In Reply to: One Interesting Point posted by Charles Hansen on October 23, 2017 at 23:44:21:
Perhaps I am missing something ( always possible with me) , but isn't the point that recorded music most commonly uses A=440Hz or close to it? If you bought a tuning fork that is what it will be i.e. what has been standard concert pitch since 1939 and is now an ISO standard.
Of course tuning A = 432 may occur but this would be unusual in classical music though (except perhaps for HIP performances of mid 19th century works). However for all I know 432 may be popular in other genres?
I too doubt that that 2Hz variation over A=430 would be audibly very obvious to the average person. After all the mean speed variation of many turntables from a precise 33.3rpm would exceed this and still be unnoticeable to the user.
Anyway I believe that any argument for listening to all recorded music at a nominal pitch other than that used in the actual performance is fallacious.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: One Interesting Point - PAR 10/24/1703:59:16 10/24/17 (14)
- Also agree. That said - jusbe 02:48:32 10/25/17 (6)
- Helps prove that Intonation is an Art, not a Science. Some - oldmkvi 09:25:57 10/26/17 (4)
- RE: piano tuners - thump 16:21:00 12/7/17 (0)
- Yes. Absolutely. - jusbe 10:17:19 10/27/17 (2)
- i remembered the archie cartoon today - thump 14:13:53 12/12/17 (0)
- RE: Yes. Absolutely. - thump 12:29:24 12/9/17 (0)
- Very interesting data point! Thanks. (nt) - Charles Hansen 03:11:45 10/25/17 (0)
- RE: One Interesting Point - Charles Hansen 17:10:55 10/24/17 (4)
- For what it's worth - Frihed89 02:28:02 10/25/17 (0)
- RE: One Interesting Point - PAR 22:54:19 10/24/17 (2)
- Modern Instruments couldn't possibly tune to A 432. It's hard enough keeping 440 without going sharp. - oldmkvi 07:26:13 10/25/17 (0)
- RE: One Interesting Point - Charles Hansen 03:08:39 10/25/17 (0)
- I'm with you, and I Am a Musican... - oldmkvi 05:33:31 10/24/17 (1)
- And even within the Tempered System, we adjust intervals - oldmkvi 10:21:29 10/24/17 (0)