Critic's Corner Discuss a review. Provide constructive feedback. Talk to the industry. |
|
In Reply to: Watched the whole thing. Enjoyed it immensely! posted by Bruce from DC on March 2, 2018 at 18:29:50:
John Atkinson
Technical Editor, Stereophile
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups Full ThreadTopic - Should a professional review mention what speakers are used..... - viridian 15:36:17 02/18/18 (132)
- Should the pope poop in the pines? - Jay Buridan 09:10:27 03/4/18 (3)
- Why isn't a copy of Stereophile photoshopped in, to replace the newspaper??? nt - toothpaste 09:38:06 03/4/18 (2)
- RE: Why isn't a copy of Stereophile photoshopped in, to replace the newspaper??? nt - John Atkinson 11:23:05 03/5/18 (1)
- Plus, I'm not adept at photoshop - Jay Buridan 12:02:04 03/5/18 (0)
- I'd rather know what he ate, how his social life is going, and other blather they all write about. - toothpaste 09:25:55 02/23/18 (87)
- RE: I'd rather know what he ate, how his social life is going, and other blather they all write about. - acres verde 13:33:56 02/23/18 (85)
- RE: I'd rather know what he ate, how his social life is going, and other blather they all write about. - John Atkinson 16:23:09 02/23/18 (84)
- RE: I'd rather know what he ate, how his social life is going, and other blather they all write about. - acres verde 20:14:30 02/25/18 (0)
- Sam Tellig comes to mind! nt - oldmkvi 16:56:14 02/23/18 (82)
- A perfect counterpoint to Atkinson, he . . . - Billy Wonka 08:14:06 03/7/18 (0)
- "...even my wife, Marina, ..." /nt\ - cdb 07:25:05 02/25/18 (71)
- How about Lars? - 4everyoung 07:13:16 02/28/18 (0)
- Sam was like a breath of fresh air in a hobby that reeks of stuffy old men - 4everyoung 07:59:57 02/25/18 (69)
- If you can't stand the heat, go into the kitchen! - 13th Duke of Wymbourne 17:35:38 02/27/18 (0)
- He was a complete drag here! Always cranky, and he put down SACD regularly, - oldmkvi 09:12:04 02/27/18 (1)
- in fairness to Sam . . . - Bruce from DC 19:26:29 03/6/18 (0)
- But he was... - mkuller 12:09:02 02/25/18 (65)
- And bitter as evidenced by his private disputes with JA he openly complained about here (nt) - Steve O 14:25:45 02/25/18 (64)
- His columns were neither stuffy nor bitter. nt - Rick W 15:16:59 02/25/18 (63)
- Sam had a sense of humor and we all know.. - 4everyoung 07:30:27 02/26/18 (62)
- "I'm starting my own website and looking for a sidekick ... Sam" - DAP 10:31:01 02/27/18 (59)
- What about Corey Greenburg? nt - Ozzie 21:05:57 03/1/18 (17)
- RE: What about Corey Greenburg? nt - BubbaMike 18:19:56 03/4/18 (2)
- RE: What about Corey Greenburg? nt - SpotcheckBilly12345 07:17:08 03/5/18 (0)
- Corey on the NBC Today Show - 4everyoung 04:23:03 03/5/18 (0)
- I wouldn't hire anyone crazier than me :-) - 4everyoung 10:57:51 03/2/18 (13)
- female perspective? - DAP 13:45:37 03/2/18 (12)
- And men wonder why there aren't more women in the hobby... (nt) - Dave_K 07:51:25 03/3/18 (0)
- RE: female perspective? - 4everyoung 06:35:25 03/3/18 (1)
- Where you find quite a few - E-Stat 08:04:02 03/3/18 (0)
- pretty snarky, there DAP - Bruce from DC 18:24:42 03/2/18 (8)
- It wasn't obvious to me why 4everyoung mentioned a female perspective - DAP 17:44:19 03/3/18 (7)
- Fiddling, tinkering and tweaking - 4everyoung 08:23:38 03/5/18 (3)
- I'd love to ask the women in this hobby what initially sparked their interest. - DAP 09:10:51 03/5/18 (2)
- One of the owners/managers at Stereo Exchange in NYC is a woman. nt - Rick W 10:27:06 03/5/18 (1)
- RE: One of the owners/managers at Stereo Exchange in NYC is a woman. nt - 4everyoung 15:29:47 03/5/18 (0)
- RE: It wasn't obvious to me why 4everyoung mentioned a female perspective - Bruce from DC 20:34:21 03/3/18 (2)
- RE: It wasn't obvious to me why 4everyoung mentioned a female perspective - Inmate51 09:24:26 03/5/18 (1)
- change: why? - Bruce from DC 19:29:56 03/6/18 (0)
- RE: "I'm starting my own website and looking for a sidekick ... Sam" - 4everyoung 05:47:17 02/28/18 (0)
