Critic's Corner Discuss a review. Provide constructive feedback. Talk to the industry. |
|
In Reply to: Fair enough posted by E-Stat on June 2, 2018 at 07:40:52:
> Charlie and John had a nice conversation about this a while back.
Thank you for reminding me about this exchange. It bears on an article
I am writing on the time-domain behavior of A/D converters.
John Atkinson
Technical Editor, Stereophile
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups Full ThreadTopic - Where will MQA be a year from now (5/23/19)? - Dale Clark 06:14:29 05/23/18 (102)
- I don't know if it will survive - josh358 09:29:10 06/21/19 (2)
- RE: I don't know if it will survive - Dale Clark 04:10:55 06/24/19 (1)
- RE: I don't know if it will survive - josh358 07:43:58 06/24/19 (0)
- RE: Where will MQA be a year from now (5/23/19)? - Dale Clark 17:04:35 10/15/18 (7)
- RE: Where will MQA be a year from now (5/23/19)? - TubeDriver 06:32:58 01/23/19 (4)
- RE: Where will MQA be a year from now (5/23/19)? - Dale Clark 13:58:16 01/23/19 (3)
- RE: Where will MQA be a year from now (5/23/19)? - TubeDriver 10:06:54 02/7/19 (2)
- RE: Where will MQA be a year from now (5/23/19)? - Dale Clark 05:02:48 02/8/19 (1)
- RE: Where will MQA be a year from now (5/23/19)? - Dale Clark 03:01:17 05/29/19 (0)
- RE: Where will MQA be a year from now (5/23/19)? - Dale Clark 06:51:21 01/9/19 (1)
- RE: Where will MQA be a year from now (5/23/19)? - Krav Maga 16:40:53 01/9/19 (0)
- RE: Where will MQA be a year from now (5/23/19)? - Dale Clark 16:52:10 06/25/18 (0)
- Will MQA have run out of Shills by 5/19/19? - rt66indierock 10:38:25 06/25/18 (0)
- RE: Where will MQA be a year from now (5/23/19)? - TubeDriver 15:41:47 06/22/18 (2)
- RE: Where will MQA be a year from now (5/23/19)? - Krav Maga 16:31:38 06/22/18 (1)
- RE: Where will MQA be a year from now (5/23/19)? - Dale Clark 05:34:16 06/23/18 (0)
- MQA will be fully integrated into block chain tech . . . - Billy Wonka 18:16:35 06/19/18 (1)
- RE: MQA will be fully integrated into block chain tech . . . - Dale Clark 15:45:23 06/20/18 (0)
- RE: Where will MQA be a year from now (5/23/19)? - Dale Clark 05:29:40 06/17/18 (0)
- IMO any attempt to build a controlling position for all recording companys in a streaming world looks - Timbo in Oz 03:29:28 06/15/18 (0)
- A better question might be - 4everyoung 12:52:18 06/11/18 (19)
- A millennial lifestyle? - DAP 06:19:25 06/15/18 (0)
- Sue, so long as I can still play my LPs, CDs, and cassettes on my Nak, - Timbo in Oz 03:44:58 06/15/18 (0)
- RE: A better question might be - CG 19:44:35 06/12/18 (7)
- All true of young people here in the UK too. - jusbe 02:08:31 07/2/18 (1)
- RE: All true of young people here in the UK too. - CG 06:27:28 07/2/18 (0)
- RE: A better question might be - Dale Clark 04:08:56 06/16/18 (4)
- RE: A better question might be - CG 06:48:23 06/16/18 (3)
- RE: A better question might be - Dale Clark 05:27:54 06/17/18 (2)
- RE: A better question might be - CG 08:12:57 06/17/18 (1)
- RE: A better question might be - Dale Clark 18:08:47 06/17/18 (0)
- Double edged sword ... - TeddiJackEddie 06:59:04 06/12/18 (1)
- Great minds think alike - 4everyoung 07:58:13 06/12/18 (0)
- "We Are Millennials. We Are The Future." - Krav Maga 15:48:26 06/11/18 (4)
- "Where is she now?" An independent "contractor"!...for Stereophile no less... - Steve O 16:38:31 06/11/18 (3)
- Ms. Dagdagan's social media say that Stereophile is a former position - John Marks 10:03:59 06/13/18 (1)
- My, that didn't take long... - Steve O 10:39:38 06/13/18 (0)
- poor girl - 4everyoung 01:53:19 06/12/18 (0)
- RE: A better question might be - regmac 14:00:30 06/11/18 (1)
- Successful millennials apparently have been smitten by many leisure pursuits... - Steve O 14:49:54 06/11/18 (0)
- Will it outlast this thread? - Atwood 09:13:57 06/11/18 (0)
- Hopefully, in my listening room - 4everyoung 05:58:16 06/2/18 (1)
- RE: Hopefully, in my listening room - Bruce from DC 15:44:48 06/2/18 (0)
- Still hailed by the print media - Beetlemania 13:54:15 05/26/18 (31)
- Well, the print media has a certain advantage - josh358 14:37:36 05/31/18 (30)
- So have many of us critics, listened to MQA that is, and don't think it's any better than native high rez [nt] - Steve Cortez 16:32:47 05/31/18 (29)
