonderful sonics sort of albums paraded around as 'jaw dropping' sorts - Elizabeth 17:15:15 06/15/11 (2)

RE: The problem is the group of boring but wonderful sonics sort of albums paraded around as 'jaw dropping' sorts - magiccarpetride 10:16:34 06/16/11 (1)

RE: The problem is the group of boring but wonderful sonics sort of albums paraded around as 'jaw dropping' sorts - middleground 06:14:51 06/18/11 (0)

I'm going to chime in an agree with Jim - jult52 05:54:34 06/14/11 (0)

RE: Overrated audiophile recordings - Gag Halfrunt 02:21:50 06/14/11 (1)

Great rant! Thanks! :) (nt) - willkayakforfood 02:33:22 06/14/11 (0)

I can't say i ever bought a recording for the sound rather than the plain old music. - Elizabeth 23:26:49 06/13/11 (3)

RE: I can't say i ever bought a recording for the sound rather than the plain old music. - magiccarpetride 13:24:46 06/15/11 (1)

RE: "So what's up with that?" I have an idea... - willkayakforfood 14:39:38 06/15/11 (0)

RE: I can't say i ever bought a recording for the sound rather than the plain old music. - rick_m 06/14/1115:18:22 06/14/11 (0)

On the positive side - boboli 21:03:30 06/13/11 (2)

RE: On the positive side - magiccarpetride 10:03:35 06/16/11 (0)

Ditto!...N/T - musetap 11:09:00 06/14/11 (0)

All of them... - audio_d 20:44:25 06/13/11 (5)

M A Recordings is an "audiophile" label and everything I've heard of theirs is superb... - musetap 21:30:06 06/13/11 (4)

I have Ita Ima plying the Goldberg Variations on vinyl - and it is superb! Both ... - andyr 19:41:43 06/14/11 (1)

Dang! Vinyl is OOP, but I'll look for the CD. Thanks!...N/T - musetap 21:24:59 06/14/11 (0)

Agreed. Great performances and production values! (mt) - Stephæn 11:47:15 06/14/11 (1)

A description also worthy of Alia Vox...N/T - musetap 12:57:45 06/14/11 (0)

Agree about most of Chesky catalogue but... - kuma 20:10:22 06/13/11 (2)

RE: Now you just wait a derned minute! - amioutaline? 15:23:54 06/14/11 (1)

Chesky's Lt. Kije? - kuma 18:34:31 06/14/11 (0)

The definition of an audiophile recording... - mkuller 20:02:29 06/13/11 (9)

RE: The definition of an audiophile recording... - Todd Krieger 20:07:01 06/13/11 (8)

i waaay prefer......` - hifitommy 21:17:31 06/13/11 (6)

Now yer talkin' - kavakidd 23:13:46 06/13/11 (5)

there are quite a few that are good - hifitommy 06:00:03 06/14/11 (4)

I have all of those - kavakidd 09:37:10 06/14/11 (3)

"lack a certain energy" - hifitommy 14:59:21 06/14/11 (2)

I have indeed - kavakidd 16:24:06 06/14/11 (1)

its funny, i have always liked those perfs - hifitommy 17:10:17 06/14/11 (0)

I saw her sing live in about 1985... - mkuller 20:13:06 06/13/11 (0)

RE: Overrated audiophile recordings - Regor Ladan 19:20:46 06/13/11 (0)

I agree with you about the RVG remasters - Mike K 19:11:09 06/13/11 (0)

RE: Overrated audiophile recordings - Todd Krieger 18:55:43 06/13/11 (0)

you have to know who to trust - hifitommy 18:01:32 06/13/11 (3)

Kraftwerk - kavakidd 23:16:03 06/13/11 (2)

cafe was on hp's list - hifitommy 06:02:39 06/14/11 (1)

"not all of hp's choices were credible musically" - Rob Doorack 04:34:00 06/15/11 (0)

What do you expect? - Kal Rubinson 15:38:45 06/13/11 (2)

RE: What do you expect? - magiccarpetride 15:50:28 06/13/11 (1)

RE: What do you expect? - Kal Rubinson 18:28:34 06/13/11 (0)

Recording quality is different from "good" music or performances - Sordidman 15:31:59 06/13/11 (2)

RE: Recording quality is different from "good" music or performances - Pat D 16:09:19 06/13/11 (1)

South - Sordidman 20:31:21 06/14/11 (0)

I'm always concerned with *the performance*. A quality recording--of a great performance--is a bonus. - willkayakforfood 15:11:09 06/13/11 (13)

Agree with you 100% It is the performance and not the sound that matters, good sound is a bonus - Elizabeth 17:18:22 06/13/11 (12)

C'mon, ladies ... - andyr 19:26:56 06/13/11 (11)

Casals, Starker, 19/20th century performance practices vs. 16/17/18th century practices, etc. - willkayakforfood 21:10:18 06/13/11 (10)

RE: Casals, Starker - pbarach 15:50:37 06/14/11 (0)

RE: Casals, Starker, 19/20th century performance practices vs. 16/17/18th century practices, etc. - rmilewsk 23:26:32 06/13/11 (5)

Start here, but don't stop here... - willkayakforfood 00:32:46 06/14/11 (4)

willk - jult52 05:41:26 06/14/11 (3)

RE: Mischa Maisky - willkayakforfood 07:32:03 06/14/11 (2)

Hey debating the merits of musicians - jult52 06:44:31 06/15/11 (1)

RE: Hey debating the merits of musicians - willkayakforfood 07:00:09 06/15/11 (0)

So,wkff ... what good "baroque" version of the Suites would you recommend? :-)) ... - andyr 21:19:02 06/13/11 (2)

Please see reply to "rmilewsk", above. (nt) - willkayakforfood 00:38:11 06/14/11 (1)

Thank you, thank you, wkff. :-)) ... - andyr 01:36:16 06/14/11 (0)

RE: Overrated audiophile recordings - pbarach 15:06:15 06/13/11 (1)

For Britten - Daverz 21:15:12 06/13/11 (0)

Follow Ups

RE: I can't say i ever bought a recording for the sound rather than the plain old music. - rick_m 06/14/1115:18:22 06/14/11 (0)

Post a Message!