In Reply to: That's too bad. No problem distinguishing 320 Kbps MP3 from CD on my system. posted by carcass93 on November 29, 2012 at 08:14:04:
"For me, about 10 seconds into a track that has plentiful HF content, cymbals and the like, is more than sufficient to tell the two apart reliably."Ok carcass, bear, Tony, J.Mac, Dynobot...
Lets make a simple test out of this. If you guys can identify a song segment that has HF content or anything you think MP3 sucks at encoding, I'll happily create a couple WAV files to see if people can A-B a well encoded MP3.
This could be educational and enjoyable! I'd love to see if there is a correlation with equipment quality as well.
-------
Archimago's Musings: A 'more objective' audiophile blog.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- LETS MAKE AN A-B TEST OUT OF THIS... - Archimago 12/2/1210:41:50 12/2/12 (20)
- No takers!? RE: LETS MAKE AN A-B TEST OUT OF THIS... - Archimago 13:48:23 12/3/12 (19)
- You would have to buy a CD(s), if I understand you correctly. - carcass93 15:33:29 12/3/12 (18)
- The procedure... RE: You would have to buy a CD(s), if I understand you correctly. - Archimago 15:47:59 12/3/12 (17)
- That's fine with me, but you positively do not have the CDs I'm going to recommend. - carcass93 11:50:17 12/4/12 (2)
- RE: That's fine with me, but you positively do not have the CDs I'm going to recommend. - Archimago 20:26:17 12/9/12 (0)
- RE: That's fine with me, but you positively do not have the CDs I'm going to recommend. - Archimago 08:25:42 12/7/12 (0)
- RE: The procedure... RE: You would have to buy a CD(s), if I understand you correctly. - Tony Lauck 05:56:37 12/4/12 (13)
- Adversarial, really? RE: The procedure... RE: You would have to buy a CD(s), if I understand you correctly. - Archimago 08:00:53 12/4/12 (12)
- RE: Adversarial, really? RE: The procedure... RE: You would have to buy a CD(s), if I understand you correctly. - Tony Lauck 09:02:44 12/4/12 (11)
- RE: Adversarial, really? RE: The procedure... RE: You would have to buy a CD(s), if I understand you correctly. - Archimago 10:24:46 12/7/12 (5)
- RE: Adversarial, really? RE: The procedure... RE: You would have to buy a CD(s), if I understand you correctly. - Tony Lauck 10:38:33 12/7/12 (4)
- RE: Adversarial, really? RE: The procedure... RE: You would have to buy a CD(s), if I understand you correctly. - Archimago 15:13:01 12/7/12 (1)
- RE: Adversarial, really? RE: The procedure... RE: You would have to buy a CD(s), if I understand you correctly. - Tony Lauck 16:26:57 12/7/12 (0)
- RE: Adversarial, really? RE: The procedure... RE: You would have to buy a CD(s), if I understand you correctly. - Old Listener 11:54:24 12/7/12 (1)
- RE: Adversarial, really? RE: The procedure... RE: You would have to buy a CD(s), if I understand you correctly. - Tony Lauck 12:02:50 12/7/12 (0)
- RE: Adversarial, really? RE: The procedure... RE: You would have to buy a CD(s), if I understand you correctly. - Ryelands 10:28:32 12/4/12 (4)
- RE: Adversarial, really? RE: The procedure... RE: You would have to buy a CD(s), if I understand you correctly. - Archimago 10:16:22 12/7/12 (0)
- RE: Adversarial, really? RE: The procedure... RE: You would have to buy a CD(s), if I understand you correctly. - Tony Lauck 11:46:11 12/4/12 (2)
- With CDeX, it's as simple as copying the DLL into a particular folder. - carcass93 12:49:42 12/4/12 (0)
- It's the charm that does it . . . - Ryelands 12:29:48 12/4/12 (0)