Critic's Corner Discuss a review. Provide constructive feedback. Talk to the industry. |
|
In Reply to: Seems like an utterly absurd premise for a legal case. posted by Rick W on November 8, 2019 at 11:31:01:
> If you consulted a lawyer at the time what was his/her response?
That it was absurd, as he outlined in his response to the plaintiff's
lawyer. Still had to pay for that opinion, of course :-)
John Atkinson
Technical Editor, Stereophile
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups Full ThreadTopic - Manley Review by By Al Chieng - hawkmoon 04:56:50 11/6/19 (77)
- Al Chieng has no clue. I owned a pair of these monoblocks - AbeCollins 20:43:13 11/14/19 (3)
- Abe, you'll love this -- Manley is using a quote from Chieng on their website :-) - Rick W 14:07:22 11/15/19 (1)
- Thanks for pointing that out..... If I were Manley Labs.... - AbeCollins 19:21:57 11/15/19 (0)
- Great picture! - hawkmoon 13:43:44 11/15/19 (0)
- FWIW: i see both sides of this issue, - or 3 sides - Sordidman 11:41:43 11/13/19 (0)
- What speakers did he use? - Rod M 19:35:55 11/10/19 (1)
- RE: "Stairway to Heaven is on the list." - Ivan303 06:58:20 11/11/19 (0)
- Yeah F' that! ... how do they sound playing Kind of Blue or a Bach Kantata??? - bjh 06:14:57 11/9/19 (0)
- Maybe he didn't like it and was preserving an advertiser?* - Billy Wonka 15:40:47 11/8/19 (0)
- That wasn't a review... - Jim Treanor 12:41:13 11/6/19 (0)
- I agree and won't waste my time reading any of Chieng's "reviews" in the future. nt - Rick W 08:06:02 11/6/19 (66)
- Yes. It is a problem with many ( most?) online magazines - PAR 11:18:34 11/6/19 (65)
- 'transported to the soundspace' :p - mhardy6647 05:40:04 11/8/19 (2)
- RE: 'transported to the soundspace' :p - CG 12:42:15 11/8/19 (1)
- Most popular recordings don't even have the folks in the same room/time/space anymore - Timbo in Oz 02:35:37 11/29/19 (0)
- RE: Yes. It is a problem with many ( most?) online magazines - CG 17:58:00 11/6/19 (61)
- Room Measurements - CG 06:29:05 11/9/19 (7)
- How much did the treatments cost, were they precise about where to put them, and did you install them? - Timbo in Oz 15:15:08 12/12/19 (0)
- RE: Room Measurements - Dave_K 14:41:01 11/11/19 (1)
- RE: Room Measurements - CG 16:37:36 11/11/19 (0)
- RE: Room Measurements - John Atkinson 07:13:42 11/10/19 (1)
- RE: Room Measurements - CG 07:54:30 11/10/19 (0)
- RE: Room Measurements - tketcham 04:57:42 11/10/19 (1)
- RE: Room Measurements - CG 07:51:29 11/10/19 (0)
- RE: Yes. It is a problem with many ( most?) online magazines - PAR 04:14:28 11/7/19 (52)
- The reasons why measurements aren't done... - Doug Schneider 09:24:23 11/17/19 (42)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - PAR 09:38:45 11/17/19 (41)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - Doug Schneider 14:31:38 11/17/19 (40)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - pictureguy 15:12:26 11/17/19 (0)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - CG 15:05:32 11/17/19 (38)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - Doug Schneider 16:11:46 11/17/19 (37)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - CG 17:23:12 11/17/19 (36)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - Doug Schneider 17:49:13 11/17/19 (35)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - CG 18:39:31 11/17/19 (34)
- So how about listing, say, 10 out of the hundreds of missing measurements? - Rick W 08:59:46 11/30/19 (4)
- RE: So how about listing, say, 10 out of the hundreds of missing measurements? - CG 19:00:55 11/30/19 (3)
- Thanks for the reply. I'm too ignorant to comment but hope somebody knowledgeable does. nt - Rick W 09:29:54 12/1/19 (2)
- RE: Thanks for the reply. I'm too ignorant to comment but hope somebody knowledgeable does. nt - CG 06:00:08 12/6/19 (1)
- Agree 100%. Well said. nt - Rick W 13:23:18 12/21/19 (0)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - RGA 03:47:43 11/30/19 (28)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - Archimago 11:03:05 11/30/19 (4)
- Measurements Are What They Are - Doug Schneider 13:17:33 11/30/19 (3)
- I'd like to have some of what he was smokin' when he bought those glasses. nt - Rick W 14:07:18 11/30/19 (2)
- That's the guy from, Rush, right?... N/T - musetap 14:35:45 12/7/19 (0)
- RE: I'd like to have some of what he was smokin' when he bought those glasses. nt - Krav Maga 00:34:23 12/5/19 (0)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - CG 07:15:28 11/30/19 (22)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - RGA 15:49:22 11/30/19 (21)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - Doug Schneider 17:21:50 11/30/19 (20)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - RGA 16:58:48 12/1/19 (19)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - Doug Schneider 19:11:50 12/1/19 (18)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - RGA 17:17:20 12/2/19 (9)
- Selling Stereo - Inmate51 11:12:05 12/4/19 (0)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - Doug Schneider 09:46:25 12/3/19 (7)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - RGA 16:59:41 12/6/19 (6)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - Doug Schneider 19:21:04 12/8/19 (5)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - RGA 22:58:28 12/11/19 (3)
- Dealers - Inmate51 08:30:34 12/12/19 (2)
- RE: Dealers - RGA 22:20:59 12/16/19 (1)
- RE: Dealers - Inmate51 10:16:21 12/17/19 (0)
- When I Was 17... - Inmate51 11:40:17 12/10/19 (0)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - Inmate51 10:33:18 12/2/19 (7)
- Additionally - RGA 00:47:25 12/3/19 (4)
- RE: Additionally - Inmate51 12:05:04 12/4/19 (3)
- RE: Additionally - RGA 15:26:50 12/4/19 (2)
- RE: Additionally - Inmate51 16:02:58 12/4/19 (1)
- RE: Additionally - RGA 16:30:11 12/4/19 (0)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - Doug Schneider 15:27:28 12/2/19 (0)
- RE: The reasons why measurements aren't done... - RGA 15:17:00 12/2/19 (0)
- RE: Yes. It is a problem with many ( most?) online magazines - John Atkinson 04:21:43 11/7/19 (8)
- remarkable -- I did NOT know that! - mhardy6647 11:56:10 11/8/19 (0)
- RE: Yes. It is a problem with many ( most?) online magazines - CG 04:42:12 11/7/19 (6)
- RE: Yes. It is a problem with many ( most?) online magazines - jamesgarvin 12:42:25 11/7/19 (3)
- RE: Yes. It is a problem with many ( most?) online magazines - John Atkinson 04:17:31 11/8/19 (2)
- Seems like an utterly absurd premise for a legal case. - Rick W 11:31:01 11/8/19 (1)
- RE: Seems like an utterly absurd premise for a legal case. - John Atkinson 11/8/1911:55:16 11/8/19 (0)
- RE: Yes. It is a problem with many ( most?) online magazines - PAR 04:59:57 11/7/19 (1)
- RE: Yes. It is a problem with many ( most?) online magazines - CG 05:18:35 11/7/19 (0)
Follow Ups
- RE: Seems like an utterly absurd premise for a legal case. - John Atkinson 11/8/1911:55:16 11/8/19 (0)