|
Music Lane: It's that time again. The Messiah. by edta It's all about the music, dude! Sit down, relax and listen to some tunes. |
For Sale Ads |
67.140.87.21
Ok, I've had a few of the recommended versions, viz., Davis and Beecham. Along comes another on two Linn hybrid SACDs, and it's the Dublin version by Butts and the Dunedin.
If nothing else, the sound is fantastic. You can understand every word. Ok, the chorus is only 12 and includes the soloists. Very fine singing and the orchestral work is very good on period instruments in a lighter arrangement than the traditional.
Do I like it best of all I've heard? I think so. Whatever the judgment, this is a worthwhile version of this masterpiece in exceptional sound and I'm just listening to the CD layer on my living room system, my SACD system has a broken amp at this time. Could it get any better on SACD?
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - It's that time again. The Messiah. - edta 17:30:18 11/29/07 ( 40)
- Forgive, please, my compulsive pedantry - John Marks 19:05:51 11/29/07 ( 39)
- Interesting discussion - Larry I 07:00:15 12/3/07 ( 4)
- "Nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition"--bizarre and far-afield - John Marks 13:23:45 12/3/07 ( 3)
- RE: "Nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition"--bizarre and far-afield - Pat D 20:31:34 12/7/07 ( 0)
- Hmmmm... I pick the road to self-determination - gd 06:20:52 12/4/07 ( 0)
- My favorite line too. - Larry I 14:30:06 12/3/07 ( 0)
RE: Meanwhile, back at the Robert Shaw - Square Peg 08:30:32 12/1/07 ( 1)
- Klemperer was great. - Pat D 18:52:01 12/1/07 ( 0)
You want "anti-semitic"? Try Handel's suppressed oratorio, "For Fear of the Jews". - clarkjohnsen 07:10:52 12/1/07 ( 2)
- direct nt source - docw 10:57:00 12/1/07 ( 1)
- But isn't it always the LEADERS who give the PAWNS a bad name? nt - clarkjohnsen 22:57:12 12/1/07 ( 0)
I just read in English it's "Messiah" not "The M"--the only comment is re... - docw 11:07:20 11/30/07 ( 0)
BTW, not true in German or French - TGR 07:46:42 11/30/07 ( 3)
- Please read the author's summary I posted below - John Marks 11:56:00 11/30/07 ( 2)
- The confederate battle flag - TGR 12:31:03 11/30/07 ( 1)
- Analogy - John Marks 12:58:22 11/30/07 ( 0)
Well, it does appear compulsive... - EBerlin 05:13:09 11/30/07 ( 0)
Huh........? Ok.......... - edta 05:10:40 11/30/07 ( 1)
- moe--shy--acchhh (equal stress on all syllables) - John Marks 07:50:14 11/30/07 ( 0)
The pedantry is OK. But - TGR 21:14:17 11/29/07 ( 20)
- Thanks for the comments re Dublin which directly relate to my post. - edta 17:26:49 11/30/07 ( 0)
I decline to grant you rule by fiat, let's see who says what - John Marks 08:25:27 11/30/07 ( 6)
- Well, "nations" does appear to be the correct translation - Pat D 13:28:27 12/2/07 ( 0)
"Divine retribution on Judaism ." Hmmm... Let's see... - clarkjohnsen 07:34:33 12/1/07 ( 0)
"The faith-busting wiles of deists and Jews " - Feanor 17:56:32 11/30/07 ( 0)
Reading this reminds me of - TGR 10:17:54 11/30/07 ( 0)
RE: I decline to grant you rule by fiat, let's see who says what - Brian Cheney 09:52:10 11/30/07 ( 1)
- Indeed. The spirit of Scrooge emerges each year. - edta 17:48:08 11/30/07 ( 0)
RE: The pedantry is OK. But - edta 05:13:47 11/30/07 ( 0)
Lots of older books claim - kavakidd 21:39:13 11/29/07 ( 10)
- Yeah, let's bring back blacklisting. - Rick W 11:13:29 11/30/07 ( 6)
- Boy - Rick - you're reading an awful lot into - kavakidd 11:45:16 11/30/07 ( 5)
- The US faces a far, far greater threat today ... - Feanor 12:56:11 12/3/07 ( 0)
- It never ceases to amaze me, how the loudest yappers against McCarthy... - clarkjohnsen 07:44:46 12/1/07 ( 1)
- Separate? - Rick W 08:45:55 12/1/07 ( 0)
- Ok, Kava. Sorry if I read too much into it, but..... - Rick W 16:10:02 11/30/07 ( 1)
- Ike and Joe - TGR 16:43:43 11/30/07 ( 0)
RE: Lots of older books claim - TGR 07:49:41 11/30/07 ( 1)
- RE: Lots of older books claim - kavakidd 08:58:55 11/30/07 ( 0)
A big "Yep" on the Venona. [nt] - Charlie F. 07:16:27 11/30/07 ( 0)