In Reply to: I'm the opposite! posted by E-Stat on January 7, 2022 at 06:17:39:
Relying on THD, THD+noise, or "SINAD" isn't the trick. Simply, THD can be very low but the various harmonics that comprise the overall result can be quite different. Thus a device that is pretty high in 2nd order distortion with maybe a bit of 3rd or 4th but very little higher orders, will probably sound pleasant to most people. Characteristically it will sound smooth, warm, and full-bodied.Furthermore these low order distortions work well to disguise the shortcomings of other components and of not-so-great recordings, (IMO).
So it's OK to like sort of this sound: no need for apology.
However it isn't accurate to the recording which is what some other people want and like. Granted, some types of music are more demanding of ultimate accuracy than others. Classical orchestral and larger-scale choral music fall into this category, (IMO of course), vernacular forms including Jazz not so much.
True accuracy as opposed to euphonic sound requires the lowest possible distortion overall and especially of higher order harmonics. I attach a pic of the distortion profile of the Purifi 1ET440A amp module: this is very close to SOTA in terms of this criteria.
Measurements might not be everything, but checking out measurements can be narrow down the list of equipment you ought to audition to fulfil your musical tastes.
Dmitri Shostakovich
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- It's not complicated: lots of people like distortion - Feanor 01/7/2208:01:45 01/7/22 (7)
- RE: It's not complicated: lots of people like distortion - RGA 17:01:37 01/10/22 (5)
- RE: It's not complicated: lots of people like distortion - RV817 18:09:56 01/10/22 (4)
- RE: It's not complicated: lots of people like distortion - RGA 00:32:59 01/11/22 (3)
- RE: It's not complicated: lots of people like distortion - RV817 12:50:57 01/11/22 (2)
- RE: It's not complicated: lots of people like distortion - RGA 20:07:41 01/11/22 (1)
- 10-4* - RV817 21:11:42 01/11/22 (0)
- "Measurements might not be everything..." - E-Stat 08:12:35 01/7/22 (0)