![]() |
Amp/Preamp Asylum Looking for a new Amp or Preamp? If you're after tubes, post over here. |
|
In Reply to: RE: your statement isn't logical. posted by morricab on February 15, 2025 at 23:57:49:
I'm not twisting anything. I have been told many times I take things too literally.
Sorry, you said Class B amps don't have to have zero crossing distortion and I just showed you many examples of so called Class AB amps that have crossover distortion.This would imply that basically all Class B amps have this because that is simply how transistors behave.
The conclusion in the above statement isn't supported by its opening sentence. In addition to that I see you are qualifying it now by this comment:
I never said all AB amps.
That is true, where your argument falls apart is this conclusion:
I said even a lot of AB amps have zero crossing distortion, so reduce that bias current further to get Class B and they will always have zero crossing distortion.
Your comment here takes the form of a logical 'If then' statement; 'so' being the 'if' and 'and' being the 'then'.
The logical failure is the assumption that somehow because some AB amps have this problem (which I pointed out earlier is either a setup or design flaw and isn't inherent to class AB) then all class B amps will have a zero crossing problem, despite the fact I showed two that do not.
What you are not taking into account is that a designer of a class B amp might have a solution to prevent crossover distortion. Your assumption seems to be that such solutions don't exist, despite examples that belie your position.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: your statement still isn't logical. - Ralph 02/17/2509:04:29 02/17/25 (55)
- RE: your statement still isn't logical. - morricab 08:58:43 02/18/25 (52)
- FWIW, something you may not know - Ralph 09:48:44 02/27/25 (4)
- Interesting - Tre' 12:44:37 03/9/25 (3)
- By this metric, all solid state amps are class A. - Ralph 09:52:24 03/10/25 (2)
- RE: By this metric, all solid state amps are class A. - Tre' 10:12:53 03/10/25 (1)
- RE: By this metric, all solid state amps are class A. - Ralph 10:24:42 03/10/25 (0)
- Apparently you've not been reading my posts. - Ralph 09:23:57 02/18/25 (46)
- RE: Apparently you've not been reading my posts. - morricab 07:30:36 02/24/25 (8)
- So who are you going to believe? - Ralph 08:16:42 02/24/25 (7)
- RE: So who are you going to believe? - morricab 08:23:38 02/24/25 (6)
- RE: So who are you going to believe? - morricab 03:15:56 02/26/25 (0)
- You gotta try harder than that- hearsay isn't evidence. nt - Ralph 08:39:12 02/24/25 (4)
- RE: You gotta try harder than that- hearsay isn't evidence. nt - morricab 03:17:42 02/26/25 (3)
- If you have the experience it would be first hand. - Ralph 09:48:24 02/26/25 (2)
- RE: If you have the experience it would be first hand. - morricab 00:53:52 03/3/25 (1)
- Res ipsa loquitur nt - Ralph 10:35:24 03/3/25 (0)
- RE: Apparently you've not been reading my posts. - morricab 07:28:04 02/24/25 (21)
- Actually no cold water - yet. - Ralph 08:37:27 02/24/25 (20)
- RE: Actually no cold water - yet. - morricab 03:00:06 02/26/25 (19)
- Apparently you've not been reading my posts. no speculation nt - Ralph 09:31:25 02/26/25 (18)
- RE: Apparently you've not been reading my posts. no speculation nt - morricab 00:58:01 03/3/25 (17)
- When you use name calling that is abusive on most websites. - Ralph 10:34:05 03/3/25 (16)
- RE: When you use name calling that is abusive on most websites. - morricab 00:09:33 03/4/25 (15)
- RE: When you use name calling that is abusive on most websites. - Ralph 08:58:48 03/4/25 (14)
- RE: When you use name calling that is abusive on most websites. - morricab 01:49:45 03/5/25 (5)
- When you attack the patent - Ralph 09:43:55 03/7/25 (4)
- RE: When you attack the patent - morricab 11:49:45 03/7/25 (3)
- Rolleyes... again, how would you like those results? - Ralph 09:59:31 03/10/25 (2)
- RE: Rolleyes... again, how would you like those results? - morricab 10:47:17 03/10/25 (1)
- Data posted at link. - Ralph 10:54:50 03/10/25 (0)
- RE: When you use name calling that is abusive on most websites. - morricab 01:37:00 03/5/25 (7)
- Please do not gaslight me. - Ralph 10:14:38 03/5/25 (6)
- RE: Please do not gaslight me. - morricab 07:08:49 03/7/25 (5)
- more gaslighting. - Ralph 08:27:44 03/7/25 (4)
- If you don't believe me then here is what Doug Self says - morricab 13:07:45 03/7/25 (2)
- :) clearly not a blameless amp - Ralph 10:06:05 03/10/25 (1)
- RE: :) clearly not a blameless amp - morricab 10:50:44 03/10/25 (0)
- RE: more gaslighting. - morricab 11:41:55 03/7/25 (0)
- RE: Apparently you've not been reading my posts. - morricab 04:34:35 02/24/25 (14)
- Since you have a burr under your saddle - Ralph 08:46:40 02/24/25 (13)
- RE: Since you have a burr under your saddle - morricab 03:12:23 02/26/25 (12)
- RE: Since you still have a burr under your saddle - Ralph 09:46:32 02/26/25 (11)
- RE: Since you still have a burr under your saddle - morricab 01:18:31 03/3/25 (10)
- RE: Since you still have a burr under your saddle - Ralph 10:28:52 03/3/25 (8)
- RE: Since you still have a burr under your saddle - morricab 00:15:22 03/4/25 (7)
- You are objuscating. - Ralph 09:12:51 03/4/25 (6)
- RE: You are objuscating. - morricab 01:41:27 03/5/25 (5)
- Apparently you're not interested in the truth. - Ralph 10:16:31 03/5/25 (4)
- RE: Apparently you're not interested in the truth. - morricab 11:52:33 03/7/25 (3)
- Again, for the 5th time now, what will you consider to be data? - Ralph 10:07:08 03/10/25 (2)
- RE: Again, for the 5th time now, what will you consider to be data? - morricab 10:51:49 03/10/25 (1)
- Data posted at link. - Ralph 10:58:02 03/10/25 (0)
- RE: Since you still have a burr under your saddle - morricab 01:22:59 03/3/25 (0)
- Does Quasi Complementary... - Cougar 10:42:32 02/17/25 (1)
- Too many variables to say - Ralph 13:25:36 02/17/25 (0)