Critic's Corner Discuss a review. Provide constructive feedback. Talk to the industry. |
|
In Reply to: RE: To me, Sue, high-end, can only be about coherent 3D recordings of acoustic music. posted by Krav Maga on November 4, 2018 at 20:36:12:
> With the assumption that the recordings given to you were the same as the
> recordings Bob Carver gained access to, the results of your test is of some
> importance.
I was told that a journalist colleague had sent Mr. Carver the same set of
MQA files and their PCM originals that I had been sent. So I picked 3 of
the recordings that I had compared.
John Atkinson
Technical Editor, Stereophile
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups Full ThreadTopic - Bob Carver asserts that MQA is perhaps the biggest hoax ever foisted off on the music listening public. - Krav Maga 00:47:52 10/18/18 (69)
- My experience with a Sonic Holograph ... - TeddiJackEddie 06:46:51 10/22/18 (3)
- I experienced the marijuana sound without the marijuana . . . - Billy Wonka 12:23:34 10/23/18 (1)
- Painstakingly setup ...- - GratefulBob 23:33:47 10/23/18 (0)
- RE: My experience with a Sonic Holograph ... - Beetlemania 08:23:31 10/22/18 (0)
- RE: Bob Carver asserts that MQA is perhaps the biggest hoax ever foisted off on the music listening public. - Lee M 17:40:56 10/21/18 (0)
- Bob Carver is still alive? - suekraft 07:51:09 10/21/18 (23)
- RE: Bob Carver is still alive? - stereo5 10:02:43 11/13/18 (0)
- I ask myself that every morning before I go to the trouble of shaving. * - Billy Wonka 14:52:47 10/21/18 (12)
- You should be asking is high end audio still alive - suekraft 16:48:25 10/21/18 (11)
- To me, Sue, high-end, can only be about coherent 3D recordings of acoustic music. - Timbo in Oz 03:48:40 11/1/18 (9)
- RE: To me, Sue, high-end, can only be about coherent 3D recordings of acoustic music. - cpmavrick 05:28:50 11/1/18 (8)
- RE: To me, Sue, high-end, can only be about coherent 3D recordings of acoustic music. - John Atkinson 16:03:04 11/1/18 (7)
- RE: To me, Sue, high-end, can only be about coherent 3D recordings of acoustic music. - cpmavrick 05:40:40 11/2/18 (5)
- RE: To me, Sue, high-end, can only be about coherent 3D recordings of acoustic music. - John Atkinson 07:54:42 11/2/18 (4)
- RE: To me, Sue, high-end, can only be about coherent 3D recordings of acoustic music. - cpmavrick 14:38:26 11/3/18 (3)
- RE: To me, Sue, high-end, can only be about coherent 3D recordings of acoustic music. - John Atkinson 13:00:22 11/4/18 (2)
- RE: To me, Sue, high-end, can only be about coherent 3D recordings of acoustic music. - Krav Maga 20:36:12 11/4/18 (1)
- RE: To me, Sue, high-end, can only be about coherent 3D recordings of acoustic music. - John Atkinson 11/5/1807:56:24 11/5/18 (0)
- "I have read and reread his criticism and it doesn't actually make sense." - Krav Maga 00:22:55 11/2/18 (0)
- Those were the sort of ads I saw just before the demise of Audio magazine-nT - Cleantimestream 06:24:05 10/22/18 (0)
- What is it that JA said that you're agreeing with? nt - Rick W 08:07:29 10/21/18 (8)
- RE: What is it that JA said that you're agreeing with? nt - Krav Maga 14:10:06 10/21/18 (0)
- Wasn't JA questioning the veracity of the article? - suekraft 09:21:57 10/21/18 (3)
- RE: Wasn't JA questioning the veracity of the article? - Krav Maga 16:11:07 10/21/18 (0)
- RE: Wasn't JA questioning the veracity of the article? - Bruce from DC 13:39:28 10/21/18 (0)
- Dunno, but if so I can't find it. nt - Rick W 13:21:47 10/21/18 (0)
- Carver made it all up? (nt) - Steve O 09:04:59 10/21/18 (2)
- Well, after seeing a couple of his Ads, he appears to be a Nut-Job. - oldmkvi 09:28:07 10/21/18 (1)
- Publicity: no such thing as "bad" (nt) - Steve O 10:26:30 10/21/18 (0)
- Just say no to MQA - Jay Buridan 17:49:18 10/19/18 (1)
