In Reply to: "But that a listening session is also part of the test suite" posted by Cleantimestream on April 19, 2019 at 13:15:03:
I think I did say exactly that!"And if the listening test fails, then the engineering really doesn't matter." [Gusser]
And I never said everyone hears the same! Who ever did?
But you need to consider we don't hear only with our ears. We hear with our brains. And that brain is highly subject to other influences. This is well proven.
Placebo effect, expectation bias is very real. That's why we have DBT. Now some claim DBT is not perfect either and perhaps it's not. But it's certainly more reliable than listening tests where all the parameters are fully disclosed before hand.
You build tube amps. Tube amps are simple circuits and very wide tolerance. Now can you build a state of the art DC coupled SS amp just from part data sheets. No schematic to follow, just data sheets. Try to do that without resorting to math and EE principles!
As for the 70s and 80s, what about the SS amps of the 60s? And we still have bad audio products today. Point is every decade had good and bad audio components. I still use Haflers of the early 80s. These were good amps. Not everything back then was junk.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: "But that a listening session is also part of the test suite" - gusser 04/19/1913:27:02 04/19/19 (25)
- Absolute Rubbish - Duster 15:56:04 05/2/19 (0)
- RE: "But that a listening session is also part of the test suite" - Cleantimestream 08:03:49 04/20/19 (23)
- +1 -t - Sordidman 11:01:58 04/22/19 (0)
- You missed my point. - gusser 11:30:21 04/20/19 (21)
- RE: You missed my point. - Cleantimestream 16:44:53 04/20/19 (20)
- I never said that! - gusser 17:09:17 04/20/19 (19)
- One can't design anything without engineering principles - Sordidman 11:03:46 04/22/19 (0)
- RE: I never said that! - Cleantimestream 17:25:06 04/20/19 (17)
- Misunderstanding - gusser 17:47:35 04/20/19 (16)
- Another False statement - Sordidman 11:16:08 04/22/19 (15)
- Now you say I am an EE? - gusser 11:31:12 04/22/19 (14)
- you're insulting John and your insulting me - Sordidman 12:02:34 04/22/19 (13)
- RE: you're insulting John and your insulting me - gusser 12:07:39 04/22/19 (12)
- RE: you're insulting John and your insulting me - Sordidman 12:14:34 04/22/19 (11)
- But I have the ability and experience to listen! - gusser 12:19:22 04/22/19 (10)
- RE: But I have the ability and experience to listen! - Sordidman 12:50:19 04/22/19 (9)
- RE: But I have the ability and experience to listen! - gusser 13:59:44 04/22/19 (8)
- RE: But I have the ability and experience to listen! - Sordidman 14:22:49 04/22/19 (7)
- Another area? - gusser 14:38:21 04/22/19 (6)
- RE: Another area? - Sordidman 15:34:17 04/22/19 (5)
- Clueless! - gusser 15:51:52 04/22/19 (4)
- Yes, - you absolutely are..... - Sordidman 16:34:45 04/22/19 (3)
- RE: Yes, - you absolutely are..... - gusser 16:43:57 04/22/19 (2)
- on the basis of your posts - Sordidman 16:58:02 04/22/19 (1)
- RE: on the basis of your posts - gusser 17:00:40 04/22/19 (0)