I agree with you... I've NEVER understood what all the fuss....

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - C. Kleiber/VPO Beethoven 5th - Doktor Brahms 06:47:48 12/31/20 (50)

Wow - can I get in on this C. Kleiber hate-fest too? - Chris from Lafayette 15:13:37 12/31/20 (46)

RE: Wow - can I get in on this C. Kleiber hate-fest too? - gussclarinet 12:03:37 01/14/21 (2)

RE: Wow - can I get in on this C. Kleiber hate-fest too? - pbarach 13:49:23 01/14/21 (1)

RE: Wow - can I get in on this C. Kleiber hate-fest too? - gussclarinet 06:59:47 01/15/21 (0)

RE: Wow - can I get in on this C. Kleiber hate-fest too? - Todd Krieger 19:58:10 01/1/21 (39)

Berlin Philharmonic should have consulted with you prior to offering him the musical directorship - tinear 09:27:05 01/3/21 (28)

As I Was Saying............. - Todd Krieger 23:43:49 01/8/21 (0)

Touche, tin! But I think one has to be careful with polls like that BBC one - Chris from Lafayette 11:17:07 01/3/21 (26)

They were conductors. 100. Many of high note. I just mentioned the poll - tinear 11:24:27 01/3/21 (25)

Just exactly HOW many of high note, aside from the four you list? - Chris from Lafayette 11:41:20 01/3/21 (24)

A cursory look at others high on that list should - tinear 12:31:55 01/3/21 (23)

LOL. This forum should be renamed "Conductor Denigration". Its always been like this. nt - Rick W 11:01:14 01/4/21 (1)

It comes with the territory! - Chris from Lafayette 12:53:48 01/4/21 (0)

Furtwangler, Karajan. . . yeah! - Chris from Lafayette 14:27:20 01/3/21 (20)

RE: Furtwangler, Karajan. . . yeah! - blakey 19:45:49 01/3/21 (1)

Good point about Kleiber's limited discography - Chris from Lafayette 01:21:06 01/4/21 (0)

Orwell did no such thing. He wrote that Tolstoy had. - tinear 18:56:37 01/3/21 (17)

And Tolstoy DID! (And Orwell agreed!) - Chris from Lafayette 01:17:10 01/4/21 (16)

So you got your source wrong? You probably didn't even read - tinear 07:15:50 01/4/21 (14)

You would do well not to make assumptions on the little evidence you have - Chris from Lafayette 10:54:25 01/4/21 (13)

Pretty amusing that you quote some critics/reviewers to bolster you point while classifying...... - Rick W 11:27:26 01/4/21 (3)

Here's the thing, Rick - Chris from Lafayette 13:08:57 01/4/21 (2)

RE: Here's the thing, Rick - rivervalley817 13:49:50 01/4/21 (1)

That too! [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 16:10:22 01/4/21 (0)

You seem unable or unwilling to read a reply. You just keep repeating. Go back, - tinear 11:14:04 01/4/21 (8)

Just keep it up with the pronouncements, tin! ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 12:02:30 01/4/21 (0)

RE: You seem unable or unwilling to read a reply. You just keep repeating. Go back, - rivervalley817 11:37:06 01/4/21 (6)

Hey, man - I take the difference between ebonics and eubonics very seriously! [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 12:10:05 01/4/21 (4)

RE: Hey, man - I take the difference between ebonics and eubonics very seriously! [nt] ;-) - rivervalley817 12:22:15 01/4/21 (3)

I did NOT know that - very interesting! [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 12:52:12 01/4/21 (2)

RE: I did NOT know that - very interesting! [nt] - rivervalley817 13:39:56 01/4/21 (1)

Fact checking - always appreciated! [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 16:11:59 01/4/21 (0)

Cookies? Did you say... cookies? Before me, right this second, are several dozen - tinear 11:56:13 01/4/21 (0)

Rattle and original instruments - pbarach 04:51:03 01/4/21 (0)

Proof of the pudding for Yuja (for me) - Chris from Lafayette 01:34:26 01/2/21 (9)

Reminds me of something similar but different - Analog Scott 09:16:12 01/5/21 (0)

I had the same thing happen to me - DrChaos 12:11:03 01/2/21 (7)

You know, I could see hearing some of these C. Kleiber recordings. . . - Chris from Lafayette 12:21:10 01/2/21 (6)

Kleiber DG on SHM-CD is wonderful - richardl 13:39:08 01/2/21 (3)

Did they do a remaster for that incarnation? - Chris from Lafayette 14:19:22 01/2/21 (2)

RE: Did they do a remaster for that incarnation? - richardl 10:22:17 01/5/21 (1)

Yes - that's what I would suspect too - thanks! [nt] - Chris from Lafayette 12:40:32 01/7/21 (0)

RE: You know, I could see hearing some of these C. Kleiber recordings. . . - pbarach 12:42:16 01/2/21 (1)

RE: You know, I could see hearing some of these C. Kleiber recordings. . . - Wojciech 13:10:50 01/2/21 (0)

Scherchen's is the one to have. Energy could light up a small city. Nt - jdaniel@jps.net 17:09:25 12/31/20 (0)

'70's HVK Beeth. 7th beats hell outta Kleiber's IMO. I'm a fan of Kleiber's 5th despite shaky LP sound. nt. - Rick W 17:05:16 12/31/20 (0)

I'm told by friend that you have to wait till after 12:00 California time... - Ivan303 15:52:39 12/31/20 (0)

I agree with you... I've NEVER understood what all the fuss.... - TWB 12/31/2010:59:06 12/31/20 (0)

RE: C. Kleiber/VPO Beethoven 5th - Dave Billinge 09:51:57 12/31/20 (0)

RE: C. Kleiber/VPO Beethoven 5th - classfolkphile 08:02:21 12/31/20 (0)

Follow Ups

I agree with you... I've NEVER understood what all the fuss.... - TWB 12/31/2010:59:06 12/31/20 (0)

Post a Message!