![]() |
Amp/Preamp Asylum Looking for a new Amp or Preamp? If you're after tubes, post over here. |
|
I run a pair of class D monoblocks that drive a pair of Magnepan 1.7is. The current draw is minimal, based on the fact that my power regenerator
(max output 300w) has NEVER gone into shutdown mode.
Now let us consider a pair of 300/600 watt (8/4 ohm) output class AB amps.
The ABs pull about 6 times the power at idle as the D; the ABs basically require their own dedicated circuit, based on their current draw at full output; the Ds can coexist comfortably on the same 15 amp circuit as the rest of the gear in you system. The ABs cost 2x to 3x the Ds.
My question is: why would you prefer class AB amps over class D amps? I know, I know, you might say that the ABs sound marginally better. The ABs
run much hotter, require their own dedicated electrical circuit, cost a lot more to purchase, require 3 men and a healthy boy to move, have huge heat sinks, and cost a bundle to ship.
I do not understand running class AB amps in this day and age. Maybe someone out there can enlighten me as to the supposed benefits of class AB amps.
Lack of skill dictates economy of style. - Joey Ramone
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - Class D vs. class AB amps - Mike K 07:52:01 08/15/23 (54)
- Don't forget ADH Class - Freo-1 15:24:07 08/17/23 (14)
- ADH is not a Class. It's marketing speak... - AbeCollins 05:27:16 08/18/23 (13)
- Wrong - Freo-1 05:40:11 08/18/23 (12)
- RE: Wrong - pictureguy 22:16:18 08/23/23 (1)
- Well, It's not Class AB per se then - Freo-1 12:38:59 08/24/23 (0)
- Amplifier Classes - AbeCollins 11:30:53 08/18/23 (1)
- Why not call it a Class A/D amp? - Freo-1 12:20:35 08/18/23 (0)
- " It's not Class D." - E-Stat 08:05:45 08/18/23 (7)
- They don't differ at all. They acknowledge it's a unique class - Freo-1 08:30:14 08/18/23 (6)
- Contrary to the manufacturer's own assertions... - E-Stat 08:39:06 08/18/23 (5)
- Threshold Stasis Amps are great! - Freo-1 08:48:54 08/18/23 (4)
- RE: Threshold Stasis Amps are great! - E-Stat 10:13:54 08/18/23 (3)
- Semantics - Freo-1 10:33:33 08/18/23 (2)
- "Assume they are trying to inform the public that the topology is unique." - E-Stat 11:44:26 08/19/23 (1)
- Eh Bien - Freo-1 11:54:17 08/19/23 (0)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - KanedaK 20:53:20 08/16/23 (0)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - boogyman 13:18:43 08/16/23 (3)
- What is your electric rate? - mlsstl 14:21:08 08/16/23 (2)
- RE: What is your electric rate? - boogyman 15:58:07 08/16/23 (0)
- RE: What is your electric rate? - Tre' 15:43:15 08/16/23 (0)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - cawson@onetel.com 11:37:18 08/16/23 (8)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - Chuck 04:47:30 08/17/23 (2)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - cawson@onetel.com 06:26:00 08/17/23 (1)
- thank you! interesting (nt) - Chuck 10:53:52 08/17/23 (0)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - AbeCollins 13:06:29 08/16/23 (4)
- Compared to Benchmark? - jimbill 09:22:34 08/17/23 (2)
- Tough call. - AbeCollins 11:59:50 08/17/23 (1)
- RE: Tough call. - G Squared 12:55:04 08/17/23 (0)
- I had an X150.5 just before my VTV Purifi - Feanor 04:24:22 08/17/23 (0)
- Generalizations rarely work - G Squared 17:58:48 08/15/23 (3)
- "All generalizations are false - including this one." ;) (nt) - mhardy6647 05:20:51 08/16/23 (2)
- "Everything I say is a Lie." Capt Kirk. Should work against A.I. too.nt - oldmkvi 10:28:30 08/16/23 (1)
- I believe he borrowed that from Epimenides (the Cretan) - mhardy6647 17:29:01 08/16/23 (0)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - John Elison 14:59:26 08/15/23 (0)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - Ozzy 11:04:41 08/15/23 (1)
- Well stated. - Freo-1 11:14:56 08/15/23 (0)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - AbeCollins 08:06:37 08/15/23 (6)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - morricab 01:55:05 08/16/23 (5)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - John Elison 02:06:35 08/16/23 (4)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - morricab 04:53:25 08/16/23 (3)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - AbeCollins 12:54:13 08/16/23 (2)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - morricab 02:44:25 08/18/23 (1)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - AbeCollins 11:44:11 08/18/23 (0)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - Freo-1 08:01:42 08/15/23 (4)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - AbeCollins 08:13:45 08/15/23 (3)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - morricab 01:49:05 08/16/23 (2)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - AbeCollins 12:47:21 08/16/23 (1)
- RE: Class D vs. class AB amps - morricab 02:38:37 08/18/23 (0)
- Maybe for the same sort of reason some prefer tube amps - Feanor 08:01:18 08/15/23 (5)
- RE: Maybe for the same sort of reason some prefer tube amps - morricab 01:42:29 08/16/23 (2)
- Morri, why not just be easier to admit you like tube distortion? - Feanor 05:06:06 08/16/23 (1)
- RE: Morri, why not just be easier to admit you like tube distortion? - morricab 05:43:02 08/16/23 (0)
- RE: Maybe for the same sort of reason some prefer tube amps - Ozzy 11:06:51 08/15/23 (1)
- RE: Maybe for the same sort of reason some prefer tube amps - hahax@verizon.net 21:15:17 08/15/23 (0)