Classical Court From Perotin to Prokofiev (and beyond), performed by Caruso to Khatia, it's all here. |
|
In Reply to: I NEVER understood the love fest for Mehta.... posted by TWB on January 4, 2019 at 08:44:18:
Mahler, Mozart Opera dvds
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups Full ThreadTopic - Schumann Symphonies..... - TWB 21:28:24 01/2/19 (59)
- Tennstedt/Berliner ... - kuma 01:46:10 01/8/19 (0)
- RE: Schumann Symphonies..... - flyingdutchman 23:58:01 01/3/19 (0)
- Christoph von Dohnanyi, Carlo Maria Giulini, and Otto Klemperer....... - Todd Krieger 19:20:17 01/3/19 (17)
- Otto Klemperer for sure in #4 - andy evans 04:21:15 01/4/19 (16)
- Not bad for Klemperer - Chris from Lafayette 13:03:13 01/4/19 (10)
- RE: Not bad for Klemperer - Todd Krieger 17:52:16 01/5/19 (9)
- Basically, I agree about the Schumann Fourth first movement - Chris from Lafayette 21:47:12 01/5/19 (8)
- Tchaikovsky Four Opening Movement............... - Todd Krieger 00:02:19 01/6/19 (7)
- RE: Tchaikovsky Four Opening Movement............... - docw 10:01:13 01/9/19 (0)
- I remember Jahja Ling - he conducted in SF too - Chris from Lafayette 00:58:11 01/6/19 (5)
- RE: I remember Jahja Ling - he conducted in SF too - pbarach 03:36:31 01/7/19 (0)
- RE: I remember Jahja Ling - he conducted in SF too - Todd Krieger 10:32:30 01/6/19 (3)
- My one live experience with Janowski - TGR 08:11:27 01/7/19 (1)
- RE: My one live experience with Janowski - pbarach 16:07:03 01/7/19 (0)
- Well now you've got me more interested in that Janowski recording! [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 11:23:04 01/6/19 (0)
- Nuthin' wrong with the Klemperer but I don't hear it as better than the Bernstein/NYP LP I have. - Rick W 09:09:38 01/4/19 (4)
- RE: Nuthin' wrong with the Klemperer but I don't hear it as better than the Bernstein/NYP LP I have. - Todd Krieger 18:21:57 01/5/19 (3)
- "The only thing that makes me prefer the Klemperer is there was more "biting articulation"" - Chris from Lafayette 21:51:59 01/5/19 (2)
- RE: "The only thing that makes me prefer the Klemperer is there was more "biting articulation"" - Todd Krieger 22:49:49 01/5/19 (1)
- I think the Klemperer stereo recordings came mostly from the time when EMI. . . - Chris from Lafayette 22:54:04 01/5/19 (0)
- Wow- so much Schumann! - TGR 10:40:49 01/3/19 (16)
- No. 2 is my favorite. - Daverz 20:06:26 01/4/19 (0)
- The Rhenish is my favorite AND Giulini was one of my favorite... - TWB 18:29:56 01/3/19 (11)
- Available on DG - TGR 08:26:51 01/4/19 (10)
- I JUST found my copy! I had it filed under Beethoven because the disc pairs the Rhenish... - TWB 14:30:25 01/8/19 (0)
- I NEVER understood the love fest for Mehta.... - TWB 08:44:18 01/4/19 (8)
- OK, Mehta will never be confused with Giulini - Chris from Lafayette 14:47:18 01/4/19 (6)
- Mehta and Holst's The Planets is ANOTHER revered combo.... - TWB 14:59:56 01/4/19 (5)
- I second that - TGR 15:55:47 01/4/19 (4)
- I agree with you on Steinberg.... But for me the piece hinges on.... - TWB 20:23:26 01/4/19 (0)
- I wasn't speaking of my own favorite Planets, just the general critical consensus - Chris from Lafayette 17:31:53 01/4/19 (2)
- I enjoyed Mehta's Bruckner 9th quite a bit, HDTT transfer. nt - jdaniel@jps.net 09:49:57 01/5/19 (1)
- His LA Bruckner Fourth also received kudos from Robert C. Marsh in the old High Fidelity magazine - Chris from Lafayette 22:12:07 01/5/19 (0)
- RE: I NEVER understood the love fest for Mehta.... - fstein 01/4/1914:32:34 01/4/19 (0)
- RE: Wow- so much Schumann! - docw 15:09:16 01/3/19 (0)
- I'd also recommend Furt's live 4th with the RIAS on Audite. And I recall Kubelik's 2nd cycle being semi- - jdaniel@jps.net 12:25:50 01/3/19 (1)
- Kubelik's 2nd cycle - TGR 17:35:06 01/3/19 (0)
- SFS? nt - oldmkvi 10:21:00 01/3/19 (11)
- After my positive experience w/ their 6th, I'm very curious. Nt - jdaniel@jps.net 12:28:10 01/3/19 (10)
- I rarely say anything bad about a performance.... - srl1 16:30:12 01/4/19 (9)
- Glad you did. That's why we're here. nt - jdaniel@jps.net 18:20:00 01/4/19 (0)
- "Every time there is a new SFS release I really get my hopes up, but usually I'm somewhat disappointed" - Chris from Lafayette 17:33:39 01/4/19 (7)
- Case by case...case by case...case by case...case by case.... nt - jdaniel@jps.net 18:25:43 01/4/19 (6)
- Case by case. . . case by case. . . produce broad generalizations [nt] ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 01:30:23 01/5/19 (5)
- Exactly the opposite, no? : ) nt. - jdaniel@jps.net 08:19:35 01/5/19 (4)
- Well. . . if the cases are all consistent with each other, then you can derive a valid generalization ;-) - Chris from Lafayette 09:11:11 01/5/19 (3)
- Too often, one misses the unexpected home run: Haitink's Debussy, Von K's early years, Solti's... Solti's... - jdaniel@jps.net 09:21:05 01/5/19 (2)
- According to TWB (above), it's Solti's. . . Planets! - Chris from Lafayette 09:46:22 01/5/19 (1)
- Right there in front of me! I'd forgotten that his "Planets" turned out to be my favorite of the Lp versions - jdaniel@jps.net 09:48:51 01/5/19 (0)
- RE: Schumann Symphonies - my list - andy evans 02:41:38 01/3/19 (3)
- Interesting List! - Chris from Lafayette 10:01:05 01/3/19 (2)
- RE: Interesting List! - Berrell88 15:37:03 01/5/19 (1)
- Yes. . . I have to admit that, sometimes when I've listened to that Goodman version . . . - Chris from Lafayette 22:18:41 01/5/19 (0)
- RE: Schumann Symphonies..... - Russell 23:39:24 01/2/19 (0)
- RE: Schumann Symphonies..... - Mel 21:34:52 01/2/19 (3)
- "You might like to try Frank Beermann" - Yes! - Chris from Lafayette 01:30:13 01/3/19 (2)
- Sawallisch - Dave Billinge 08:46:53 01/3/19 (0)
- Will give Sawallisch a go today.... - Ivan303 06:10:52 01/3/19 (0)
- RE: Schumann Symphonies..... - fstein 21:34:35 01/2/19 (0)
Follow Ups
- RE: I NEVER understood the love fest for Mehta.... - fstein 01/4/1914:32:34 01/4/19 (0)