In Reply to: Re: That old devil "Wood Effect" posted by mike_h on August 18, 2005 at 13:17:53:
Hi Mike,Mark doesn't appear to understans what Stan is saying in his article about the different pictures shown on his trusty old oscilloscope.
If I can paraphrase - but I won't speak for Clark ... he's old enough and ugly enough to speak for himself! ;-) - there IS such a thing as correct polarity. It's when your speakers deliver the sound of the 'bones BLOWING, at that point in the recording, not sucking.
If your system does this, for that recording, then it has correct (absolute) polarity. It may get inverted an even number of times through your component chain but the final result is correct.
If your system in "incorrect" or reverses polarity, the 'bones won't sound correct.
Having said that, Mark is kinda right because not all recording engineers take as much care as Stan does so many other recordings do not exhibit correct polarity. If all the microphones were at least connected up with the same polarity then flipping your "polarity reversal" switch or reversing R & L speaker cables will restore correct polarity ... for that recording!
More likely, not all microphones were connected right - so you have mixed polarity. In that case, changing absolute polarity will exchange one mess for its reverse ... however, one way is likely to sound more pleasing to your brain.
If only we could clone Stan Ricker ... :-)
Regards,
Andy
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: That old devil "Wood Effect" - andyr 08/18/0514:19:36 08/18/05 (15)
- Re: That old devil "Wood Effect" - Doc Gaw 10:45:41 08/19/05 (9)
- "Obviously the old horn mechanical systems were always in correct polarity." And you know that, how?... nt - clarkjohnsen 09:37:35 08/20/05 (0)
- Hear hear! - andyr 15:16:07 08/19/05 (7)
- have I earned an honorable mention yet? _ (nt) - Mart 10:07:56 08/21/05 (1)
- Har har har ... - andyr 14:29:33 08/21/05 (0)
- "No single person in the history of audiophilia has ruined more people's lives than Clark Johnsen!!" - clarkjohnsen 09:39:43 08/20/05 (4)
- There was a "smiley" after my comment, Clark. - andyr 17:17:41 08/20/05 (3)
- No Andy there were OTHERS,and WELL before Mr Johnsen. - Timbo in Oz 22:59:08 08/21/05 (2)
- Well I did say I had posted a Smiley! ... - andyr 05:14:02 08/22/05 (1)
- Re: Well I did say I had posted a Smiley! ... - Timbo in Oz 15:37:38 08/22/05 (0)
- Re: That old devil "Wood Effect" - markrohr 15:30:58 08/18/05 (4)
- Re: That old devil "Wood Effect" - andyr 15:47:42 08/18/05 (3)
- "That Cardas test disc with 'In polarity' and 'Out of polarity' tracks." - clarkjohnsen 08:25:23 08/19/05 (0)
- I understand . . . finally! ;-) - markrohr 06:39:08 08/19/05 (1)
- Re: I understand . . . finally! ;-) - mitsumoto 06:20:52 08/20/05 (0)