- ...Past, Present, Future... - Doug Schneider 13:12:34 02/27/18 (11)
- Garrett Hongo has by far the most well-trained ears I've ever encountered. - stehno 20:54:04 03/8/18 (0)
- Brent Butterworth? - Dave Pogue 10:25:18 02/28/18 (0)
- web-site wagging the dog - 13th Duke of Wymbourne 17:32:26 02/27/18 (8)
- RE: web-site wagging the dog - Doug Schneider 18:43:34 02/27/18 (2)
- For instance, what is the purpose of the soundstagesimplifi site? - DAP 19:09:35 02/27/18 (1)
- RE: For instance, what is the purpose of the soundstagesimplifi site? - Doug Schneider 19:23:42 02/27/18 (0)
- I agree with that - DAP 18:24:55 02/27/18 (0)
- agreed - Bruce from DC 18:24:28 02/27/18 (3)
- RE: agreed - Doug Schneider 18:41:42 02/27/18 (2)
- Thanks for the reply, Doug - Bruce from DC 18:12:31 03/2/18 (1)
- RE: Thanks for the reply, Doug - Doug Schneider 18:30:52 03/2/18 (0)
- RE: "I'm starting my own website and looking for a sidekick ... Sam" - John Atkinson 11:03:23 02/27/18 (27)
- As a content producer yourself, do you think you still need the magazines? (nt) - DAP 19:30:05 02/27/18 (26)
- RE: As a content producer yourself, do you think you still need the magazines? (nt) - John Atkinson 04:35:33 02/28/18 (11)
- RE: As a content producer yourself, do you think you still need the magazines? (nt) - John Atkinson 12:41:18 02/28/18 (9)
- RE: As a content producer yourself, do you think you still need the magazines? (nt) - DAP 13:31:06 02/28/18 (0)
- RE: As a content producer yourself, do you think you still need the magazines? (nt) - Doug Schneider 13:21:26 02/28/18 (7)
- RE: As a content producer yourself, do you think you still need the magazines? (nt) - John Atkinson 13:36:33 02/28/18 (6)
- Specialty hobby magazines may never die. They have a special connection to the reader. - toothpaste 09:40:05 03/1/18 (1)
- RE: Specialty hobby magazines may never die. They have a special connection to the reader. - John Atkinson 07:18:35 03/2/18 (0)
- RE: As a content producer yourself, do you think you still need the magazines? (nt) - John Atkinson 04:28:52 03/1/18 (3)
- Watched the whole thing. Enjoyed it immensely! - Bruce from DC 18:29:50 03/2/18 (1)
- Thank you (NT) - John Atkinson 03/4/1804:56:35 03/4/18 (0)
- Thanks - 4everyoung 06:35:15 03/1/18 (0)
- How would these compare in numbers? - DAP 07:01:17 02/28/18 (0)
- Dead tree edition ad blockers are still in developmental stage (nt) - Steve O 20:22:50 02/27/18 (13)
- Dead tree edition ads are HALF of the reason to look at the printed magazine... - toothpaste 09:42:07 03/1/18 (0)
- Good point :-) - DAP 20:31:36 02/27/18 (11)
- RE: Good point :-) - Doug Schneider 08:21:20 02/28/18 (10)
- There's not an online audio publication or forum in the world that operates behind a paywall. - DAP 13:38:25 02/28/18 (0)
- Paywalls seem to work if "readers" truly value the content... - Steve O 09:40:49 02/28/18 (8)
- RE: Paywalls seem to work if "readers" truly value the content... - Doug Schneider 09:53:05 02/28/18 (7)
- " If someone can set up a pay site and have someone pay..." - 4everyoung 11:01:09 02/28/18 (6)
- I'll take your word for it regarding the other sites... - Steve O 11:48:51 02/28/18 (4)
- RE: I'll take your word for it regarding the other sites... - Doug Schneider 12:58:28 02/28/18 (1)
- As a "user" I KNOW the ad vs adblock war is escalating.. - Steve O 14:39:56 02/28/18 (0)
- At least the print magazines... - 4everyoung 12:55:32 02/28/18 (1)
- RE: At least the print magazines... - Doug Schneider 13:09:57 02/28/18 (0)
- RE: " If someone can set up a pay site and have someone pay..." - Doug Schneider 11:41:53 02/28/18 (0)
- I you website going to be blog?, reviews? Do you have a server? nt - toothpaste 13:42:34 02/26/18 (1)
- RE: I you website going to be blog?, reviews? Do you have a server? nt - 4everyoung 14:37:17 02/26/18 (0)
- Sam Tellig really started the whole thing of wasting a full page on prattle. - toothpaste 10:03:54 02/24/18 (8)
- That was always annoying to me. (NT) - marc g. 20:08:50 02/25/18 (0)
- RE: Sam Tellig really started the whole thing of wasting a full page on prattle. - regmac 12:28:48 02/24/18 (6)
