In Reply to: Re: There is the electrical engineer's view that a cable is an LCR network, and then there are audiphile fantasies posted by morricab on October 10, 2005 at 12:52:51:
Morricab: ""Yes but that is not all there is to the story. If you have read Hawksford (admittedly a bit trying) you will see that application of Maxwell gets you some very interesting results. This is not the engineer's view, which IMO is somewhat myopic, but the physicist's view and IMO the more correct one. ""If I were going to publish a paper on skin effect, I would be more likely to check the beginning assumptions upon which I based the entire paper..
He did not, therefore, the entire paper is a worthless piece of floobydust..
Actually, it is worse than that...as it has people like you claiming that it has merit..that, IMHO, is the worst part of it all..
When writing "the seminal paper" on skin effect, note to self....do not use the high frequency skin approximation at frequencies where that approximation is not applicable, or accurate..
Geeze...will it never end?
Morricab: ""application of Maxwell gets you some very interesting results""It is even MORE interesting when it is done correctly..
Cheers, John
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: There is the electrical engineer's view that a cable is an LCR network, and then there are audiphile fantasies - jneutron 10/10/0513:19:35 10/10/05 (20)
- Re: There is the electrical engineer's view that a cable is an LCR network, and then there are audiphile fantasies - morricab 04:55:32 10/11/05 (19)
- Hmmm.. - jneutron 06:23:28 10/11/05 (18)
- Re: Hmmm.. - morricab 07:47:12 10/11/05 (1)
- Re: Hmmm.. - jneutron 08:37:02 10/11/05 (0)
- The arguement seems irrelavent - Soundmind 07:31:41 10/11/05 (15)
- Your argument is nothing ... - bjh 09:59:26 10/11/05 (7)
- You sound like you are in group II, the suckers who have wasted their money and cat admit it even to themselves - Soundmind 11:54:25 10/11/05 (6)
- BTW, re: DBT ... - bjh 12:51:13 10/11/05 (2)
- Re: BTW, re: DBT ... - Soundmind 13:03:21 10/11/05 (1)
- Try to stay on topic! - bjh 13:28:47 10/11/05 (0)
- Sad! ... - bjh 12:18:31 10/11/05 (2)
- Re: Sad! ... - Soundmind 13:15:55 10/11/05 (1)
- Look I'm not going - bjh 13:35:41 10/11/05 (0)
- perhaps.. - jneutron 08:48:29 10/11/05 (6)
- Re: perhaps.. - Soundmind 12:05:16 10/11/05 (5)
- wow.. - jneutron 13:10:21 10/11/05 (4)
- I am astonished at the waste of time and energy on "imagaing" when sound systems do everything else so badly - Soundmind 14:19:17 10/11/05 (3)
- Re: I am astonished at the waste of time and energy on "imagaing" when sound systems do everything else so badly - kerr 10:48:11 10/12/05 (0)
- hmm.. - jneutron 06:36:07 10/12/05 (1)
- If you wish to continue, start a new post..this right side is killin me.nt - jneutron 09:55:28 10/12/05 (0)