In a recent email conversation with Frihed89 about his latest adventures on the way to “getting it right,” (his words), I dropped the gratuitous remark, “Getting it right would be great if 'right' would stand still!” and now I can’t get the remark out of my head.
Because, at least so far, any one system can only get aspects of what ‘live’ music sounds like, we tend to move around among systems seduced by what aspect seems most important to us at the time. And because beauty, clarity, physicality, fullness, robustness, ease, subtety all have their appeal -- all are ‘right’ about an aspect of ‘live’ music, if we get out and around and hear systems that get one or two of these aspects ‘right,’ we find that rightness does indeed appear to be moving around. Even those of us who think we know which aspects of live music are most important to us can get into trouble when we hear a system that gets something we didn’t think mattered that much to us perfectly right.
Any system that gets some aspect(s) of music wonderfully right can have become persuasive if we live with it long enough. This is what can make the experience of hearing something that gets other, different things right so confounding. At first, the new thing sounds wrong, sometimes utterly wrong. If we run away at that point, we’re safe. But if we stay around long enough, in many cases the new thing will begin to reprogram our attachment to what had been our ‘reference,’ changing our sense of what is most important about live music. And then, if we’re patient enough -- if we have some good reason for remaining patient -- we may well find that rightness has moved and that we have new reference.
I apologize to those of you to whom this is obvious. It sounds obvious spelled out this way but the experience has always been quite a shock to me.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - Rightness in Motion - Bob Neill 08:41:50 06/18/13 (62)
- RE: The moving target is... - BigguyinATL 11:22:44 06/20/13 (0)
- Great post, Bob! (nt) - jfz 09:22:44 06/19/13 (2)
- RE: Great post, Bob! (nt) - Bob Neill 12:18:33 06/19/13 (1)
- The Unsettled Man - R Browne 18:21:53 06/19/13 (0)
- I attend at least one live acoustic music event each week - Timbo in Oz 01:28:17 06/19/13 (0)
- Hey that would make a great song title..... - JayG 22:21:27 06/18/13 (1)
- Even better as a moral/religious theme for racecar drivers.. nt - Elizabeth 08:19:10 06/19/13 (0)
- "Live" is the wrong goal - 4season 21:39:52 06/18/13 (4)
- RE: "Live" is the wrong goal - Todd Krieger 08:12:08 06/19/13 (3)
- Just measure it - 4season 14:02:11 06/19/13 (2)
- RE: Just measure it - Todd Krieger 14:42:31 06/19/13 (1)
- RE: Just measure it - 4season 15:56:49 06/19/13 (0)
- The aspiration to swim... - Shep 16:14:53 06/18/13 (2)
- RE: The aspiration to swim... - Renman 16:44:36 06/18/13 (1)
- RE: The aspiration to swim... - Shep 04:50:32 06/19/13 (0)
- I frequent live music a bit and listen to my rig a bit - G Squared 13:43:45 06/18/13 (0)
- What a Crock. - Inmate51 10:33:30 06/18/13 (4)
- RE: What a Crock. - Todd Krieger 15:37:46 06/18/13 (0)
- RE: What a Crock. - Bob Neill 10:51:54 06/18/13 (2)
- RE: What a Crock. - Inmate51 13:46:44 06/18/13 (1)
- RE: What a Crock. - Bob Neill 14:19:24 06/18/13 (0)
- I reject live music as some type of ideal......... - viridian 09:23:11 06/18/13 (36)
- Disagree..... Because......... - Todd Krieger 15:10:55 06/18/13 (0)
- RE: I reject live music as some type of ideal......... - Bob Neill 11:52:23 06/18/13 (25)
- Accuracy is a fiction....... - viridian 12:17:32 06/18/13 (24)
- The one... - mkuller 15:49:07 06/18/13 (0)
- RE: Accuracy is a fiction....... - Bob Neill 12:44:37 06/18/13 (22)
- So accuracy is subjective, but not a fiction. Pretty hard to argue with that one. nt - viridian 12:58:13 06/18/13 (16)
- Mincing Words - Bob Neill 14:02:12 06/18/13 (15)
- I respectfully disagree........ - viridian 14:14:29 06/18/13 (14)
- A truly excellent point: one that the OP is missing - Sordidman 16:05:54 06/18/13 (5)
- Huh? - E-Stat 06:03:51 06/19/13 (4)
- sorry - Sordidman 09:42:06 06/19/13 (3)
- RE: sorry - E-Stat 10:01:32 06/19/13 (2)
- I think that I understand you better: thanks. - Sordidman 10:52:25 06/19/13 (1)
- Just different perspectives - E-Stat 11:46:00 06/19/13 (0)
- RE: I respectfully disagree........ - Tre' 15:44:51 06/18/13 (7)
- "This is not high fidelity" - Sordidman 16:12:41 06/18/13 (6)
- SOmetimes it is, though ... - Bromo33333 18:18:57 06/18/13 (0)
- RE: "This is not high fidelity" - Tre' 18:08:53 06/18/13 (4)
- RE: "This is not high fidelity" - E-Stat 12:06:34 06/19/13 (2)
- Wow, - Windham Hill? an amazing historical reference - Sordidman 12:13:14 06/19/13 (1)
- Historical reference? - E-Stat 13:53:44 06/19/13 (0)
- RE: "This is not high fidelity" - Sordidman 10:36:00 06/19/13 (0)
- RE: Accuracy is a fiction....... - Frihed89 12:53:27 06/18/13 (4)
- Illusions and fictions or lies are not real. -nt - soulfood 15:53:59 06/18/13 (3)
- The ultimate goal is joy, not "the truth" - Frihed89 21:57:32 06/18/13 (2)
- Nice: FWIW, - I agree: about enhancing the experience - Sordidman 10:59:13 06/19/13 (0)
- The ultimate goal is joy, not "the truth"??? - soulfood 05:23:29 06/19/13 (0)
- I reject music altogether. I only listen to Pink Noise. - oldmkvi 11:11:22 06/18/13 (3)
- Better than Pink Floyd nt - Ktem 18:20:52 06/18/13 (2)
- Better than Frijid Pink (does that date me?)nt - viridian 07:51:23 06/19/13 (1)
- "Better than Everything, except..." Bob Dourough. - oldmkvi 11:56:00 06/19/13 (0)
- For most pop/rock music venues, I agree! - E-Stat 11:07:55 06/18/13 (1)
- I'll second that. - Tre' 18:41:19 06/18/13 (0)
- True, but... - mkuller 09:59:26 06/18/13 (0)
- I cansee your point.. but SOME live music can be a guide to what our setups could sound like - Elizabeth 09:36:20 06/18/13 (1)
- RE: I cansee your point.. but SOME live music can be a guide to what our setups could sound like - Tre' 18:44:54 06/18/13 (0)
- RE: Rightness in Motion - JayG 09:06:37 06/18/13 (0)
- RE: Rightness in Motion - Todd Krieger 09:05:18 06/18/13 (2)
- " But things will never become perfect.... Maybe closer and closer, but never totally there." - Bob Neill 10:11:21 06/18/13 (1)
- I Think We're Stating the Same Thing............. - Todd Krieger 14:55:11 06/18/13 (0)