- RE: So have many of us critics, listened to MQA that is, and don't think it's any better than native high rez [nt] - josh358 17:10:38 05/31/18 (28)
- Note from a graph in another thread - E-Stat 11:48:47 06/1/18 (25)
- But DSD is a lossy format . . . - josh358 13:55:44 06/1/18 (24)
- RE: But DSD is a lossy format . . . - PAR 17:41:28 06/2/18 (7)
- Is Dynamic Range the only consideration? nt - oldmkvi 17:53:45 06/4/18 (1)
- RE: Is Dynamic Range the only consideration? nt - PAR 01:33:43 06/5/18 (0)
- My guess is... - E-Stat 12:03:18 06/3/18 (3)
- Remember this? - Krav Maga 16:05:08 06/3/18 (2)
- I wouldn't exactly call - E-Stat 16:34:50 06/3/18 (1)
- RE: I wouldn't exactly call - Krav Maga 19:04:05 06/3/18 (0)
- RE: But DSD is a lossy format . . . - josh358 18:44:05 06/2/18 (0)
- The industry - E-Stat 14:34:32 06/1/18 (15)
- The point - josh358 15:11:09 06/1/18 (14)
- RE: The point - E-Stat 15:25:41 06/1/18 (13)
- RE: The point - josh358 16:14:51 06/1/18 (12)
- My experience - E-Stat 16:47:44 06/1/18 (11)
- RE: My experience - josh358 16:57:51 06/1/18 (10)
- We're not communicating - E-Stat 17:19:17 06/1/18 (9)
- RE: We're not communicating - josh358 19:12:49 06/1/18 (8)
- RE: We're not communicating - E-Stat 19:24:57 06/1/18 (7)
- RE: We're not communicating - josh358 19:54:19 06/1/18 (6)
- RE: We're not communicating - E-Stat 20:38:40 06/1/18 (5)
- RE: We're not communicating - josh358 05:14:46 06/2/18 (4)
- Fair enough - E-Stat 07:40:52 06/2/18 (3)
- RE: Fair enough - John Atkinson 06/2/1816:03:55 06/2/18 (1)
- You're welcome - E-Stat 05:32:41 06/3/18 (0)
- RE: Fair enough - josh358 10:19:18 06/2/18 (0)
- "rather between MQA and 44.1" - lol, the goalposts move again - Beetlemania 07:35:12 06/1/18 (1)
- RE: "rather between MQA and 44.1" - lol, the goalposts move again - josh358 11:39:43 06/1/18 (0)
- The Smithsonian's Stone Age Exhibit -nt - Jim Treanor 16:40:43 05/25/18 (0)
- not in my home, or car. - toothpaste 17:05:02 05/24/18 (3)
- Actually... - E-Stat 11:53:37 05/27/18 (2)
- RE: Actually... - Dale Clark 16:00:41 05/29/18 (1)
- RE: Actually... - TubeDriver 11:04:38 05/30/18 (0)
- Stillborn I expect, because.... - Steve Cortez 23:47:17 05/23/18 (4)
- I just looked and apple isn't that big - josh358 14:34:24 05/31/18 (2)
- You might want to look at a more updated stat... - Steve Cortez 16:30:05 05/31/18 (1)
- I'm not sure why this differs so much - josh358 05:15:22 06/1/18 (0)
- True about the 99%. And besides - DAP 07:47:56 05/24/18 (0)
- RE: Where will MQA be a year from now (5/23/19)? - TubeDriver 10:23:49 05/23/18 (1)
- If Tidal fails - josh358 14:40:36 05/31/18 (0)
- RE:Dead and buried hopefully. - b.l.zeebub 08:59:42 05/23/18 (0)
- RE: Where will MQA be a year from now (5/23/19)? - PAR 08:54:11 05/23/18 (13)
- Perhaps... - mkuller 11:08:48 05/24/18 (0)
- Were you aware that US Sprint paid cash (or so I was told) for a substantial minority position in Tidal? - John Marks 16:38:48 05/23/18 (11)
- RE: Were you aware that US Sprint paid cash (or so I was told) for a substantial minority position in Tidal? - regmac 04:44:31 05/24/18 (7)
- RE: Were you aware that US Sprint paid cash (or so I was told) for a substantial minority position in Tidal? - Dale Clark 04:55:43 05/24/18 (6)
- RE: Were you aware that US Sprint paid cash (or so I was told) for a substantial minority position in Tidal? - regmac 05:38:50 05/24/18 (5)
- RE: Were you aware that US Sprint paid cash (or so I was told) for a substantial minority position in Tidal? - Dale Clark 06:02:11 05/24/18 (0)
- As usual, regmac, you hit the nail on the head ... - TeddiJackEddie 06:01:11 05/24/18 (3)
- "This is all about the aging of the baby boom." - Krav Maga 11:20:45 05/24/18 (1)
- RE: "This is all about the aging of the baby boom." - Dale Clark 14:20:02 05/24/18 (0)
- RE: As usual, regmac, you hit the nail on the head ... - regmac 06:14:08 05/24/18 (0)
- RE: Were you aware that US Sprint paid cash (or so I was told) for a substantial minority position in Tidal? - PAR 03:20:02 05/24/18 (2)
- You are welcome! - John Marks 17:47:59 05/24/18 (1)
- RE: You are welcome! - PAR 02:47:52 05/26/18 (0)
Follow Ups
- RE: Fair enough - John Atkinson 06/2/1816:03:55 06/2/18 (1)
- You're welcome - E-Stat 05:32:41 06/3/18 (0)