- not just audio magazines ;) (nt) - mhardy6647 06:37:04 10/20/18 (0)
- Makes the Joyce Hatto scandal seem quaint by comparison... N/T - musetap 11:08:16 10/19/18 (1)
- RE: Makes the Joyce Hatto scandal seem quaint by comparison... N/T - Ruinthere@sbcglobal.net 12:28:08 10/19/18 (0)
- MQA doesn't spy on you or anything.. no it really doesn't - Sordidman 10:45:41 10/19/18 (4)
- RE: MQA doesn't spy on you or anything.. no it really doesn't - Coner 13:48:35 10/19/18 (3)
- WTF? nt - Rick W 14:19:00 10/19/18 (2)
- RE: WTF? nt - Coner 14:38:21 10/19/18 (1)
- Nevermind, pal. nt - Rick W 20:36:33 10/19/18 (0)
- RE: Bob Carver asserts that MQA is perhaps the biggest hoax ever foisted off on the music listening public. - Steve O 12:00:43 10/18/18 (16)
- John Atkinson suggested elsewhere that Bob Carver made this up.... - stehno 22:17:00 10/18/18 (9)
- this is too similar to everything ELSE I hear/read/see in the media nowadays - mhardy6647 08:32:44 10/19/18 (0)
- Where? Link please...(nt) - mkuller 08:32:29 10/19/18 (6)
- RE: Where? Link please...(nt) - Krav Maga 16:10:57 10/19/18 (0)
- Here is the link to Moncrieff's comments - E-Stat 10:10:18 10/19/18 (4)
- My bad on the parentheses .... - stehno 18:04:38 10/19/18 (1)
- RE: "I just assumed others would read it that way..." - Ivan303 07:13:09 10/20/18 (0)
- Ayn Rand is envious (nt) - Steve O 11:24:30 10/19/18 (1)
- Peter Shrugged! -nt - E-Stat 11:33:19 10/19/18 (0)
- I respect both but learned decades ago to listen when Bob Carver shares an opinion. - volunteer 07:46:00 10/19/18 (0)
- wonder if the DRM could tell if one were pulling the analog signal to a tape recorder? - mhardy6647 13:06:17 10/18/18 (4)
- Copying via analogue pathway means the "A" of MQA is gone... - Steve O 13:52:27 10/18/18 (3)
- Watermarking was part of DVD-A - Dave_K 17:31:48 10/18/18 (2)
- An analogue tape dub of the audio on a DVD-A could be traced??? (nt) - Steve O 18:32:41 10/18/18 (1)
- RE: An analogue tape dub of the audio on a DVD-A could be traced??? (nt) - Dave_K 05:08:01 10/19/18 (0)
- RE: Bob Carver asserts that MQA is perhaps the biggest hoax ever foisted off on the music listening public. - TubeDriver 12:18:30 10/18/18 (0)
- Is that surprising? - Ivan303 06:01:01 10/18/18 (4)
- he (Carver, that is) certainly was a master of hyperbole in his prime - mhardy6647 10:04:39 10/18/18 (3)
- RE: he (Carver, that is) certainly was a master of hyperbole in his prime - stehno 01:49:42 10/21/18 (2)
- RE: he (Carver, that is) certainly was a master of hyperbole in his prime - pbarach 10:13:26 10/21/18 (1)
- RE: he (Carver, that is) certainly was a master of hyperbole in his prime - stehno 14:54:18 10/21/18 (0)
- RE: Bob Carver asserts that MQA is perhaps the biggest hoax ever foisted off on the music listening public. - RhythmDevil 03:55:28 10/18/18 (7)
- easy-peasy: Carver's not using his ears, he's using arithmetic! :) (nt) - mhardy6647 13:22:44 10/18/18 (3)
- RE: easy-peasy: Carver's not using his ears, he's using arithmetic! :) (nt) - Krav Maga 13:35:06 10/18/18 (2)
- technically arithmetic, not mathematics, but, yeah :) (nt) - mhardy6647 08:30:57 10/19/18 (1)
- RE: technically arithmetic, not mathematics, but, yeah :) (nt) - Krav Maga 14:18:25 10/19/18 (0)
- RE: Bob Carver asserts that MQA is perhaps the biggest hoax ever foisted off on the music listening public. - ahendler 09:04:16 10/18/18 (2)
- RE: Bob Carver asserts that MQA is perhaps the biggest hoax ever foisted off on the music listening public. - Krav Maga 10:21:16 10/18/18 (0)
- "...differences do(sic) to crosstalk cancellation" - acres verde 10:05:33 10/18/18 (0)
- He is not wrong* - b.l.zeebub 02:07:04 10/18/18 (0)
Follow Ups
- RE: To me, Sue, high-end, can only be about coherent 3D recordings of acoustic music. - John Atkinson 11/5/1807:56:24 11/5/18 (0)