- I also enjoyed Lisa Astor.. - 4everyoung 07:36:02 02/25/18 (4)
- RE: I also enjoyed Lisa Astor.. - mkuller 20:50:00 02/27/18 (3)
- Ah, yes, Enid Lumley... - Steve O 06:09:52 02/28/18 (2)
- That was Judith Reilly, not Enid - Dave Pogue 10:29:17 02/28/18 (1)
- Ah yes: Those were the early days...it's all a blur now (nt) - Steve O 10:36:26 02/28/18 (0)
- THe problem is: if a little was good, more is not always better. nt - toothpaste 04:37:56 02/25/18 (0)
- Come on... - mkuller 10:43:13 02/23/18 (0)
- RE: Should a professional review mention what speakers are used..... - hahax@verizon.net 20:55:16 02/22/18 (0)
- RE: Should a professional review mention what speakers are used..... - fstein 13:12:28 02/20/18 (2)
- RE: Should a professional review mention what speakers are used..... - regmac 19:04:54 02/23/18 (0)
- "Bitter old men" - 4everyoung 18:10:27 02/20/18 (0)
- RE: Should a professional review mention what speakers are used..... - fantja 03:06:49 02/20/18 (0)
- RE: Should a professional review mention what speakers are used..... - John Atkinson 04:17:51 02/19/18 (27)
- What, no LS3/5As? - Frihed89 15:06:30 02/19/18 (0)
- Why didn't the reviewer mention them... - mkuller 09:38:15 02/19/18 (0)
- Tough audience ! - E-Stat 06:39:15 02/19/18 (4)
- RE: Tough audience ! HAH! - hifitommy 12:05:12 02/19/18 (3)
- RE: Tough audience ! HAH! - E-Stat 12:31:32 02/19/18 (2)
- RE: Tough audience ! HAH! - kentaja 17:16:26 02/19/18 (1)
- Thanks - E-Stat 07:13:37 02/20/18 (0)
- Thank you, but I'm throwing in the towel.... - viridian 05:14:17 02/19/18 (19)
- I was thinking the same thing, but - Frihed89 13:54:12 02/24/18 (0)
- RE: Thank you, but I'm throwing in the towel.... - kentaja 17:13:10 02/19/18 (14)
- " Stereophile is a great magazine and well worth the buck a month that is costs." +1 n/t - PAR 03:49:01 02/20/18 (13)
- RE: " Stereophile is a great magazine and well worth the buck a month that is costs." +1 n/t - kentaja 06:02:09 02/20/18 (12)
- Not to mention gushing sycophants....nt - viridian 10:27:12 02/20/18 (11)
- Hardly.... - kentaja 10:58:48 02/20/18 (10)
- Well, aside from what you view as his whine...... - Rick W 11:27:05 02/20/18 (9)
- RE: Well, aside from what you view as his whine...... - kentaja 12:14:28 02/20/18 (6)
- RE: Well, aside from what you view as his whine...... - John Atkinson 14:13:06 02/20/18 (2)
- As I have said on this forum before you are always a class act..... - viridian 14:36:39 02/20/18 (0)
- RE: Well, aside from what you view as his whine...... - kentaja 14:17:48 02/20/18 (0)
- RE: Well, aside from what you view as his whine...... - Rick W 12:47:18 02/20/18 (2)
- RE: Well, aside from what you view as his whine...... - gordguide 11:25:39 02/21/18 (0)
- RE: Well, aside from what you view as his whine...... - kentaja 13:50:12 02/20/18 (0)
- Although as Tuco (the Good, the Bad and the Ugly) might have said - DAP 11:40:27 02/20/18 (1)
- Exactly! - kentaja 12:15:11 02/20/18 (0)
- RE: Thank you, but I'm throwing in the towel.... - SpotcheckBilly12345 08:26:29 02/19/18 (2)
- RE: Thank you, but I'm throwing in the towel.... - PAR 11:09:37 02/19/18 (0)
- I'm just fine with Mr. Atkinson having to make an editorial decision.... - viridian 08:49:59 02/19/18 (0)
- Yes... - mkuller 19:20:59 02/18/18 (0)
- RE: Should a professional review mention what speakers are used..... - Kal Rubinson 16:02:13 02/18/18 (5)
- mention what speakers are used..... - hifitommy 12:09:38 02/19/18 (0)
- Thanks Kal, but that did not appear in the print version of the mag.... - viridian 16:23:58 02/18/18 (3)
- RE: Thanks Kal, but that did not appear in the print version of the mag.... - Kal Rubinson 17:09:47 02/18/18 (2)
- RE: "you should ask it in the comment thread attached to the article on the Stereophile website" - Krav Maga 13:56:27 02/19/18 (1)
- I thought it would be more likely to get a response there. (NT) - Kal Rubinson 19:51:44 02/19/18 (0)
Follow Ups
- Thank you (NT) - John Atkinson 03/4/1804:56:35 03/4/18 (0)