Why bother with SACD when Jonathan Scull in his Stereophile review of the Sony player says "Overall, I'd rate the SCD-1 playing Super Audio CD a tad less involving than the dCS upsampling front-end. The Sony at its best---ie, with SACD recordings---still had slightly less air and transparency than the more expensive dCS duo."I'm not saying Scull has the final word, but it seems upsampled Redbook is very close to, if not better than SACD. But what you really get with upsampling CDs is access to the zillion titles already out there. You don't have to settle for Toto and Michael Jackson discs for the next couple years.
Why aren't people clamouring for a cheaper upsampler, less than the $20,000 dCS, instead of moving to a new format? And why doesn't a cheap 24/192 upsampler exist by now?
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - Why bother with SACD when... - Stephen Murphy 09:17:51 03/9/00 (23)
- Re: Why bother with SACD when... - Mikenificent1 16:10:29 03/12/00 (0)
- Re: Why bother with SACD when... - ts 06:41:36 03/10/00 (0)
- That's like saying... - Steven Waugh 14:50:33 03/9/00 (4)
- I'm in agreement with you about Scull... - Rich 15:52:24 03/9/00 (0)
- SACD won't necessarily... - Rich 15:44:39 03/9/00 (2)
- I agree... - Steven Waugh 15:56:09 03/9/00 (1)
- Some are so gooood... - Rich 16:32:38 03/9/00 (0)
- Re: Why bother with SACD when... - Kelly 14:36:59 03/9/00 (1)
- Re: Why bother with SACD when... - JoeII-K 17:00:08 03/9/00 (0)
- Re: Why bother with SACD when... - Kelly 14:35:37 03/9/00 (0)
- Re: Why bother with SACD when... - Lee 12:54:12 03/9/00 (8)
- Re: Why bother with SACD when... - JoeII-K 16:51:01 03/9/00 (5)
- Re: Why bother with SACD when... - Lee 17:01:53 03/9/00 (4)
- Re: Why bother with SACD when... - JoeII-K 17:11:14 03/9/00 (3)
- Re: Why bother with SACD when... - Lee 18:05:59 03/9/00 (2)
- Re: Why bother with SACD when... - LenQ 20:08:37 03/9/00 (0)
- Re: Why bother with SACD when... - JoeII-K 18:21:57 03/9/00 (0)
- upset with realloction of resources - Stevo 13:18:24 03/9/00 (0)
- ???? - Rich 13:03:02 03/9/00 (0)
- transport issues - Stevo 11:03:37 03/9/00 (0)
- ???? - Rich 10:46:46 03/9/00 (0)
- Re: Why bother with SACD when... - Rodney Gold 10:30:48 03/9/00 (0)
- Re: Why bother with SACD when... - nataraj 09:40:00 03/9/00 (0)