In Reply to: Accuracy is a fiction....... posted by viridian on June 18, 2013 at 12:17:32:
No accuracy, or rather accurate, is a comparative adjective when used among audiophiles meaning that what we're listening to sounds most like what we hear in the concert hall or jazz club. Measurements are not part of that conversation. What is most accurate to each of us is what sounds to us most like the real thing. And yes, of course, this is subjective but the reference that we can all go and hear in the hall, is not. So yes, I'm on that side of the argument rather than the whatever makes us happy side, which defends itself with defeatist solipsism.
To repeat myself, I do not believe there is yet a system that is persuasively 'accurate' in capturing all aspects of live sound. I have heard several that can get several of them wonderfully well.. So I see us as choosing among them, based on which aspects strike us as most important.
And, as I say, I see us always vulnerable to having our sense of what's important challenged and even altered when faced by a system that captures different aspects of musical reality brilliantly.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- RE: Accuracy is a fiction....... - Bob Neill 06/18/1312:44:37 06/18/13 (22)
- So accuracy is subjective, but not a fiction. Pretty hard to argue with that one. nt - viridian 12:58:13 06/18/13 (16)
- Mincing Words - Bob Neill 14:02:12 06/18/13 (15)
- I respectfully disagree........ - viridian 14:14:29 06/18/13 (14)
- A truly excellent point: one that the OP is missing - Sordidman 16:05:54 06/18/13 (5)
- Huh? - E-Stat 06:03:51 06/19/13 (4)
- sorry - Sordidman 09:42:06 06/19/13 (3)
- RE: sorry - E-Stat 10:01:32 06/19/13 (2)
- I think that I understand you better: thanks. - Sordidman 10:52:25 06/19/13 (1)
- Just different perspectives - E-Stat 11:46:00 06/19/13 (0)
- RE: I respectfully disagree........ - Tre' 15:44:51 06/18/13 (7)
- "This is not high fidelity" - Sordidman 16:12:41 06/18/13 (6)
- SOmetimes it is, though ... - Bromo33333 18:18:57 06/18/13 (0)
- RE: "This is not high fidelity" - Tre' 18:08:53 06/18/13 (4)
- RE: "This is not high fidelity" - E-Stat 12:06:34 06/19/13 (2)
- Wow, - Windham Hill? an amazing historical reference - Sordidman 12:13:14 06/19/13 (1)
- Historical reference? - E-Stat 13:53:44 06/19/13 (0)
- RE: "This is not high fidelity" - Sordidman 10:36:00 06/19/13 (0)
- RE: Accuracy is a fiction....... - Frihed89 12:53:27 06/18/13 (4)
- Illusions and fictions or lies are not real. -nt - soulfood 15:53:59 06/18/13 (3)
- The ultimate goal is joy, not "the truth" - Frihed89 21:57:32 06/18/13 (2)
- Nice: FWIW, - I agree: about enhancing the experience - Sordidman 10:59:13 06/19/13 (0)
- The ultimate goal is joy, not "the truth"??? - soulfood 05:23:29 06/19/13 (0)